The Agora Almanac

Member profile / first post August 2016

Metaphysician Undercover

Metaphysician Undercover wrote 14,863 posts on The Philosophy Forum between 7 August 2016 and 17 February 2026: 14,852 comments and 11 opening posts.

That places them 8th of 4,083 members by number of posts, among the ten most prolific in the archive. Their busiest year was 2017, with 2,215 posts.

In all they wrote about 3.2 million words of their own, quotations excluded. A typical post of theirs runs to 126 words; the forum-wide median for a comment is 52. They were still posting at the end of the archive, in February 2026.

In the reply network Metaphysician Undercover belongs to the cluster Mathematics and infinity: 31 members who mostly answer one another.

14,863
Posts
8th of 4,083 members
11
Threads opened
14,852 comments in 1,404 threads
3.2 million
Words written
126 in a typical post
3,376
Days active
over 9 years and 6 months
30,815
Replies given
26,628 received

Activity

Posts per month

Opening posts and comments together. The busiest month was February 2017, with 270 posts; Metaphysician Undercover posted in 115 months of the archive's 125 and on 3,376 separate days.

015030020162017201820192020202120222023202420252026
YearPostsShare of their postsRank that year
20168576%11th
20172,21515%9th
20181,81112%13th
20191,47610%18th
20201,60611%13th
20211,3459%outside top 25
20221,3839%22nd
20231,2809%24th
20241,2879%18th
20251,4079%13th
20261961%14th

Threads

Where they commented most

Metaphysician Undercover commented in 1,404 threads. The twelve below account for 20% of their comments.

  1. 1The Shoutbox765
  2. 2Philosophical Investigations, reading it together.375
  3. 3Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)344
  4. 4Reading group: Negative Dialectics by Theodor Adorno200
  5. 5Is 'information' physical?191
  6. 610k Philosophy challenge169
  7. 7Some remarks on Wittgenstein's private language argument (PLA)159
  8. 8The Mind-Created World158
  9. 9Thoughts on Epistemology148
  10. 10"What is truth? said jesting Pilate; and would not stay for an answer."144
  11. 11Can it be that some physicists believe in the actual infinite?131
  12. 12What is the difference between actual infinity and potential infinity?115

Threads

Threads they opened

Metaphysician Undercover opened 11 threads; a typical one drew 18 comments. The ten that drew the most comments are listed.

  1. 1"Chance" in Evolutionary Theory2016254
  2. 2Symmetry: is it a true principle?2021120
  3. 3The Distinct and Inconsistent Reality of a Dream2025115
  4. 4The Difference Between Future and Past201984
  5. 5Coherentism202084
  6. 6Real-time Debating201718
  7. 7Does Roundup (glyphosate) harm the human body?201716
  8. 8Biodigital Convergence, the good, the bad, and the ugly20257
  9. 9How does a reader know which category any particular discussion is in?20185
  10. 10Why are the times on this site so screwed up?20194

Vocabulary

Signature words

Tracked words that Metaphysician Undercover uses unusually often compared with the forum as a whole; larger means more distinctive. The small figure is how many times they used the word. Profanity, insults and a few charged terms are left out of these lists.

Vocabulary

Subject mix

Uses of each subject family's keywords per 10,000 words written by Metaphysician Undercover, beside the forum-wide rate.

Reading

Thinkers named most

How often Metaphysician Undercover names each thinker in their own words, counting related forms such as "Kantian".

  1. 1Aristotle2,801
  2. 2Plato2,629
  3. 3Wittgenstein1,367
  4. 4Socrates426
  5. 5Newton425
  6. 6Kant393
  7. 7Hegel359
  8. 8Aquinas356
  9. 9Pythagoras343
  10. 10Adorno305

Vocabulary

Closest vocabulary

Members whose choice of words is most like that of Metaphysician Undercover, by cosine similarity of word profiles (1 would be identical). It measures shared subject matter, not agreement.

Conversation

Replied to most

Metaphysician Undercover quoted or replied to other members 30,815 times, reaching 666 different members.

  1. 1Luke1,484
  2. 2Banno1,236
  3. 3apokrisis1,182
  4. 4Janus968
  5. 5Wayfarer941
  6. 6fishfry904
  7. 7Mww698
  8. 8Dan681
  9. 9Dfpolis581
  10. 10Terrapin Station563

Conversation

Most replies from

Metaphysician Undercover was quoted or replied to 26,628 times, by 525 different members.

  1. 1Luke1,859
  2. 2fishfry1,552
  3. 3apokrisis938
  4. 4Dfpolis851
  5. 5Banno737
  6. 6Janus731
  7. 7Mww703
  8. 8Dan655
  9. 9ucarr652
  10. 10aletheist566

Record

At a glance

First post
7 August 2016 (August 2016)
Last post
17 February 2026 (February 2026)
Span
9 years and 6 months
Cohort
First posted in 2016, with 210 others
Rank by posts
8th of 4,083
Busiest year
2017 (2,215 posts)
Longest post
2,745 words
Days with a post
3,376
Network cluster
Mathematics and infinity

About these figures. Member names are the public handles shown in the archive. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.