The Agora Almanac

Member profile / first post December 2016

MindForged

MindForged wrote 732 posts on The Philosophy Forum between 31 December 2016 and 10 April 2019: 728 comments and 4 opening posts.

That places them 217th of 4,083 members by number of posts, inside the top 10% of the archive. Their busiest year was 2018, with 568 posts.

In all they wrote about 105,000 words of their own, quotations excluded. A typical post of theirs runs to 95 words; the forum-wide median for a comment is 52.

In the reply network MindForged belongs to the cluster Mathematics and infinity: 31 members who mostly answer one another.

732
Posts
217th of 4,083 members
4
Threads opened
728 comments in 135 threads
105,000
Words written
95 in a typical post
146
Days active
over 2 years and 3 months
1,029
Replies given
1,164 received

Activity

Posts per month

Opening posts and comments together. The busiest month was January 2019, with 132 posts; MindForged posted in 15 months of the archive's 125 and on 146 separate days.

07515020162017201820192020202120222023202420252026
YearPostsShare of their postsRank that year
201691%outside top 25
20174under 1%outside top 25
201856878%outside top 25
201915121%outside top 25

Threads

Where they commented most

MindForged commented in 135 threads. The twelve below account for 44% of their comments.

  1. 1Do you believe there can be an Actual Infinite79
  2. 2Arguments for discrete time37
  3. 3All A is B and all A is C, therefore some B is C33
  4. 4A question about the liar paradox31
  5. 5Mathematical Conundrum or Not? Number Four27
  6. 6Is Logic "Fundamental" to Reality?22
  7. 7Belief (not just religious belief) ought to be abolished!18
  8. 8Is infinity a quantity?16
  9. 9How do we justify logic?16
  10. 10The Definition of Infinity is Contradictory15
  11. 11A problem for the deflationary theory of truth14
  12. 12Meinong's Jungle14

Threads

Threads they opened

MindForged opened 4 threads; a typical one drew 78 comments.

  1. 1Is Logic "Fundamental" to Reality?201889
  2. 2Do Concepts and Words Have Essential Meanings?201878
  3. 3What is Self-Evidence? Also Fallibilism Discussed201811
  4. 4Why are Public Intellectuals (Often Scientists) So Embarrassing in their Political Commentary?20189

Vocabulary

Signature words

Tracked words that MindForged uses unusually often compared with the forum as a whole; larger means more distinctive. The small figure is how many times they used the word. Profanity, insults and a few charged terms are left out of these lists.

Vocabulary

Subject mix

Uses of each subject family's keywords per 10,000 words written by MindForged, beside the forum-wide rate.

Reading

Thinkers named most

How often MindForged names each thinker in their own words, counting related forms such as "Kantian".

  1. 1Aristotle79
  2. 2Frege43
  3. 3Russell38
  4. 4Cantor24
  5. 5Godel22
  6. 6Plato21
  7. 7Tarski21
  8. 8Kripke19
  9. 9Marx17
  10. 10Newton14

Vocabulary

Closest vocabulary

Members whose choice of words is most like that of MindForged, by cosine similarity of word profiles (1 would be identical). It measures shared subject matter, not agreement.

Conversation

Replied to most

MindForged quoted or replied to other members 1,029 times, reaching 118 different members.

  1. 1Metaphysician Undercover118
  2. 2Devans9985
  3. 3Dfpolis58
  4. 4Terrapin Station48
  5. 5TheMadFool32
  6. 6khaled28
  7. 7fishfry26
  8. 8andrewk23
  9. 9S22
  10. 10Banno21

Conversation

Most replies from

MindForged was quoted or replied to 1,164 times, by 108 different members.

  1. 1Dfpolis166
  2. 2Metaphysician Undercover123
  3. 3litewave61
  4. 4Terrapin Station43
  5. 5Devans9937
  6. 6Andrew M33
  7. 7fishfry31
  8. 8TheMadFool24
  9. 9khaled24
  10. 10S23

Record

At a glance

First post
31 December 2016 (December 2016)
Last post
10 April 2019 (April 2019)
Span
2 years and 3 months
Cohort
First posted in 2016, with 210 others
Rank by posts
217th of 4,083
Busiest year
2018 (568 posts)
Longest post
1,134 words
Days with a post
146
Network cluster
Mathematics and infinity

About these figures. Member names are the public handles shown in the archive. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.