The Agora Almanac

Section 06 / Network / Cluster 5 of 6

God and atheism

Members who mostly answer one another about the existence of God, belief and unbelief. 38 members of the 400 most prolific fall into this cluster; between them they wrote 54,624 posts, 5% of the archive.

Of the replies its members sent to others on the map, 25% went to fellow members of the cluster.

Its most prolific members are Terrapin Station, Harry Hindu, DingoJones. Membership describes who a member answered most, not what they believe.

38
Members
of 400 on the map
54,624
Posts by its members
5% of the archive
25%
Replies kept inside
share sent to fellow members

Fig. 1

Words that mark the cluster

Words its members use unusually often compared with the forum as a whole, with each member's contribution capped so that no one voice defines the group.

Fig. 2

Strongest ties inside the cluster

Pairs of members in the cluster, by replies exchanged in both directions.

  1. 1Harry Hindu and Terrapin Station656
  2. 2Terrapin Station and AJJ610
  3. 3Terrapin Station and Andrew4Handel497
  4. 4Terrapin Station and Devans99491
  5. 5Terrapin Station and regularguy433
  6. 6Terrapin Station and Rank Amateur383
  7. 7Terrapin Station and DingoJones380
  8. 8Terrapin Station and macrosoft358
  9. 9Devans99 and Frank Apisa348
  10. 10Terrapin Station and Pattern-chaser339
  11. 11BrianW and eodnhoj7281
  12. 12Terrapin Station and leo263
  13. 13Terrapin Station and Artemis248
  14. 14christian2017 and Gnostic Christian Bishop248
  15. 15Pattern-chaser and Devans99210

Fig. 3

Threads where its members gathered

Comments by members of the cluster, summed over each member's twelve most-visited threads.

  1. 1Should hate speech be allowed ?1,022
  2. 2Morality722
  3. 3Idealism vs. Materialism631
  4. 4On Antinatalism535
  5. 5Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)489
  6. 6People want to be their own gods. Is that good or evil? The real Original Sin, then and today, to mo348
  7. 7Art highlights the elitism of opinion342
  8. 8Problem with the view that language is use276
  9. 9Moore, Open Questions and ...is good.244
  10. 10Coronavirus237
  11. 11Why are We Back-Peddling on Racial Color-Blindness?233
  12. 12Existence is relative, not absolute.230

Fig. 4

The 38 members

Click a heading to sort.

Terrapin Station 14,146 14,498 13,592 2016 2019
Harry Hindu 6,047 9,019 7,964 2015 2020
DingoJones 2,903 3,076 2,898 2018 2019
Devans99 2,727 3,479 3,784 2018 2019
regularguy 2,622 2,409 2,084 2018 2019
Andrew4Handel 2,541 1,898 3,442 2017 2018
Frank Apisa 2,159 2,201 2,056 2019 2020
Artemis 1,950 2,286 2,066 2018 2019
Pattern-chaser 1,924 2,096 1,663 2018 2019
Rank Amateur 1,568 1,722 1,648 2018 2019
Gnostic Christian Bishop 1,410 1,494 1,154 2019 2019
christian2017 1,365 1,330 866 2019 2020
alcontali 1,336 2,034 1,810 2019 2019
BrianW 1,001 1,075 870 2018 2018
AJJ 921 1,114 1,055 2019 2019
leo 895 1,383 1,574 2018 2019
Shamshir 861 956 797 2019 2019
ZhouBoTong 850 1,737 1,045 2019 2019
macrosoft 674 839 597 2018 2018
Nobeernolife 598 616 630 2020 2020
fresco 580 294 603 2019 2019
whollyrolling 557 357 556 2019 2019
Wittgenstein 455 381 674 2019 2019
SteveKlinko 396 458 429 2017 2018
Fafner 387 508 473 2017 2017
Qwex 366 133 214 2020 2020
TogetherTurtle 355 600 380 2018 2019
petrichor 326 308 445 2018 2019
DiegoT 319 228 268 2018 2018
Jamesk 319 270 304 2016 2018
IvoryBlackBishop 299 207 264 2020 2020
TheGreatArcanum 299 400 412 2019 2019
eodnhoj7 269 235 308 2018 2018
Herg 258 372 356 2017 2018
sign 245 305 218 2018 2018
hachit 237 149 192 2018 2019
ChrisH 231 307 237 2017 2019
Monitor 228 154 144 2015 2020

About these figures. Clusters are computed from reply counts alone; the name is editorial shorthand. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.