The Agora Almanac

Section 02 / Threads

Where the arguments happen

The longest thread, The Shoutbox, collected 62,422 comments from 356 members over 10 years and 4 months. It is an outlier among outliers: half of all threads drew fewer than 24 comments.

Every one of the 13,923 threads in the archive has a page here, with its timeline, its most active participants, its distinctive words and the threads most like it.

A new thread usually gets its first reply within 51 minutes, and half of all threads have seen their last comment within 6 days.

13,923
Threads
13,770 with a known opener
2,110
Ran past 100 comments
73 past 1,000
23
Median comments
607 threads drew none
51 minutes
Median wait for a reply
from opening post to first comment
6 days
Median lifespan
from opening post to last comment

Fig. 1

Every thread ever started

One dot per thread: when it opened, and how many comments it drew, on a logarithmic scale. Larger dots had more members taking part. The eight largest threads are named.

Fig. 2

The great threads, month by month

Comments per month in the twenty-four largest threads, ordered by when each peaked, with heights on a square-root scale. Some burn for a season; a few never go out.

Fig. 3

The pace of a conversation

How long after a thread opens its first reply comes, when its comments arrive, and when the last one is written. The horizontal scale is logarithmic; dashed lines mark the medians.

first replyall commentslast comment

1 min1 hour1 day1 week1 month1 year10 yearsfirst reply: 51 minutesmedian comment: 6 dayslast comment: 6 days

Fig. 4

How long a post runs

Distribution of post length in words, quoted text removed, on a logarithmic scale. Opening posts run long; replies are mostly a paragraph.

commentsopening posts

1101001,00010,000 wordscomments: median 52 wordsopening posts: median 182 words

Fig. 5

The fifty largest threads

Ranked by number of comments. The full table of the 500 largest can be filtered and sorted.

1The ShoutboxJamalOctober 2015February 202662,422356
2Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)Rene DescartesFebruary 2018April 202523,700286
3Ukraine CrisisManuelJanuary 2022February 202618,206126
4CoronavirusPunshhhFebruary 2020September 20258,436165
5Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West BankManuelMay 2021October 20257,579112
6Climate change denialMikieJuly 2021March 20253,93393
7What are you listening to right now?MongrelOctober 2015February 20263,688197
8Currently ReadingJamalOctober 2015February 20263,564217
9BrexitChangelingDecember 2018July 20243,10278
10Nothing to do with Dennett's "Quining Qualia"BannoOctober 2020December 20202,97730
11"What is truth? said jesting Pilate; and would not stay for an answer."PieAugust 2022October 20222,77944
12Joe Biden (+General Biden/Harris Administration)0 thru 9March 2020May 20252,639104
13The Mind-Created WorldWayfarerSeptember 2023December 20252,43867
14BanningsBadenJuly 2018December 20252,432162
15US Election 2024 (All general discussion)frankFebruary 2023February 20252,39857
16Should hate speech be allowed ?WittgensteinAugust 2019October 20192,32655
17Moralitya deleted accountMarch 2019April 20192,22632
18Indirect Realism and Direct RealismAshrielFebruary 2024June 20242,20740
19The Road to 2020 - American ElectionsMawJanuary 2020February 20212,15683
20The American Gun Control DebateBrianOctober 2017November 20252,120105
21Is there an external material world ?Hello HumanJune 2022March 20232,03059
22Post truthBannoDecember 2016December 20201,98768
23Systemic racism in the US: Why is it happening and what can be done?BadenMay 2020March 20241,91166
24Donald Trump (All Trump Conversations Here)BenkeiApril 2025February 20261,88148
25On AntinatalismShawnJuly 2019July 20201,85055
26Naming and Necessity, reading group?ShawnNovember 2018January 20191,81723
27Philosophical Investigations, reading it together.ValentinusNovember 2018July 20191,79637
28Antinatalism ArgumentsBadenAugust 2022September 20241,77397
29BeliefBannoFebruary 2018October 20231,74259
30Thoughts on EpistemologySam26December 2017October 20251,69546
31Why is the Hard Problem of Consciousness so hard?Art48January 2023April 20241,67073
32What is faithGregoryMarch 2025July 20251,63557
33Is 'information' physical?WayfarerOctober 2017December 20211,57677
34A Case for Moral Anti-realismBob RossNovember 2023July 20241,55432
35Evidence of Consciousness Surviving the BodySam26September 2017February 20261,498123
36The Last WordHanoverJanuary 2017January 20241,45159
37Anti-Vaxxers, Creationists, 9/11 Truthers, Climate Deniers, Flat-EarthersMikieSeptember 2021January 20251,44558
38PerceptionMp202020July 2024September 20241,40842
39Abortion - Why are people pro life?SamlwSeptember 2024November 20241,39947
40Why are We Back-Peddling on Racial Color-Blindness?NOS4A2October 2019October 20231,39261
41Culture is criticalAthenaMay 2023December 20231,37925
42Rational thinking: animals and humansAthenaSeptember 2024February 20251,36636
43The Invalidity of AtheismGregory AMarch 2022May 20221,35743
44All things wrong with antinatalismBenkeiDecember 2020February 20221,33842
45The source of moralshachitApril 2019May 20191,32535
46The ineffableBannoNovember 2022January 20231,31539
47Debate Discussion: "The content of belief is propositional".fdrakeDecember 2020September 20231,29942
48Disambiguating the concept of genderPfhorrestSeptember 2019June 20251,29253
49Direct realism about perceptionClarendonJanuary 2026February 20261,28230
50A first cause is logically necessaryPhilosophimNovember 2021April 20241,27975

Fig. 6

Who starts threads that take off

The fifteen members who opened the most threads, with the comments a typical thread of theirs drew and the share that ran past one hundred.

Fig. 7

Browse threads by the month they opened

Each figure is the number of threads started that month and links to a page listing all of them.

About these figures. 153 threads were opened by accounts that no longer exist in the archive; their comments are counted but their openers are unknown. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.