Section 03 / Topics / Subject family
Logic on the forum
Propositions, semantics, validity and the foundations of reasoning. The 17 keywords in this family were used 195,328 times on The Philosophy Forum: 18.8 of every 10,000 words written. 1,967 members used at least one of them, in 8,724 threads.
Among full calendar years the subject was most prominent in 2024, at 27.3 uses per 10,000 words.
Keywords: logic, logical, sentence, proposition, valid, propositions, axioms, sentences and 9 more.
Trend
Uses per 10,000 words, by quarter
All 17 keywords together, relative to everything written in the quarter. The peak was Q3 2024, at 34.3 per 10,000 words. The last quarter ends on 25 February 2026.
Keywords
The 17 keywords of this family
Total uses of each keyword over the whole archive. Each links to its own page.
People
Who wrote the most about it
Members ranked by total uses of the family's keywords.
- 1Metaphysician Undercover8,359
- 2Banno7,786
- 3TonesInDeepFreeze7,482
- 4TheMadFool4,060
- 5Janus3,550
- 6Michael3,371
- 7Sam263,254
- 8RussellA3,245
- 9Mww3,181
- 10Wayfarer3,089
- 11apokrisis3,072
- 12Leontiskos2,987
- 13Gnomon2,829
- 14fishfry2,432
- 15creativesoul2,372
People
For whom it looms largest
Uses per 10,000 of the member's own words, among members with a substantial body of writing.
- 1TonesInDeepFreeze159
- 2MindForged141
- 3eodnhoj7125
- 4sime91.3
- 5Cartesian trigger-puppets73.1
- 6alcontali67.5
- 7Sam2663.7
- 8Tarskian63.1
- 9RussellA60.7
- 10aletheist55.4
- 11bongo fury53.8
- 12EricH52.8
- 13Banno51.0
- 14Corvus50.1
- 15litewave48.0
Threads
Threads with the most uses
Threads ranked by total uses of the family's keywords.
- 1"What is truth? said jesting Pilate; and would not stay for an answer."1,988
- 2A -> not-A1,797
- 3The Liar Paradox - Is it even a valid statement?1,715
- 4A challenge to Frege on assertion1,470
- 5Logical Nihilism1,369
- 6An Analysis of "On Certainty"1,198
- 7Debate Discussion: "The content of belief is propositional".1,127
- 8The Shoutbox1,070
- 9Do (A implies B) and (A implies notB) contradict each other?1,057
- 10Is the distinction between metaphysical realism & anti realism useless and/or wrong1,034
- 11Ukraine Crisis1,028
- 12Thoughts on Epistemology994
- 13Philosophical Investigations, reading it together.974
- 14SEP reading on possibility and actuality970
- 15A Summary of the "Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus"969
Threads
Threads most given over to it
Uses per 10,000 words of the thread, among threads of a substantial length.
- 1The Liar Paradox - Is it even a valid statement?333
- 2Attempt at an intuitive explanation (ELI12) for the weirdest logic theorem ever (Godel-Carnap)297
- 3Does Tarski Undefinability apply to HOL ?283
- 4Where does logic get its power?283
- 5A question concerning formal modal logic282
- 6Is Truth an Inconsistent Concept?263
- 7What is Logic?263
- 8Fitch's paradox of Knowability260
- 9The Full Import of Paradoxes255
- 10Is Logic "Fundamental" to Reality?250
- 11How do we justify logic?249
- 12Abstractions of Godel Incompleteness243
- 13The 9 Prime Directives of Reasoning.233
- 14A -> not-A229
- 15References for discussion of truth as predication?223
About these figures. The keyword list is hand-picked and deliberately narrow, so a thread can be about this subject without scoring highly here. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.