The Agora Almanac

Section 06 / Network / Cluster 6 of 6

Mathematics and infinity

Members who mostly answer one another about set theory, the continuum and the foundations of mathematics. 31 members of the 400 most prolific fall into this cluster; between them they wrote 55,666 posts, 6% of the archive.

Of the replies its members sent to others on the map, 32% went to fellow members of the cluster.

Its most prolific members are Metaphysician Undercover, apokrisis, jgill. Membership describes who a member answered most, not what they believe.

31
Members
of 400 on the map
55,666
Posts by its members
6% of the archive
32%
Replies kept inside
share sent to fellow members

Fig. 1

Words that mark the cluster

Words its members use unusually often compared with the forum as a whole, with each member's contribution capped so that no one voice defines the group.

Fig. 2

Strongest ties inside the cluster

Pairs of members in the cluster, by replies exchanged in both directions.

  1. 1Metaphysician Undercover and Luke3,343
  2. 2Metaphysician Undercover and fishfry2,456
  3. 3apokrisis and Metaphysician Undercover2,120
  4. 4Metaphysician Undercover and Dfpolis1,432
  5. 5Dan and Metaphysician Undercover1,336
  6. 6Metaphysician Undercover and ucarr1,164
  7. 7fishfry and keystone1,143
  8. 8Metaphysician Undercover and aletheist1,043
  9. 9noAxioms and boundless849
  10. 10fishfry and TonesInDeepFreeze845
  11. 11TonesInDeepFreeze and keystone769
  12. 12Metaphysician Undercover and TonesInDeepFreeze741
  13. 13fishfry and Mephist708
  14. 14noAxioms and fishfry615
  15. 15noAxioms and ucarr603

Fig. 3

Threads where its members gathered

Comments by members of the cluster, summed over each member's twelve most-visited threads.

  1. 1The Shoutbox822
  2. 2Philosophical Investigations, reading it together.664
  3. 3Can it be that some physicists believe in the actual infinite?518
  4. 4Is 'information' physical?503
  5. 510k Philosophy challenge385
  6. 6My own (personal) beef with the real numbers381
  7. 7Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)378
  8. 8Infinity353
  9. 9Some remarks on Wittgenstein's private language argument (PLA)349
  10. 10Infinite Staircase Paradox348
  11. 11Continuum does not exist344
  12. 12A -> not-A328

Fig. 4

The 31 members

Click a heading to sort.

Metaphysician Undercover 14,863 30,815 26,628 2016 2017
apokrisis 7,885 11,812 11,977 2016 2017
jgill 4,112 3,501 3,815 2019 2022
TonesInDeepFreeze 3,851 5,259 3,459 2021 2024
fishfry 3,449 8,990 6,190 2017 2021
Luke 2,906 6,197 5,231 2017 2020
ucarr 1,885 5,540 4,241 2021 2024
noAxioms 1,754 3,750 6,256 2016 2017
aletheist 1,468 2,721 2,168 2016 2017
Dfpolis 1,429 4,598 2,806 2018 2018
A Christian Philosophy 1,250 2,162 1,872 2017 2017
sime 1,208 709 1,502 2016 2019
litewave 933 1,247 1,143 2017 2017
InPitzotl 917 2,600 1,737 2020 2021
Galuchat 814 711 724 2017 2017
JerseyFlight 806 928 987 2020 2020
boundless 772 2,206 1,515 2018 2025
MindForged 732 1,029 1,164 2016 2018
Tarskian 666 760 979 2024 2024
Heiko 535 580 492 2018 2018
keystone 436 1,136 1,470 2021 2024
jkg20 426 365 468 2018 2018
JuanZu 383 443 643 2023 2025
Mephist 355 525 704 2019 2019
Real Gone Cat 346 343 487 2016 2022
Philosopher19 289 460 505 2018 2024
O implies everything 264 288 304 2023 2023
Inis 243 300 287 2018 2019
Dan 235 704 777 2016 2024
Marty 228 184 328 2016 2017
aporiap 226 223 297 2016 2018

About these figures. Clusters are computed from reply counts alone; the name is editorial shorthand. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.