The Agora Almanac

Section 05 / Timeline / Month

January 2023

Members of The Philosophy Forum wrote 9,340 posts in January 2023: 117 opening posts and 9,223 comments, running to about 910,000 words. 153 members posted, 8 of them for the first time.

By number of posts it ranks 38th of the archive's 125 months. 117 threads were opened, and 186 threads received at least one comment.

The most active thread was Why is the Hard Problem of Consciousness so hard?, with 942 comments in the month.

9,340
Posts
38th of 125 months
153
Members posting
8 for the first time
117
Threads opened
186 threads active
910,000
Words written
97 per post
450
Posts on the busiest day
3 January 2023

Fig. 1

Posts per day in January 2023

Days are UTC. The busiest was 3 January 2023, with 450 posts, 77 of them in Why is the Hard Problem of Consciousness so hard?.

0 250 500 1 8 15 22 29

Fig. 2

Most active threads

Comments posted during January 2023, whenever the thread was opened.

  1. 1Why is the Hard Problem of Consciousness so hard?942
  2. 2The Shoutbox727
  3. 3Ukraine Crisis422
  4. 4Emergence383
  5. 5Kripke: Identity and Necessity279
  6. 6Atheism and Lack of belief268
  7. 7Evolution and the universe251
  8. 8The Subject as Subjected: Self vs Identity in Our Social Context226
  9. 9Positive characteristics of Females216
  10. 10Top Ten Favorite Films162
  11. 11Is "good", indefinable?161
  12. 12The Economic Pie160
  13. 13How can metaphysics be considered philosophy?148
  14. 14Is the blue pill the rational choice?147
  15. 15Should humanity be unified under a single government?142

Fig. 3

Most active members

Posts written during January 2023.

  1. 1Agent Smith578
  2. 2180 Proof482
  3. 3Banno349
  4. 4Wayfarer346
  5. 5T_Clark334
  6. 6frank304
  7. 7Isaac289
  8. 8universeness275
  9. 9javi2541997249
  10. 10Vera Mont249
  11. 11Tom Storm246
  12. 12Baden226
  13. 13Hanover197
  14. 14Shawn196
  15. 15BC167

Fig. 4

The words of January 2023

Tracked words used unusually often this month compared with the archive as a whole: used by at least five members in the month, with no one member supplying more than 35% of the uses. Larger means more distinctive; the small figure is the number of uses.

Fig. 5

117 threads opened in January 2023

117 listed

Every thread started this month, with the comments it went on to draw by the end of the archive.

