The Agora Almanac

Section 06 / Network / Cluster 4 of 6

War and geopolitics

Members whose exchanges are concentrated in the long-running threads on Ukraine, the Middle East and world politics. 50 members of the 400 most prolific fall into this cluster; between them they wrote 151,493 posts, 15% of the archive.

Of the replies its members sent to others on the map, 42% went to fellow members of the cluster.

Its most prolific members are schopenhauer1, Isaac, NOS4A2. Membership describes who a member answered most, not what they believe.

50
Members
of 400 on the map
151,493
Posts by its members
15% of the archive
42%
Replies kept inside
share sent to fellow members

Fig. 1

Words that mark the cluster

Words its members use unusually often compared with the forum as a whole, with each member's contribution capped so that no one voice defines the group.

Fig. 2

Strongest ties inside the cluster

Pairs of members in the cluster, by replies exchanged in both directions.

  1. 1Isaac and Olivier52,260
  2. 2khaled and Isaac1,691
  3. 3ssu and Isaac1,508
  4. 4schopenhauer1 and khaled1,471
  5. 5Isaac and Pfhorrest1,330
  6. 6Isaac and neomac1,313
  7. 7ssu and Tzeentch1,253
  8. 8ssu and boethius1,203
  9. 9praxis and NOS4A21,189
  10. 10Tzeentch and Isaac1,154
  11. 11Benkei and ssu971
  12. 12ssu and NOS4A2970
  13. 13Christoffer and Isaac923
  14. 14Isaac and Jabberwock898
  15. 15Isaac and Mikie854

Fig. 3

Threads where its members gathered

Comments by members of the cluster, summed over each member's twelve most-visited threads.

  1. 1Ukraine Crisis13,667
  2. 2Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)9,610
  3. 3Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West Bank4,842
  4. 4Coronavirus3,979
  5. 5The Shoutbox2,453
  6. 6Climate change denial1,955
  7. 7Brexit1,324
  8. 8Joe Biden (+General Biden/Harris Administration)1,246
  9. 9US Election 2024 (All general discussion)1,041
  10. 10All things wrong with antinatalism957
  11. 11Donald Trump (All Trump Conversations Here)881
  12. 12Systemic racism in the US: Why is it happening and what can be done?858

Fig. 4

The 50 members

Click a heading to sort.

schopenhauer1 11,060 15,249 14,728 2015 2023
Isaac 10,707 19,825 17,410 2018 2022
NOS4A2 10,404 9,018 13,097 2019 2020
ssu 9,854 13,333 11,848 2015 2020
Streetlight 8,746 5,979 9,334 2015 2020
Benkei 7,518 7,303 8,817 2015 2020
praxis 7,312 7,263 7,023 2017 2021
Mikie 7,125 9,798 8,277 2019 2021
Olivier5 6,183 6,114 6,270 2020 2022
I like sushi 5,458 4,946 5,644 2016 2019
Pfhorrest 4,821 5,520 6,550 2019 2020
Tzeentch 4,570 6,339 7,245 2018 2023
jorndoe 4,310 2,944 3,415 2015 2023
Punshhh 3,716 3,194 3,481 2016 2020
khaled 3,600 9,895 5,938 2018 2021
RogueAI 3,513 3,110 3,824 2019 2023
Kenosha Kid 3,213 4,946 4,403 2020 2021
Brett 3,141 4,520 2,768 2019 2020
James Riley 2,929 3,712 2,529 2021 2021
BitconnectCarlos 2,772 4,008 3,729 2019 2020
Echarmion 2,728 5,804 4,600 2019 2019
SophistiCat 2,680 3,413 3,081 2016 2020
boethius 2,665 4,645 4,424 2018 2022
Christoffer 2,495 4,941 3,961 2018 2022
Judaka 1,702 3,022 3,070 2019 2020
ChatteringMonkey 1,652 2,135 2,024 2018 2020
counterpunch 1,633 2,419 2,035 2021 2021
neomac 1,622 3,149 2,613 2021 2022
thewonder 1,369 1,195 1,028 2019 2021
Hippyhead 1,063 1,083 1,006 2020 2020
David Mo 1,028 1,305 1,442 2019 2020
ernestm 1,017 841 815 2017 2020
Pinprick 1,003 1,445 1,310 2020 2020
synthesis 935 1,045 1,258 2021 2021
FreeEmotion 805 654 558 2017 2022
Book273 785 774 753 2020 2021
Mr Bee 735 1,032 865 2017 2020
Agree-to-Disagree 675 705 786 2023 2023
Anaxagoras 439 756 479 2019 2019
Saphsin 390 252 319 2015 2020
Lif3r 387 210 317 2018 2018
Chester 382 300 343 2017 2020
Tim3003 352 290 425 2018 2019
Jabberwock 347 1,022 1,015 2023 2023
MondoR 335 238 353 2020 2021
Foghorn 331 311 291 2021 2021
wax 301 179 241 2019 2019
Asif 241 0 178 2020 2020
iolo 226 136 142 2018 2019
Ansiktsburk 218 117 210 2017 2020

About these figures. Clusters are computed from reply counts alone; the name is editorial shorthand. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.