Section 06 / Network
Who answers whom
Every quote or reply tag on the forum points at a comment, and every comment has an author. Linking the two gives 1,173,050 exchanges between members, across 52,283 different pairs.
Among the 400 most prolific members those exchanges fall into six clusters of people who mostly answer one another.
The strongest tie in the archive joins Wayfarer and Janus, who answered each other 5,445 times.
Fig. 1
The map of who talks to whom
The 400 most prolific members, placed so that those who answer each other often sit close together. Circle size follows the number of posts; colour marks the cluster. Lines join each member to the four members they exchanged most replies with. The most connected members are named, and every circle links to a profile.
Cosmos and consciousnessThe Shoutbox circleLanguage and logicWar and geopoliticsGod and atheismMathematics and infinity
Fig. 2
Six clusters
Groups of members who answer one another more than they answer anyone else, found by community detection on the reply counts. The names are editorial shorthand for the words each group uses unusually often.
- 101 members / 39% kept inside
Cosmos and consciousness
180 Proof, TheMadFool, Agent Smith, universeness
- 94 members / 53% kept inside
The Shoutbox circle
T_Clark, Michael, BC, Hanover
- 86 members / 52% kept inside
Language and logic
Banno, Wayfarer, Janus, frank
- 50 members / 42% kept inside
War and geopolitics
schopenhauer1, Isaac, NOS4A2, ssu
- 38 members / 25% kept inside
God and atheism
Terrapin Station, Harry Hindu, DingoJones, Devans99
- 31 members / 32% kept inside
Mathematics and infinity
Metaphysician Undercover, apokrisis, jgill, TonesInDeepFreeze
Fig. 3
The conversation matrix
The forty most-answered members, grouped by cluster. Each cell shows how often the member in the row quoted or replied to the member in the column; darker means more. Lines divide the clusters.
fewermore replies
Fig. 4
The great duets
The pairs of members who answered each other most, with the replies sent in each direction.
| Pair | First to second | Second to first | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wayfarer and Janus | 2,399 | 3,046 | 5,445 |
| Banno and frank | 1,700 | 1,871 | 3,571 |
| Banno and Janus | 1,580 | 1,769 | 3,349 |
| Metaphysician Undercover and Luke | 1,484 | 1,859 | 3,343 |
| Wayfarer and Banno | 1,306 | 1,501 | 2,807 |
| Philosophim and Bob Ross | 2,142 | 315 | 2,457 |
| Metaphysician Undercover and fishfry | 904 | 1,552 | 2,456 |
| S and Agustino | 1,185 | 1,185 | 2,370 |
| Michael and NOS4A2 | 1,360 | 931 | 2,291 |
| Isaac and Olivier5 | 1,194 | 1,066 | 2,260 |
| Baden and Hanover | 1,152 | 986 | 2,138 |
| apokrisis and Metaphysician Undercover | 938 | 1,182 | 2,120 |
| Wayfarer and Tom Storm | 916 | 1,168 | 2,084 |
| Wayfarer and apokrisis | 1,003 | 996 | 1,999 |
| Michael and Banno | 961 | 1,015 | 1,976 |
| Banno and Metaphysician Undercover | 737 | 1,236 | 1,973 |
| 180 Proof and Agent Smith | 879 | 978 | 1,857 |
| Jamal and Noble Dust | 940 | 885 | 1,825 |
| Jamal and Hanover | 962 | 846 | 1,808 |
| Agustino and Janus | 1,066 | 727 | 1,793 |
| S and Terrapin Station | 1,022 | 734 | 1,756 |
| Hanover and T_Clark | 717 | 1,005 | 1,722 |
| Janus and Metaphysician Undercover | 731 | 968 | 1,699 |
| khaled and Isaac | 1,008 | 683 | 1,691 |
| Hanover and Banno | 790 | 887 | 1,677 |
| Agustino and Buxtebuddha | 856 | 815 | 1,671 |
| Janus and creativesoul | 781 | 826 | 1,607 |
| BC and Agustino | 606 | 975 | 1,581 |
| Michael and Agustino | 681 | 888 | 1,569 |
| ssu and Isaac | 662 | 846 | 1,508 |
Fig. 5
Answering and being answered
The fifty members involved in the most exchanges. A ratio above 1 means the member drew more replies than they wrote.
About these figures. A reply is counted whenever one member quotes or uses the reply button on another's comment. Tags are matched by the comment they cite, so exchanges survive changes of username. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.