Why is the Hard Problem of Consciousness so hard? Art48 1 Jan 2023 1,670 73
Emergence universeness 6 Jan 2023 1,098 22
The role of observers in MWI Marchesk 9 Jan 2023 265 17
Evolution and the universe Gregory 11 Jan 2023 251 16
Is Atheism Significant Only to Theists? Ciceronianus 30 Jan 2023 244 23
The Subject as Subjected: Self vs Identity in Our Social Context Baden 4 Jan 2023 226 25
Socrates and Platonic Forms introbert 29 Jan 2023 220 14
Top Ten Favorite Films Mikie 22 Jan 2023 217 35
Is "good", indefinable? Shawn 2 Jan 2023 198 25
How can metaphysics be considered philosophy? Zettel 26 Jan 2023 180 26
Biggest Puzzles in Philosophy Andrew4Handel 30 Jan 2023 176 18
Essence and Modality: Kit Fine Banno 16 Jan 2023 174 15
The Economic Pie Mikie 12 Jan 2023 161 18
Deaths of Despair Mikie 27 Jan 2023 155 20
Descartes and Animal Cruelty Wayfarer 22 Jan 2023 152 16
Is the blue pill the rational choice? TheMadMan 1 Jan 2023 147 19
The God Beyond Fiction Art48 9 Jan 2023 127 19
The Grundrisse with David Harvey Moliere 22 Jan 2023 122 7
The Shoutbox should be abolished alan1000 6 Jan 2023 119 25
Mind-body problem Wolfgang 7 Jan 2023 113 21
The inclusivity of collectivism and individualism. NOS4A2 16 Jan 2023 105 11
What if cultural moral norms track cooperation strategies? Mark S 18 Jan 2023 105 17
Is pornography a problem? Shawn 23 Jan 2023 102 22
Convergence of our species with aliens Benj96 22 Jan 2023 89 7
What's wrong with free speech absolutism? NOS4A2 21 Jan 2023 88 20
A re-think on the permanent status of 'Banned'? Amity 15 Jan 2023 87 27
What is your ontology? Benj96 18 Jan 2023 84 20
What is the root of all philosophy? Bret Bernhoft 25 Jan 2023 78 26
The "self" under materialism tom111 3 Jan 2023 69 16
Chess...and Philosophers Mikie 26 Jan 2023 68 6
Life is a competition. There are winners, and there are losers. That's a scary & depressing reality. niki wonoto 26 Jan 2023 67 17
Subjects and objects Benj96 12 Jan 2023 66 8
Ends justifying the means. Good or bad. TiredThinker 29 Jan 2023 65 10
Morality as Cooperation Strategies is complementary to consequentialism Mark S 30 Jan 2023 65 10
Is the music industry now based more on pageantry than raw talent? Benj96 23 Jan 2023 62 15
Respectful Dialog Pantagruel 12 Jan 2023 59 20
Recognizing greatness Bartricks 7 Jan 2023 51 13
Logic and Evidence: What is the Interplay and What are Fallacies in Philosophical Arguments? Jack Cummins 9 Jan 2023 51 9
Was Socrates a martyr? Shawn 13 Jan 2023 51 15
Does power breed corruption or nobility? TiredThinker 17 Jan 2023 50 13
Schopenhauer's Criticism of Kant's use of 'Noumena' Wayfarer 9 Jan 2023 49 10
Is Chance a Cause? Agent Smith 1 Jan 2023 46 12
Would true AI owe us anything? Benj96 23 Jan 2023 45 12
Causes of the large scale crimes of the 20th Century frank 20 Jan 2023 44 14
How to Solve it? Agent Smith 24 Jan 2023 42 5
What is Aloneness and the Significance of Other Minds? Jack Cummins 29 Jan 2023 41 8
What happened to the Weltanschauung thread? Bylaw 31 Jan 2023 40 7
The beauty asymmetry Bartricks 3 Jan 2023 38 13
The Prevalent Mentality Bug Biro 10 Jan 2023 38 9
Analytic philosophy needs affirmative action? Welkin Rogue 17 Jan 2023 38 8
The possibility of fields other than electromagnetic Wayfarer 2 Jan 2023 36 11
Defining "Real" neonspectraltoast 3 Jan 2023 33 11
Superficiality and Illusions within Identity john27 28 Jan 2023 33 9
Economic, social, and political crisis Athena 8 Jan 2023 32 12
Humans may be the most "unwanted" lifeform in the kingdom of life Benj96 19 Jan 2023 32 8
