The Agora Almanac

Member profile / first post January 2023

Mark S

Mark S wrote 306 posts on The Philosophy Forum between 18 January 2023 and 19 October 2025: 292 comments and 14 opening posts.

That places them 335th of 4,083 members by number of posts, inside the top 10% of the archive. Their busiest year was 2023, with 204 posts.

In all they wrote about 60,000 words of their own, quotations excluded. A typical post of theirs runs to 147 words; the forum-wide median for a comment is 52.

In the reply network Mark S belongs to the cluster Language and logic: 86 members who mostly answer one another.

306
Posts
335th of 4,083 members
14
Threads opened
292 comments in 18 threads
59,620
Words written
147 in a typical post
106
Days active
over 2 years and 9 months
531
Replies given
514 received

Activity

Posts per month

Opening posts and comments together. The busiest month was June 2023, with 41 posts; Mark S posted in 13 months of the archive's 125 and on 106 separate days.

0255020162017201820192020202120222023202420252026
YearPostsShare of their postsRank that year
202320467%outside top 25
20246020%outside top 25
20254214%outside top 25

Threads

Where they commented most

Mark S commented in 18 threads. The twelve below account for 94% of their comments.

  1. 1What if cultural moral norms track cooperation strategies?43
  2. 2The science of morality from the bottom-up and the top-down35
  3. 3What the science of morality studies and its relationship to moral philosophy35
  4. 4The value of conditional oughts in defining moral systems25
  5. 5Is there a "moral fact" about the function of cultural moral norms and our moral sense?24
  6. 6Defining what the Science of Morality Studies23
  7. 7Morality as Cooperation Strategies is complementary to consequentialism21
  8. 8Bernard Gert's answer to the question "But what makes it moral?"19
  9. 9Judging moral 'means' separately from moral 'ends'16
  10. 10How Morality as Cooperation Can Help Resolve Moral Disputes16
  11. 11Blurring the Moral Realist vs. Anti-Realist Distinction10
  12. 12Implications for Morality as Cooperation Strategies of Nazis cooperating to do evil7

Threads

Threads they opened

Mark S opened 14 threads; a typical one drew 65 comments. The ten that drew the most comments are listed.

  1. 1Is there a "moral fact" about the function of cultural moral norms and our moral sense?2025113
  2. 2What the science of morality studies and its relationship to moral philosophy2024108
  3. 3What if cultural moral norms track cooperation strategies?2023105
  4. 4The science of morality from the bottom-up and the top-down2023104
  5. 5Bernard Gert's answer to the question "But what makes it moral?"202372
  6. 6Defining what the Science of Morality Studies202467
  7. 7Morality as Cooperation Strategies is complementary to consequentialism202365
  8. 8The value of conditional oughts in defining moral systems202362
  9. 9Judging moral 'means' separately from moral 'ends'202342
  10. 10Implications for Morality as Cooperation Strategies of Nazis cooperating to do evil202336

Vocabulary

Signature words

Tracked words that Mark S uses unusually often compared with the forum as a whole; larger means more distinctive. The small figure is how many times they used the word. Profanity, insults and a few charged terms are left out of these lists.

Vocabulary

Subject mix

Uses of each subject family's keywords per 10,000 words written by Mark S, beside the forum-wide rate.

Reading

Thinkers named most

How often Mark S names each thinker in their own words, counting related forms such as "Kantian".

  1. 1Kant26
  2. 2Protagoras14
  3. 3Socrates11
  4. 4Rawls10
  5. 5Hobbes6
  6. 6Mackie6
  7. 7Plato5
  8. 8Hume5
  9. 9Hegel4
  10. 10Sam Harris4

Vocabulary

Closest vocabulary

Members whose choice of words is most like that of Mark S, by cosine similarity of word profiles (1 would be identical). It measures shared subject matter, not agreement.

Conversation

Replied to most

Mark S quoted or replied to other members 531 times, reaching 43 different members.

  1. 1Tom Storm62
  2. 2neomac49
  3. 3Banno47
  4. 4180 Proof38
  5. 5Bob Ross31
  6. 6Philosophim25
  7. 7Joshs18
  8. 8PhilosophyRunner16
  9. 9wonderer115
  10. 10SophistiCat14

Conversation

Most replies from

Mark S was quoted or replied to 514 times, by 52 different members.

  1. 1Tom Storm61
  2. 2neomac44
  3. 3Banno42
  4. 4Philosophim29
  5. 5180 Proof24
  6. 6AmadeusD19
  7. 7Metaphysician Undercover17
  8. 8Joshs17
  9. 9Chet Hawkins16
  10. 10Bob Ross15

Record

At a glance

First post
18 January 2023 (January 2023)
Last post
19 October 2025 (October 2025)
Span
2 years and 9 months
Cohort
First posted in 2023, with 114 others
Rank by posts
335th of 4,083
Busiest year
2023 (204 posts)
Longest post
1,512 words
Days with a post
106
Network cluster
Language and logic

About these figures. Member names are the public handles shown in the archive. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.