The Agora Almanac

Section 06 / Network

Who answers whom

Every quote or reply tag on the forum points at a comment, and every comment has an author. Linking the two gives 1,173,050 exchanges between members, across 52,283 different pairs.

Among the 400 most prolific members those exchanges fall into six clusters of people who mostly answer one another.

The strongest tie in the archive joins Wayfarer and Janus, who answered each other 5,445 times.

1,173,050
Replies traced
96.4% of all quote and reply tags
52,283
Pairs who exchanged replies
in either direction
400
Members on the map
six clusters
28,187
Tags left out
pointing at deleted accounts
16,243
Self-quotations
also left out

Fig. 1

The map of who talks to whom

The 400 most prolific members, placed so that those who answer each other often sit close together. Circle size follows the number of posts; colour marks the cluster. Lines join each member to the four members they exchanged most replies with. The most connected members are named, and every circle links to a profile.

Cosmos and consciousnessThe Shoutbox circleLanguage and logicWar and geopoliticsGod and atheismMathematics and infinity

theRiddler: 260 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessAsif: 241 posts, War and geopoliticsMichael McMahon: 546 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessJosh Alfred: 227 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessneonspectraltoast: 259 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessSeeker: 214 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessGary M Washburn: 249 posts, Language and logicAleksander Kvam: 224 posts, The Shoutbox circleAnsiktsburk: 218 posts, War and geopoliticsBarkon: 230 posts, Language and logicLD Saunders: 312 posts, The Shoutbox circleMonitor: 228 posts, God and atheismFine Doubter: 214 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessiolo: 226 posts, War and geopoliticsMAYAEL: 239 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesshachit: 237 posts, God and atheismshmik: 217 posts, The Shoutbox circleVarde: 327 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessQwex: 366 posts, God and atheismProtagoras: 331 posts, Language and logicForgottenticket: 247 posts, The Shoutbox circlehope: 216 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesswax: 301 posts, War and geopoliticsYing: 425 posts, The Shoutbox circleJohn Harris: 251 posts, The Shoutbox circleDiegoT: 319 posts, God and atheismTomseltje: 250 posts, The Shoutbox circlekazan: 489 posts, The Shoutbox circleMysticMonist: 232 posts, The Shoutbox circleJake Tarragon: 347 posts, The Shoutbox circleSolarWind: 237 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessAll sight: 333 posts, The Shoutbox circleRene Descartes: 569 posts, The Shoutbox circleCartuna: 246 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessIvoryBlackBishop: 299 posts, God and atheismFrederick KOH: 243 posts, The Shoutbox circleLandru Guide Us: 245 posts, The Shoutbox circleEmptyheady: 228 posts, The Shoutbox circleLif3r: 387 posts, War and geopoliticsaporiap: 226 posts, Mathematics and infinityCornwell1: 241 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessCarlo Roosen: 243 posts, Language and logicboagie: 385 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesssign: 245 posts, God and atheismShwah: 259 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessBret Bernhoft: 260 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessbloodninja: 278 posts, The Shoutbox circleunimportant: 218 posts, Language and logicRaul: 215 posts, Language and logicintrobert: 333 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessPro Hominem: 221 posts, Language and logicDharmi: 264 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesswuliheron: 440 posts, The Shoutbox circleMarty: 228 posts, Mathematics and infinityDeus: 320 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessChrisH: 231 posts, God and atheismGraveItty: 311 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesseodnhoj7: 269 posts, God and atheismMetaphysicsNow: 322 posts, The Shoutbox circleBarry Etheridge: 349 posts, The Shoutbox circleCasKev: 410 posts, The Shoutbox circleTheMadMan: 221 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessJamesk: 319 posts, God and atheismMondoR: 335 posts, War and geopoliticsSaphsin: 390 posts, War and geopoliticsChany: 352 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessSteveKlinko: 396 posts, God and atheismHachem: 385 posts, The Shoutbox circleAaron R: 218 posts, Language and logicMapping the Medium: 366 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesskindred: 247 posts, Language and logicMonfortS26: 256 posts, The Shoutbox circleFoghorn: 331 posts, War and geopoliticsO implies everything: 264 posts, Mathematics and infinityInis: 243 posts, Mathematics and infinitystoicHoneyBadger: 219 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessMalcolm Parry: 330 posts, The Shoutbox circleCongau: 228 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessProtagoranSocratist: 298 posts, Language and logicSonJnana: 246 posts, The Shoutbox circleskyblack: 544 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesspath: 284 posts, Language and logicClearbury: 242 posts, Language and logicSir Philo Sophia: 