The Agora Almanac

Section 05 / Timeline / Month

April 2019

Members of The Philosophy Forum wrote 12,366 posts in April 2019: 228 opening posts and 12,138 comments, running to about 1.1 million words. 239 members posted, 71 of them for the first time.

By number of posts it ranks 13th of the archive's 125 months. 230 threads were opened, and 304 threads received at least one comment.

The most active thread was Why do atheists ask for evidence of God, when there is clearly no such evidence?, with 569 comments in the month.

12,366
Posts
13th of 125 months
239
Members posting
71 for the first time
230
Threads opened
304 threads active
1.1 million
Words written
88 per post
638
Posts on the busiest day
21 April 2019

Fig. 1

Posts per day in April 2019

Days are UTC. The busiest was 21 April 2019, with 638 posts, 219 of them in What Are The Chances of Life After Death?.

0 400 800 1 8 15 22 29

Fig. 2

Most active threads

Comments posted during April 2019, whenever the thread was opened.

  1. 1Why do atheists ask for evidence of God, when there is clearly no such evidence?569
  2. 2Morality546
  3. 3Subject and object500
  4. 4Why are most people unwilling to admit that they don't know if God does or does not exist?440
  5. 5The source of morals412
  6. 6Could God be Non-Material?310
  7. 7Should A Men's Rights Movement Exist?292
  8. 8What Are The Chances of Life After Death?287
  9. 9Is it immoral to do illegal drugs?284
  10. 10Philosophical Investigations, reading it together.269
  11. 11There Are No Facts. Only Opinions. .262
  12. 12Philosopher Roger Scruton Has Been Sacked for Islamophobia and Antisemitism230
  13. 13The Shoutbox222
  14. 14Quantum experiment undermines the notion of objective reality222
  15. 15The West's Moral Superiority To Islam209

Fig. 3

Most active members

Posts written during April 2019.

  1. 1S1,150
  2. 2Devans99655
  3. 3Terrapin Station616
  4. 4Merkwurdichliebe500
  5. 5Shawn457
  6. 6Frank Apisa441
  7. 7whollyrolling354
  8. 8I like sushi309
  9. 9Artemis307
  10. 10Janus303
  11. 11Banno279
  12. 12Pattern-chaser192
  13. 13christian2017189
  14. 14Isaac183
  15. 15YuZhonglu182

Fig. 4

The words of April 2019

Tracked words used unusually often this month compared with the archive as a whole: used by at least five members in the month, with no one member supplying more than 35% of the uses. Larger means more distinctive; the small figure is the number of uses.

Fig. 5

230 threads opened in April 2019

230 listed

Every thread started this month, with the comments it went on to draw by the end of the archive.