Cavemen and Libertarians Shawn 15 Jan 2023 31 14
Homeless Psychosis : Poverty Ideology Bug Biro 27 Jan 2023 31 9
Why do we get Upset? Andrew4Handel 26 Jan 2023 30 16
Papal infallibility and ex cathedra. javi2541997 1 Jan 2023 29 10
Murphy's law: "Anything that can go wrong will go wrong." Does this apply to life as well? niki wonoto 19 Jan 2023 29 9
An eye for an eye morality Benj96 3 Jan 2023 28 11
Color code introbert 26 Jan 2023 28 8
What should be done with the galaxy? Leftist 16 Jan 2023 27 16
Corporeality and Interpersonal Being kudos 26 Jan 2023 26 6
OpenAI chat on Suicide and Yukio Mishima javi2541997 30 Jan 2023 26 4
What is a person? khaled 2 Jan 2023 23 10
Hindsight Analysis Judaka 18 Jan 2023 23 6
Yes man/woman Benj96 15 Jan 2023 22 12
The Merely Real Pantagruel 22 Jan 2023 22 9
The new Help section Jamal 11 Jan 2023 21 13
Belief Formation Andrew4Handel 15 Jan 2023 21 6
Morality=Sexuality Judaka 12 Jan 2023 20 4
Innovation and Revolutionary Ideas obscurelaunting 13 Jan 2023 20 5
Life is just a bunch of distractions believenothing 12 Jan 2023 18 12
The Grand Strike Bug Biro 19 Jan 2023 17 4
Our 3D Prison? ucarr 24 Jan 2023 17 6
What is harm? Andrew4Handel 4 Jan 2023 16 7
Ownership Mikie 13 Jan 2023 16 8
Golden Rule vs "Natural Rule" James Riley 19 Jan 2023 16 9
How Karate Should Be Taught HardWorker 19 Jan 2023 14 4
Hurting those that hurt you Benj96 22 Jan 2023 14 4
Why do we make 'mistakes'? Cidat 22 Jan 2023 14 7
Jesus, Miracles, Science & Math Agent Smith 7 Jan 2023 13 5
Will to Power and Bodily Dysfunction introbert 7 Jan 2023 12 3
The Bruces: Kit Fine Banno 17 Jan 2023 11 5
Forced beliefs? Andrew4Handel 14 Jan 2023 10 4
Intent and Selective Word Use Judaka 25 Jan 2023 10 6
Is this answer acceptable? alan1000 6 Jan 2023 9 6
A Unicorn is Running Agent Smith 12 Jan 2023 9 4
Getting to Center. Meditation. God. Art48 13 Jan 2023 9 7
Philosophical Pharma introbert 13 Jan 2023 9 4
Genetic Research Vera Mont 30 Jan 2023 9 4
Letter to Aristotle Agent Smith 11 Jan 2023 8 4
Not quite the bottom of the barrel, yet... BC 26 Jan 2023 8 3
On Time and conscious experience. Benj96 31 Jan 2023 8 6
The impact of science and economics. Shawn 15 Jan 2023 7 3
The Revealers schopenhauer1 18 Jan 2023 7 4
What is your wish for this place? Alkis Piskas 2 Jan 2023 6 3
ChatGPT on Heidegger Wayfarer 23 Jan 2023 6 5
Forum Tips and Tricks - How to Quote Wayfarer 11 Jan 2023 5 4
AMOR Agent Smith 6 Jan 2023 4 2
Is goodness an illusion? TiredThinker 10 Jan 2023 4 3
Debunking NOMA: Non-overlapping Magisterium Art48 4 Jan 2023 3 2
Useful hints and tips Jamal 11 Jan 2023 3 3
Romcom tropes; beauty, personality and desireability Benj96 24 Jan 2023 3 3
The importance of forgetting Benj96 31 Jan 2023 3 3
Happiness? Rapture? god must be atheist 8 Jan 2023 2 2
Dawkins' Rule in Comparative Complexity Agent Smith 12 Jan 2023 2 2
Idea Mechanics introbert 26 Jan 2023 2 2
When are we our best? When we know we are, or when we think we aren't? TiredThinker 2 Jan 2023 1 1
Expressing individuality. Shawn 13 Jan 2023 1 1
A response to philosophical pessimism Shawn 14 Jan 2023 1 1
Ringworld and Atheism and Luck RogueAI 30 Jan 2023 1 1
LMFAO Agent Smith 4 Jan 2023 0 0
Good Patience vs Bad Patience HardWorker 4 Jan 2023 0 0
How do you think dishonestly? New2K2 7 Jan 2023 0 0
OpenAI/ChatGPT using African Sweatshops to Clean Up Output Wayfarer 19 Jan 2023 0 0

About these figures. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.