303 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessuncanni: 359 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessCuddlyHedgehog: 400 posts, The Shoutbox circleSeppo: 276 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessHeracloitus: 505 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesspetrichor: 326 posts, God and atheismAverage: 470 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessHerg: 258 posts, God and atheismTim3003: 352 posts, War and geopoliticsjkg20: 426 posts, Mathematics and infinityChester: 382 posts, War and geopoliticsPhilosophyRunner: 322 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessMariner: 374 posts, The Shoutbox circlechiknsld: 314 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessMoses: 250 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesslll: 391 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessReformed Nihilist: 279 posts, The Shoutbox circlecharles ferraro: 370 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessTheGreatArcanum: 299 posts, God and atheismAngelo Cannata: 383 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessJustSomeGuy: 313 posts, The Shoutbox circleMarcus de Brun: 443 posts, The Shoutbox circleprothero: 516 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessjas0n: 328 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesswhollyrolling: 557 posts, God and atheismdclements: 504 posts, The Shoutbox circlej0e: 443 posts, Language and logickudos: 423 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessfresco: 580 posts, God and atheismReal Gone Cat: 346 posts, Mathematics and infinityA Seagull: 619 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessspirit-salamander: 268 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessMagnus Anderson: 402 posts, Language and logicsimeonz: 317 posts, Language and logicHoo: 454 posts, Language and logicCopernicus: 414 posts, Language and logicTogetherTurtle: 355 posts, God and atheismMichael Zwingli: 416 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessanonymous66: 680 posts, The Shoutbox circlet0m: 335 posts, The Shoutbox circleCartesian trigger-puppets: 222 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessPussycat: 466 posts, Language and logicbahman: 534 posts, The Shoutbox circleHeiko: 535 posts, Mathematics and infinityHallucinogen: 359 posts, Language and logicWittgenstein: 455 posts, God and atheisminvicta: 595 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessPneumenon: 494 posts, The Shoutbox circleDaniel: 462 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessFafner: 387 posts, God and atheismLeghorn: 584 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessErik: 607 posts, The Shoutbox circlePhilosopher19: 289 posts, Mathematics and infinityBlue Lux: 583 posts, Language and logicMayor of Simpleton: 662 posts, The Shoutbox circleintrapersona: 580 posts, The Shoutbox circlePeterJones: 486 posts, Language and logicPossibleAaran: 244 posts, The Shoutbox circleMark S: 306 posts, Language and logicPL Olcott: 626 posts, Language and logicJuanZu: 383 posts, Mathematics and infinitymagritte: 639 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessovdtogt: 671 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessMijin: 390 posts, Language and logicEnnui Elucidator: 511 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessraza: 726 posts, The Shoutbox circleLuckyR: 744 posts, Language and logicAnaxagoras: 439 posts, War and geopoliticsSpaceDweller: 523 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessZelebg: 626 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessFreeEmotion: 805 posts, War and geopoliticsAstorre: 419 posts, Language and logicjohn27: 695 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessThanatos Sand: 844 posts, The Shoutbox circleDaemon: 633 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessRaymond: 816 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessNotAristotle: 594 posts, Language and logicNobeernolife: 598 posts, God and atheismRichard B: 588 posts, Language and logicMephist: 355 posts, Mathematics and infinitygurugeorge: 535 posts, The Shoutbox circleCabbage Farmer: 374 posts, Language and logicMikeL: 653 posts, The Shoutbox circleGaluchat: 814 posts, Mathematics and infinityArne: 842 posts, Language and logicEnPassant: 734 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessYohan: 679 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessmacrosoft: 674 posts, God and atheismDawnstorm: 390 posts, Language and logicBeebert: 577 posts, The Shoutbox circleCuthbert: 1,074 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessPrishon: 984 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessBook273: 785 posts, War and geopoliticsMark Nyquist: 797 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesschatterbears: 445 posts, The Shoutbox circleEsse Quam Videri: 449 posts, Language and logicBylaw: 565 posts, Language and logicTheHedoMinimalist: 473 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessHaglund: 802 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessAgree-to-Disagree: 675 posts, War and geopoliticsChet Hawkins: 290 posts, Language and logicAmalac: 489 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessernestm: 1,017 posts, War