The source of morals hachit 17 Apr 2019 1,325 35
Philosopher Roger Scruton Has Been Sacked for Islamophobia and Antisemitism Jamal 11 Apr 2019 706 41
Why do atheists ask for evidence of God, when there is clearly no such evidence? Maureen 25 Apr 2019 652 37
Subject and object Banno 13 Apr 2019 651 37
Why are most people unwilling to admit that they don't know if God does or does not exist? Maureen 7 Apr 2019 440 31
The Liar Paradox - Is it even a valid statement? Devans99 13 Apr 2019 349 22
We're conscious beings. Why? Unseen 17 Apr 2019 339 41
Assange I like sushi 17 Apr 2019 326 35
Could God be Non-Material? Devans99 14 Apr 2019 310 14
Is it self-contradictory to state 'there is no objective truth'? curiousnewbie 7 Apr 2019 295 31
Should A Men's Rights Movement Exist? Not Steve 16 Apr 2019 292 27
What Are The Chances of Life After Death? Devans99 21 Apr 2019 287 14
There Are No Facts. Only Opinions. . YuZhonglu 13 Apr 2019 262 19
Does "spirit" exist? If so, what is it? 0 thru 9 9 Apr 2019 238 31
The West's Moral Superiority To Islam Ilya B Shambat 8 Apr 2019 209 31
Are causeless effects possible? Pattern-chaser 29 Apr 2019 194 27
Houses are Turning Into Flowers Streetlight 16 Apr 2019 187 22
Should This Thread Be Considered? S 27 Apr 2019 182 9
Space Is Expanding So It Can't Be Infinite? Devans99 4 Apr 2019 170 17
Beyond The God Debate Jake 26 Apr 2019 166 20
Why Free Will can never be understood TheMadFool 17 Apr 2019 164 16
Killing a Billion I like sushi 3 Apr 2019 140 20
Are you happy to know you will die? Gnostic Christian Bishop 8 Apr 2019 140 17
Invasion of Privacy removedmembershiptx 18 Apr 2019 133 17
Do we need metaphysics? frank 29 Apr 2019 128 14
What can't you philosophize about? Wheatley 10 Apr 2019 113 19
Marijuana and Philosophy Grre 24 Apr 2019 113 24
Multitasking YuZhonglu 21 Apr 2019 107 16
Why has post-modernism proven to be popular in literature departments but not in philosophy? philosophy 27 Apr 2019 103 14
A summary of today lucafrei 11 Apr 2019 101 15
On Psychologizing Shawn 8 Apr 2019 96 10
'Why Is There Something Rather Than Nothing?' - 'No Reason' Devans99 4 Apr 2019 92 27
Do Christians have Stockholm syndrome where one loves his abuser? Gnostic Christian Bishop 4 Apr 2019 88 13
When Zizek and Peterson Argued About Marxism and Capitalism, Were They Debating the Same Concepts? YuZhonglu 23 Apr 2019 83 16
Anti-modernity rathsel 24 Apr 2019 80 15
Mind or body? Or both? Anirudh Sharma 23 Apr 2019 77 25
Why do some members leave while others stay? Shawn 1 Apr 2019 74 26
Ignore list browser extension SophistiCat 28 Apr 2019 72 29
The Problem of "-ism" on Forums I like sushi 8 Apr 2019 71 16
An Alternative Trolley Problem I like sushi 4 Apr 2019 70 11
Do you want to be happy? Shawn 6 Apr 2019 65 14
My biggest problem with discussions about consciousness khaled 30 Apr 2019 65 18
The Length Of Now Devans99 17 Apr 2019 63 10
The libertarian-ism dilemma. Shawn 4 Apr 2019 62 12
Why I choose subscribe to Feminism or Men's Rights Movement Anaxagoras 23 Apr 2019 62 15
The Traditional Attributes Of God Devans99 26 Apr 2019 61 5
Is Kripke's theory of reference consistent with Wittgenstein's? Shawn 11 Apr 2019 60 10
A model of suffering leo 29 Apr 2019 60 13
Is philosophy for everyone or who needs it? Shawn 7 Apr 2019 58 8
Nothingness vs. Experience schopenhauer1 21 Apr 2019 55 11
Was There A First Cause? Reviewing The Five Ways Devans99 11 Apr 2019 54 8
Does Jesus/Yahweh love us or is he stalking us? Gnostic Christian Bishop 26 Apr 2019 54 11
On intentionality and more Shawn 9 Apr 2019 52 12
Who is the owner of this forum... Frank Apisa 8 Apr 2019 51 12
Has progress been made? How to measure it? Shawn 20 Apr 2019 51 12
Post Modernism Ricardoc 24 Apr 2019 50 16
