The Agora Almanac

Thinker / rank 149 of 168

Mackie

Mackie is named 126 times in members' own writing on The Philosophy Forum, counting the form "mackie". The name was used by 36 members and appears in 55 threads.

That makes Mackie the 149th most-cited of the 168 thinkers the almanac tracks, at 0.121 mentions per 100,000 words. Among full calendar years the rate was highest in 2016, when Mackie ranked 142nd.

Named in at least three places in 14 threads, which is the test used for "discussed in" elsewhere on this page.

126
Mentions
149th of 168 thinkers
0.121
Per 100,000 words
whole archive
36
Members naming
under 1% of all members
55
Threads
14 with three or more mentions
2016
Peak year
ranked 142nd that year

Trend

Mentions per 100,000 words, by year

Relative to everything written in the year, so busy and quiet years compare fairly. 2015 covers October to December only and 2026 ends on 25 February.

0 0.250 0.500 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Year Uses Per 100,000 words Rank among thinkers
2015 (part) 3 0.425 76th
2016 3 0.075 142nd
2017 8 0.091 141st
2018 2 0.021 162nd
2019 2 0.018 160th
2020 17 0.145 129th
2021 25 0.173 139th
2022 15 0.133 138th
2023 13 0.123 141st
2024 9 0.086 148th
2025 29 0.303 109th
2026 (part) 0 0 155th

People

Who names Mackie most

Members ranked by number of mentions in their own words.

  1. 1Constance31
  2. 2Banno8
  3. 3Paulm128
  4. 4Astrophel6
  5. 5Mark S6
  6. 6Showmee6
  7. 7Relativist5
  8. 8Olivier55
  9. 9SophistiCat4
  10. 10Chany4
  11. 11J4
  12. 12Postmodern Beatnik3

Threads

Threads with the most mentions

Threads ranked by number of mentions.

  1. 1Moral-realism vs Moral-antirealism12
  2. 2Midgley vs Dawkins, Nietzsche, Hobbes, Mackie, Rand, Singer...9
  3. 3The self8
  4. 4Metaethics and moral realism8
  5. 5What is right and what is wrong and how do we know?8
  6. 6What if cultural moral norms track cooperation strategies?4
  7. 7Is the distinction between metaphysical realism & anti realism useless and/or wrong4
  8. 8A complex meta-ethics3
  9. 9Mackie vs Aquinas3
  10. 10The meta-ethical semantics between moral realism and moral anti-realism3
  11. 11A Case for Moral Anti-realism3
  12. 12The essence of religion3

Company

Named alongside

Thinkers most closely associated with Mackie: ranked by how often the two are discussed in the same thread, relative to how often each is discussed at all. The figure is the number of threads in which both are named at least three times.

  1. 1Tarski4 threads
  2. 2Quine6 threads
  3. 3Derrida6 threads
  4. 4Anscombe3 threads
  5. 5Levinas3 threads
  6. 6Rorty4 threads
  7. 7Kripke4 threads
  8. 8Dewey3 threads
  9. 9Wittgenstein9 threads
  10. 10Heraclitus3 threads

Method

Forms counted

Every word form that is added into this thinker's total.

  • mackie126

About these figures. A mention is a use of one of the listed word forms; the count cannot tell approval from criticism, or one bearer of a surname from another. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.