and geopoliticsDan: 235 posts, Mathematics and infinitySnakes Alive: 752 posts, Language and logicDifferentiatingEgg: 850 posts, Language and logicArt48: 509 posts, Language and logicShamshir: 861 posts, God and atheismChangeling: 1,434 posts, The Shoutbox circleDown The Rabbit Hole: 568 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessEugen: 705 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessTiredThinker: 842 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessBlueBanana: 890 posts, The Shoutbox circleBrianW: 1,001 posts, God and atheismWISDOMfromPO-MO: 753 posts, The Shoutbox circleEnrique: 845 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessTarskian: 666 posts, Mathematics and infinityExistential Hope: 789 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessArkady: 793 posts, The Shoutbox circleNils Loc: 1,513 posts, The Shoutbox circleJerseyFlight: 806 posts, Mathematics and infinityAkanthinos: 1,048 posts, The Shoutbox circleHippyhead: 1,063 posts, War and geopoliticschristian2017: 1,365 posts, God and atheismMr Bee: 735 posts, War and geopoliticsjkop: 1,006 posts, The Shoutbox circleGus Lamarch: 937 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessQuestioner: 632 posts, Language and logicJeremiah: 1,541 posts, The Shoutbox circlekarl stone: 840 posts, The Shoutbox circleEricH: 796 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessMindForged: 732 posts, Mathematics and infinitycharleton: 1,267 posts, The Shoutbox circlePie: 1,045 posts, Language and logicmcdoodle: 1,242 posts, The Shoutbox circlesime: 1,208 posts, Mathematics and infinityAJJ: 921 posts, God and atheismJabberwock: 347 posts, War and geopoliticsthewonder: 1,369 posts, War and geopoliticsdimosthenis9: 846 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesspunos: 809 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessNumber2018: 668 posts, Language and logicsynthesis: 935 posts, War and geopoliticsGnostic Christian Bishop: 1,410 posts, God and atheismCheshire: 1,090 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessm-theory: 1,088 posts, The Shoutbox circleAstrophel: 665 posts, Language and logiclitewave: 933 posts, Mathematics and infinityPinprick: 1,003 posts, War and geopoliticsCaldwell: 1,392 posts, The Shoutbox circleDavid Mo: 1,028 posts, War and geopoliticsValentinus: 1,666 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessTruth Seeker: 1,157 posts, Language and logic0 thru 9: 1,584 posts, The Shoutbox circleZhouBoTong: 850 posts, God and atheismPoeticUniverse: 1,755 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessENOAH: 1,031 posts, Language and logickeystone: 436 posts, Mathematics and infinityleo: 895 posts, God and atheismDarkneos: 1,044 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessEugeneW: 1,713 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessTate: 1,372 posts, Language and logicJake: 1,443 posts, The Shoutbox circleJackson: 1,766 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessMichael Ossipoff: 1,814 posts, The Shoutbox circleCavacava: 2,411 posts, The Shoutbox circleRank Amateur: 1,568 posts, God and atheismPattern-chaser: 1,924 posts, God and atheismApustimelogist: 946 posts, Language and logictom: 1,511 posts, The Shoutbox circleWheatley: 2,261 posts, The Shoutbox circleTobias: 1,177 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessPop: 1,523 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessToothyMaw: 1,461 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessNickolasgaspar: 1,140 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessalcontali: 1,336 posts, God and atheismHillary: 1,922 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessPseudonym: 1,220 posts, The Shoutbox circlebert1: 2,234 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessInPitzotl: 917 posts, Mathematics and infinityA Christian Philosophy: 1,250 posts, Mathematics and infinityL'elephant: 1,934 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessboundless: 772 posts, Mathematics and infinityWosret: 3,382 posts, The Shoutbox circleFrank Apisa: 2,159 posts, God and atheismMaw: 2,785 posts, The Shoutbox circleChatteringMonkey: 1,652 posts, War and geopoliticsArtemis: 1,950 posts, God and atheismregularguy: 2,622 posts, God and atheismcounterpunch: 1,633 posts, War and geopoliticsandrewk: 2,153 posts, The Shoutbox circleThe Great Whatever: 2,178 posts, The Shoutbox circlebongo fury: 1,814 posts, Language and logicConstance: 1,406 posts, Language and logicwonderer1: 2,365 posts, Language and logicBuxtebuddha: 1,751 posts, The Shoutbox circlealetheist: 1,468 posts, Mathematics and infinityPatterner: 2,034 posts, Language and logicMerkwurdichliebe: 2,624 posts, Language and logicTheWillowOfDarkness: 2,081 posts, The Shoutbox circleArcane Sandwich: 2,205 posts, Language and logicAndrew4Handel: 2,541 posts, God and atheismPierre-Normand: 2,920 posts, The Shoutbox circleplaque flag: 2,716 posts, Language and logicAndrew M: 1,636 posts, Language and logicMongrel: 3,035 posts, The Shoutbox circleRich: 3,203 posts, The Shoutbox circleAntony Nickles: 1,444 posts, Language and logicMoK: 1,901 posts, Language and logicflannel jesus: 2,909 posts, Language and logicSophistiCat: 2,680 posts, War and geopoliticsOutlander: 3,322 posts, The Shoutbox