Comedy, Taboo and "Boomer Culture" TogetherTurtle 5 Apr 2019 49 9
The interpretations of how Special Relativity works do not seem to be correct. MrCypress 10 Apr 2019 48 13
Is the Mind Informed by the Infinite? Anthony 8 Apr 2019 47 9
The end of the global internet Geo 30 Apr 2019 46 8
Theory on Why Religion/Spirituality Still Matters to People schopenhauer1 30 Apr 2019 44 12
How do/should we DO philosophy? Pattern-chaser 12 Apr 2019 41 9
Was Wittgenstein anti-philosophy? Shawn 7 Apr 2019 40 9
In Search of God Jacob-B 2 Apr 2019 38 9
An Epistemological Conundrum charles ferraro 9 Apr 2019 38 14
Do greedy capitalists do God's work? Ricardoc 27 Apr 2019 38 11
Cantor's Paradox Devans99 30 Apr 2019 38 8
On the photon Devans99 1 Apr 2019 37 8
Discussions About God. YuZhonglu 14 Apr 2019 35 11
The "Verificationist" Fallacy Daniel Cox 17 Apr 2019 35 9
On sex Shawn 17 Apr 2019 34 8
Do heroin addicts have free will? Wheatley 28 Apr 2019 33 11
To Be Is To Be The Value Of A Variable creativesoul 30 Apr 2019 33 8
The right to die Wheatley 15 Apr 2019 32 9
Tell us a story Wheatley 15 Apr 2019 32 7
sunknight fdrake 12 Apr 2019 31 9
Request undeletion of the "Psychobabble" thread? Shawn 21 Apr 2019 31 7
Why are you naturally inclined to philosophize? Edward 1 Apr 2019 30 20
Happiness not truth is a pathless land. Shawn 7 Apr 2019 30 9
What is your gripe with Psychology/Psychiatry? -Ask the Clinical Psychologist Anaxagoras 5 Apr 2019 28 9
If the universe is infinite JohnLocke 15 Apr 2019 28 9
Problem solving thread Wheatley 16 Apr 2019 28 8
Derrida, Deconstruction and Justice philosophy 23 Apr 2019 28 7
Untitled thread 5604 whollyrolling 13 Apr 2019 27 8
Communicating Effectively and with Purpose akourios 26 Apr 2019 26 6
What actually is ''Being'' for Heidegger? philosophy 26 Apr 2019 26 8
Is the lack of large ships produced by the pre-columbian americas due to low population? christian2017 7 Apr 2019 25 5
I think, therefore I am (a fictional character) Wheatley 19 Apr 2019 25 8
Does Marxism Actually Avoid the Problems of Exploitation Either? schopenhauer1 30 Apr 2019 25 7
The Hubris of Guilt ssu 2 Apr 2019 23 10
Human Condition lucafrei 11 Apr 2019 23 8
Are songs spatiotemporal? frank 20 Apr 2019 23 4
Jussie Smollett's hoax an act of terror? Roke 1 Apr 2019 22 10
Playing the idiot. Shawn 1 Apr 2019 22 6
Frege and objects/concepts marcolobo8 8 Apr 2019 22 9
Ecological Crisis; What Can Philosophy Do? Grre 14 Apr 2019 22 7
Is it natural to live without religion? Wheatley 20 Apr 2019 22 8
Silicon-based Natural Intelligence BrianW 30 Apr 2019 22 6
Fish Minds Project Grre 30 Apr 2019 22 9
Is Modern Entertainment Too Distracting? I like sushi 10 Apr 2019 21 7
Grammar or creativity? Tarun 10 Apr 2019 20 7
"philosophy" against "violence" Zekkari Mohamed 14 Apr 2019 20 11
Does philosophy cease to exist if a catastrophic event occurs? Anaxagoras 18 Apr 2019 20 5
Poincare Reoccurrence Theorem And Time Devans99 25 Apr 2019 20 7
Poor Reasoning redan 25 Apr 2019 20 11
How do we conclude what we "feel"? Edward 30 Apr 2019 20 9
What influence do we/should we have? yupamiralda 3 Apr 2019 19 8
On Wallowing Shawn 1 Apr 2019 18 6
The Cynic ethos Shawn 2 Apr 2019 18 4
Why my thread got deleted?! Nobody 19 Apr 2019 18 3
Psychology of a Stoic. Shawn 2 Apr 2019 17 4
The Bates method, Krishnamurti, Huxley and Glasses Changeling 29 Apr 2019 17 6
Religious Commitment: Decline of Religions Joe 12 Apr 2019 15 10
Propositions and the meaning of speech acts. fdrake 18 Apr 2019 15 8
Europeans And Jews: Trading Places Ilya B Shambat 3 Apr 2019 14 9
the book "Sapiens" by Noah Harrari and whether or not it has a valid argument christian2017 7 Apr 2019 14 6
I'm leaving this forum. Nobody 19 Apr 2019 14 11
The environmental situation a deleted account 20 Apr 2019 14 5
How does money cause things? Andrew4Handel 25 Apr 2019 14 9
Is a Job Interview a Good Example of Healthy Human Relationship? Anthony 8 Apr 2019 13 6
Thanks RoteichArmin 20 Apr 2019 13 8
Soft Elitism - Flaw of Democracy? I like sushi 1 Apr 2019 12 5
Killing humanity for selfish reasons Anaxagoras 3 Apr 2019 12 6
Interpretative Relevance Judaka 5 Apr 2019 12 6
Metaphysical Attitudes Survey Devans99 7 Apr 2019 12 10
Regret. Aidan buk 10 Apr 2019 12 9
The Artificial Intelligence Conundrum Devans99 24 Apr 2019 12 6
Unexpected Hanging Paradox Devans99 27 Apr 2019 12 7
Is Hedonism a bad philosophical stance to take in reaction to Existentialism? Jenn 8 Apr 2019 11 5
Can we live without anger? Wheatley 11 Apr 2019 11 10
'I Think Therefore I Am' - How Far Does It Lead? Devans99 19 Apr 2019 11 6
Are Do-Gooders Truly Arrogant? Ilya B Shambat 1 Apr 2019 10 9
Climate Change vs Population Growth Jacob-B 15 Apr 2019 10 6
Tao Te Ching Chapter 19 Tzeentch 3 Apr 2019 9 9
'Objective Standards' Shawn 3 Apr 2019 9 5
Can a tautology break the law of non-contradiction? Emils 4 Apr 2019 9 8
Marx And Reagan Ilya B Shambat 4 Apr 2019 9 6
A Philosophical Basis for Resolving the Israeli Palestinian Conflict rickyk95 8 Apr 2019 9 5
Why was my post deleted? sunknight 12 Apr 2019 9 2
Is the "Golden Rule" still applicable today? Anaxagoras 15 Apr 2019 9 3
How should you define yourself??? RBS 15 Apr 2019 9 6
A Paradox of Human Evolution or Advancement in The Sciences Athen Goh 23 Apr 2019 9 6
Kant, time and and the sense of duration Arthur Rupel 29 Apr 2019 9 4
Materialism/Physicalism i aM 7 Apr 2019 8 5
Values And Misuses Of Values Ilya B Shambat 19 Apr 2019 8 7
Bottle Imp Paradox Devans99 27 Apr 2019 8 6
Frege on Spinozas "God" marcolobo8 4 Apr 2019 7 7
Rednecks And Hippies Ilya B Shambat 6 Apr 2019 7 6
The military industrial complex and the economy christian2017 9 Apr 2019 7 6
What option do you have if you don't want to or can't deal with how difficult life is? Maureen 9 Apr 2019 7 7
Violent Criminals And Australian Manhood Ilya B Shambat 10 Apr 2019 7 5
Ethical conundrum: is obesity a form of self-harm? Jonmel 11 Apr 2019 7 7
Write a review of this forum Wheatley 13 Apr 2019 7 4
Causality and historical events curiousnewbie 18 Apr 2019 7 7
The Cult of the Mechanist orcestra 27 Apr 2019 7 5
A Natural (vs. Supernatural) Eternal Consciousness and Afterlife Bryon Ehlmann 6 Apr 2019 6 2
When your brain is too stimulated for sleep... Wheatley 10 Apr 2019 6 3
Why do some Christians compare the fear of death with a desire to live forever? Maureen 15 Apr 2019 6 5
"Money talks, bullsh*t walks" Ilya B Shambat 22 Apr 2019 6 3
What's the difference between solipsism and epistemological nihilism? camus-enthusiast 23 Apr 2019 6 6
Russia puts the hammer on criticism of the government frank 24 Apr 2019 6 3
Existentialism as Christian Moralism? Kind Glowing Seer 5 Apr 2019 5 5
What is more common in nature, regularities or irregularities? Hrvoje 7 Apr 2019 5 5
Refuting Political Correctness Ilya B Shambat 15 Apr 2019 5 4
A behavior that does not exist is not good. Proctor 15 Apr 2019 5 4
The Player Hell Ilya B Shambat 16 Apr 2019 5 5
On Intentionality Part II Shawn 18 Apr 2019 5 2
Will To Survive Vs. Will To Matter Ilya B Shambat 24 Apr 2019 5 5
Does Capitalism Still Function with Pleasure as Object? kudos 26 Apr 2019 5 5
New American Member usfan 27 Apr 2019 5 5
Ancient Egyptian vocal language Arthur Rupel 29 Apr 2019 5 5
Valued And Non-Valued Dualities Ilya B Shambat 30 Apr 2019 5 3
What is the proper definition of "invention"? Blackhole94 6 Apr 2019 4 2
Under the philosophy or religion of Gnosticism can a good christian be saved or have a good long... christian2017 6 Apr 2019 4 2