circleDingoJones: 2,903 posts, God and atheismFire Ologist: 1,742 posts, Language and logicBenj96: 2,379 posts, Cosmos and consciousnesshypericin: 2,097 posts, Language and logicAlkis Piskas: 2,147 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessPantagruel: 3,570 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessJudaka: 1,702 posts, War and geopoliticsneomac: 1,622 posts, War and geopoliticsPaine: 3,242 posts, Language and logicCiceronianus: 3,125 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessJames Riley: 2,929 posts, War and geopolitics3017amen: 3,143 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessjorndoe: 4,310 posts, War and geopoliticsSam26: 3,248 posts, Language and logicDevans99: 2,727 posts, God and atheismPunshhh: 3,716 posts, War and geopoliticsRogueAI: 3,513 posts, War and geopoliticsjgill: 4,112 posts, Mathematics and infinityGregory: 4,968 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessVagabondSpectre: 1,977 posts, The Shoutbox circleBrett: 3,141 posts, War and geopoliticsArguingWAristotleTiff: 4,973 posts, The Shoutbox circleSir2u: 3,688 posts, The Shoutbox circleTimeLine: 2,654 posts, The Shoutbox circleDfpolis: 1,429 posts, Mathematics and infinityBitconnectCarlos: 2,772 posts, War and geopoliticsThorongil: 3,153 posts, The Shoutbox circlegod must be atheist: 5,130 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessApollodorus: 3,428 posts, Language and logic_db: 3,605 posts, The Shoutbox circleJ: 2,454 posts, Language and logicRussellA: 2,696 posts, Language and logicAthena: 3,858 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessTonesInDeepFreeze: 3,851 posts, Mathematics and infinityPossibility: 2,942 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessChristoffer: 2,495 posts, War and geopoliticsjavra: 3,281 posts, Language and logicKenosha Kid: 3,213 posts, War and geopoliticsboethius: 2,665 posts, War and geopoliticsEcharmion: 2,728 posts, War and geopoliticsRelativist: 3,630 posts, Language and logicMarchesk: 4,643 posts, The Shoutbox circleManuel: 4,402 posts, Language and logicucarr: 1,885 posts, Mathematics and infinityI like sushi: 5,458 posts, War and geopoliticsnoAxioms: 1,754 posts, Mathematics and infinityBob Ross: 2,940 posts, Language and logicJack Cummins: 5,753 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessCorvus: 4,913 posts, Language and logicPfhorrest: 4,821 posts, War and geopoliticsLuke: 2,906 posts, Mathematics and infinitybaker: 6,024 posts, Language and logicOlivier5: 6,183 posts, War and geopoliticsGnomon: 5,022 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessAmity: 5,831 posts, The Shoutbox circleLudwig V: 2,495 posts, Language and logicVera Mont: 4,827 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessSrap Tasmaner: 5,209 posts, Language and logicfdrake: 5,876 posts, Language and logicAmadeusD: 4,341 posts, Language and logicCount Timothy von Icarus: 4,231 posts, Language and logicTzeentch: 4,570 posts, War and geopoliticsPhilosophim: 3,553 posts, Language and logicpraxis: 7,312 posts, War and geopoliticsjavi2541997: 7,260 posts, The Shoutbox circlefishfry: 3,449 posts, Mathematics and infinityAgent Smith: 9,469 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessStreetlight: 8,746 posts, War and geopoliticsMoliere: 6,279 posts, Language and logickhaled: 3,600 posts, War and geopoliticsBartricks: 5,999 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessMww: 5,468 posts, Language and logicBenkei: 7,518 posts, War and geopoliticsNoble Dust: 8,079 posts, The Shoutbox circleHarry Hindu: 6,047 posts, God and atheismuniverseness: 6,312 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessMikie: 7,125 posts, War and geopoliticsFooloso4: 6,299 posts, Language and logicLeontiskos: 5,611 posts, Language and logicunenlightened: 10,025 posts, The Shoutbox circlecreativesoul: 12,475 posts, Language and logicJamal: 10,010 posts, The Shoutbox circleJoshs: 6,788 posts, Language and logicNOS4A2: 10,404 posts, War and geopoliticsShawn: 13,496 posts, The Shoutbox circleapokrisis: 7,885 posts, Mathematics and infinityBaden: 14,011 posts, The Shoutbox circlessu: 9,854 posts, War and geopoliticsTom Storm: 10,917 posts, Language and logicS: 11,567 posts, The Shoutbox circleTerrapin Station: 14,146 posts, God and atheismTheMadFool: 13,954 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessBC: 14,464 posts, The Shoutbox circleschopenhauer1: 11,060 posts, War and geopoliticsHanover: 14,434 posts, The Shoutbox circleAgustino: 11,251 posts, The Shoutbox circle180 Proof: 16,469 posts, Cosmos and consciousnessT_Clark: 16,153 posts, The Shoutbox circleMichael: 15,989 posts, The Shoutbox circlefrank: 19,072 posts, Language and logicIsaac: 10,707 posts, War and geopoliticsJanus: 19,552 posts, Language and logicMetaphysician Undercover: 14,863 posts, Mathematics and infinityWayfarer: 26,147 posts, Language and logicBanno: 31,280 posts, Language and logicBannoWayfarerJanusIsaacfrankT_Clark180 ProofAgustinoHanoverBCTheMadFoolSTom StormssuBadenapokrisisShawnJoshscreativesoulLeontiskosFooloso4MikieuniversenessHarry HinduNoble DustBenkeiBartrickskhaledMoliereStreetlightAgent SmithpraxisPhilosophimTzeentchCount Timothy von IcarusfdrakeVera MontLudwig VGnomonPfhorrestCorvusJack CumminsBob RossI like sushiucarrManuel