Overcoming S 9 Apr 2019 4 3
Untitled thread 5586 whollyrolling 11 Apr 2019 4 3
The Unsung Heroes Of Economics Ilya B Shambat 12 Apr 2019 4 3
On Storytelling Wheatley 13 Apr 2019 4 4
Is the writer an artist? Eros1982 14 Apr 2019 4 3
Mindless meandering Shamshir 27 Apr 2019 4 2
Please don't move my thread to the lounge Changeling 29 Apr 2019 4 3
Monism and the Problem of Change philosophy 29 Apr 2019 4 3
The pursuit of happiness Anonymys 2 Apr 2019 3 3
A liberalist solution to every ethical dilemma. Shawn 4 Apr 2019 3 2
Untitled thread 5551 whollyrolling 9 Apr 2019 3 3
The Villain S 9 Apr 2019 3 2
Error in Russell's "On Denoting" exemple? Nicholas Ferreira 10 Apr 2019 3 3
My latest post was deleted from the 'Philosophical Investigations, reading it together' discussion? Luke 12 Apr 2019 3 2
Are We Discussing the Same Subjects? YuZhonglu 17 Apr 2019 3 3
More about shadow and Other frank 19 Apr 2019 3 2
inventing a god (for aesthetic reasons) yupamiralda 20 Apr 2019 3 3
Are you interested in co-writing a philosophical book with me? rafael 21 Apr 2019 3 3
Derrida's take on Philosophy and Politics philosophy 24 Apr 2019 3 3
Glamour Of Evil And Banality Of Evil Ilya B Shambat 25 Apr 2019 3 3
"Nerds" And "Jocks" Ilya B Shambat 29 Apr 2019 3 3
Define "Need" olivia 10 Apr 2019 2 2
The 'Box': 'Apocalypse' I like sushi 23 Apr 2019 2 2
Can people be trained to avoid coincident fallacies? orcestra 27 Apr 2019 2 2
A Thought Experiment On Universals Troodon Roar 5 Apr 2019 1 1
What am I missing with Nietzsche's "Genealogy of morals"? lg18 6 Apr 2019 1 1
Professions And Ways Of Thinking Ilya B Shambat 7 Apr 2019 1 1
Importance of recognition Tarun 9 Apr 2019 1 1
kant: Which categories, which concepts in these three judgements? alexandre mateescu 12 Apr 2019 1 1
Evolution of purpose christian2017 14 Apr 2019 1 1
The Profit of The God Concept & The Misfortune of Righteousness I like sushi 15 Apr 2019 1 1
Technology: Heidegger vs Simondon Number2018 16 Apr 2019 1 1
"Posers," "Pretentions" And Cultural Growth Ilya B Shambat 16 Apr 2019 1 1
The idiomorphic structure of human thought kostas 17 Apr 2019 1 1
How do we consciously think before translating it into word or image thoughts? Thehoneyman 18 Apr 2019 1 1
Is a mental image a picture? VeganVernon 18 Apr 2019 1 1
Question about persistence in process metaphysics rachMiel 18 Apr 2019 1 1
Logic, Religion And Spiritual Experience Ilya B Shambat 21 Apr 2019 1 1
My research for college Helen G 21 Apr 2019 1 1
Context, music, psychology, meaning, mysticism reduced a deleted account 23 Apr 2019 1 1
Do the doctors deserve all that money? Eros1982 26 Apr 2019 1 1
A pattern of confusion Shamshir 26 Apr 2019 1 1
The Social Contract, reading discussion Dagny 28 Apr 2019 1 1
The threat of exponential escalation of violences, as a means for control. wax 3 Apr 2019 0 0
Looking for a piece regarding the relationship between subject and object (by Schopenhauer?) sascha 5 Apr 2019 0 0
How to get admitted to a PHD program in Philosophy? Eros1982 7 Apr 2019 0 0
Credibility And Money Ilya B Shambat 9 Apr 2019 0 0
Can you train yourself to instinctively ignore human instinct in lieu of happiness? How? Maureen 9 Apr 2019 0 0
Ramadan water-fasting and builders etc. wax 11 Apr 2019 0 0
A summary of today lucafrei 11 Apr 2019 0 0
Fabric Of The Cosmos Jake 11 Apr 2019 0 0
You in a Galaxy...... RBS 16 Apr 2019 0 0
Can we see depth? VeganVernon 18 Apr 2019 0 0
Attaining Material Success with Spiritual Success Despues Green 18 Apr 2019 0 0
Life for a Learning Tourist orcestra 27 Apr 2019 0 0
The Right to refuse a medical examination or procedure orcestra 27 Apr 2019 0 0

About these figures. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.