Fig. 2

Six clusters

Groups of members who answer one another more than they answer anyone else, found by community detection on the reply counts. The names are editorial shorthand for the words each group uses unusually often.

Fig. 3

The conversation matrix

The forty most-answered members, grouped by cluster. Each cell shows how often the member in the row quoted or replied to the member in the column; darker means more. Lines divide the clusters.

fewermore replies

TheMadFoolTheMadFool180 Proof180 ProofBartricksBartricksuniversenessuniversenessMichaelMichaelHanoverHanoverT_ClarkT_ClarkBCBCAgustinoAgustinoShawnShawnBadenBadenunenlightenedunenlightenedSSJamalJamalNoble DustNoble DustBannoBannoWayfarerWayfarerJanusJanusfrankfrankTom StormTom StormcreativesoulcreativesoulJoshsJoshsCount Timothy von ...Count Timothy von ...Fooloso4Fooloso4fdrakefdrakeLeontiskosLeontiskosMoliereMoliereMwwMwwIsaacIsaacschopenhauer1schopenhauer1NOS4A2NOS4A2ssussuStreetlightStreetlightBenkeiBenkeiMikieMikieTzeentchTzeentchTerrapin StationTerrapin StationHarry HinduHarry HinduMetaphysician Unde...Metaphysician Unde...apokrisisapokrisis

Fig. 4

The great duets

The pairs of members who answered each other most, with the replies sent in each direction.

PairFirst to secondSecond to firstTotal
Wayfarer and Janus2,3993,0465,445
Banno and frank1,7001,8713,571
Banno and Janus1,5801,7693,349
Metaphysician Undercover and Luke1,4841,8593,343
Wayfarer and Banno1,3061,5012,807
Philosophim and Bob Ross2,1423152,457
Metaphysician Undercover and fishfry9041,5522,456
S and Agustino1,1851,1852,370
Michael and NOS4A21,3609312,291
Isaac and Olivier51,1941,0662,260
Baden and Hanover1,1529862,138
apokrisis and Metaphysician Undercover9381,1822,120
Wayfarer and Tom Storm9161,1682,084
Wayfarer and apokrisis1,0039961,999
Michael and Banno9611,0151,976
Banno and Metaphysician Undercover7371,2361,973
180 Proof and Agent Smith8799781,857
Jamal and Noble Dust9408851,825
Jamal and Hanover9628461,808
Agustino and Janus1,0667271,793
S and Terrapin Station1,0227341,756
Hanover and T_Clark7171,0051,722
Janus and Metaphysician Undercover7319681,699
khaled and Isaac1,0086831,691
Hanover and Banno7908871,677
Agustino and Buxtebuddha8568151,671
Janus and creativesoul7818261,607
BC and Agustino6069751,581
Michael and Agustino6818881,569
ssu and Isaac6628461,508

Fig. 5

Answering and being answered

The fifty members involved in the most exchanges. A ratio above 1 means the member drew more replies than they wrote.

Cluster
BannoLanguage and logic33,76336,5331.08814
WayfarerLanguage and logic29,71934,4481.16938
Metaphysician UndercoverMathematics and infinity30,81526,6280.86666
JanusLanguage and logic24,43224,2250.99550
IsaacWar and geopolitics19,82517,4100.88277
frankLanguage and logic19,01217,5640.92506
T_ClarkThe Shoutbox circle19,38116,1400.83879
MichaelThe Shoutbox circle16,40018,9961.16452
180 ProofCosmos and consciousness17,49214,7520.84689
AgustinoThe Shoutbox circle18,61713,1050.70212
TheMadFoolCosmos and consciousness15,95715,5170.971,007
BCThe Shoutbox circle15,51814,8990.96959
schopenhauer1War and geopolitics15,24914,7280.97546
HanoverThe Shoutbox circle12,77317,1161.34493
Terrapin StationGod and atheism14,49813,5920.94482
Tom StormLanguage and logic13,98612,4230.89591
SThe Shoutbox circle15,12210,9770.73361
ssuWar and geopolitics13,33311,8480.89511
BadenThe Shoutbox circle12,44612,0730.97466
apokrisisMathematics and infinity11,81211,9771.01387
ShawnThe Shoutbox circle10,71012,2561.14447
JoshsLanguage and logic12,7599,5870.75474
NOS4A2War and geopolitics9,01813,0971.45448
JamalThe Shoutbox circle9,73210,3061.06351
creativesoulLanguage and logic9,78410,0651.03332
unenlightenedThe Shoutbox circle8,57411,1531.30640
Fooloso4Language and logic10,2468,3460.81275
LeontiskosLanguage and logic11,1137,4480.67195
MikieWar and geopolitics9,7988,2770.84348
universenessCosmos and consciousness9,8627,5280.76223
Harry HinduGod and atheism9,0197,9640.88453
BartricksCosmos and consciousness8,7158,0110.92324
MwwLanguage and logic8,9947,4120.82362
Noble DustThe Shoutbox circle8,5637,8370.92301
BenkeiWar and geopolitics7,3038,8171.21307
khaledWar and geopolitics9,8955,9380.60250
StreetlightWar and geopolitics5,9799,3341.56335
fishfryMathematics and infinity8,9906,1900.69318
MoliereLanguage and logic7,4877,4340.99330
Agent SmithCosmos and consciousness7,6707,2100.94301
javi2541997The Shoutbox circle7,9146,7620.85428
PhilosophimLanguage and logic8,5456,0130.70309
praxisWar and geopolitics7,2637,0230.97392
fdrakeLanguage and logic6,2617,4831.20381
TzeentchWar and geopolitics6,3397,2451.14244
AmadeusDLanguage and logic7,9395,5610.70206
Count Timothy von IcarusLanguage and logic4,7338,6571.83290
Vera MontCosmos and consciousness7,3795,8520.79255
Srap TasmanerLanguage and logic6,0467,1791.19293
GnomonCosmos and consciousness6,6776,5410.98447

About these figures. A reply is counted whenever one member quotes or uses the reply button on another's comment. Tags are matched by the comment they cite, so exchanges survive changes of username. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.