Member profile / first post September 2023
J
J wrote 2,454 posts on The Philosophy Forum between 26 September 2023 and 20 February 2026: 2,435 comments and 19 opening posts.
That places them 107th of 4,083 members by number of posts, inside the top 10% of the archive. Their busiest year was 2025, with 1,639 posts.
In all they wrote about 357,000 words of their own, quotations excluded. A typical post of theirs runs to 100 words; the forum-wide median for a comment is 52. They were still posting at the end of the archive, in February 2026.
In the reply network J belongs to the cluster Language and logic: 86 members who mostly answer one another.
Activity
Posts per month
Opening posts and comments together. The busiest month was June 2025, with 244 posts; J posted in 30 months of the archive's 125 and on 545 separate days.
Threads
Where they commented most
J commented in 179 threads. The twelve below account for 39% of their comments.
- 1p and "I think p"132
- 2A challenge to Frege on assertion127
- 3What is faith93
- 4Must Do Better86
- 5Mathematical platonism80
- 6Is Philosophy the "Highest" Discourse?77
- 7What is real? How do we know what is real?75
- 8Can a Thought Cause Another Thought?74
- 9Two ways to philosophise.64
- 10Quine: Reference and Modality54
- 11The Mind-Created World53
- 12Thoughts on Epistemology44
Threads
Threads they opened
J opened 19 threads; a typical one drew 113 comments. The ten that drew the most comments are listed.
- 1A challenge to Frege on assertion2024757
- 2p and "I think p"2025624
- 3Is Philosophy the "Highest" Discourse?2024416
- 4Quantifier Variance, Ontological Pluralism, and Other Fun Stuff2024312
- 5Can a Thought Cause Another Thought?2025310
- 6References for discussion of mental-to-mental causation?2025292
- 7"Distinctively Logical Explanations": Can thought explain being?2024189
- 8"On the Very Idea of a Conceptual Scheme"2023141
- 9Question for Aristotelians2025136
- 10Bernard Williams and the "Absolute Conception"2025113
Vocabulary
Signature words
Tracked words that J uses unusually often compared with the forum as a whole; larger means more distinctive. The small figure is how many times they used the word. Profanity, insults and a few charged terms are left out of these lists.
Vocabulary
Subject mix
Uses of each subject family's keywords per 10,000 words written by J, beside the forum-wide rate.
Reading
Thinkers named most
How often J names each thinker in their own words, counting related forms such as "Kantian".
Vocabulary
Closest vocabulary
Members whose choice of words is most like that of J, by cosine similarity of word profiles (1 would be identical). It measures shared subject matter, not agreement.
- Leontiskos5,611 posts0.47
- Banno31,280 posts0.42
- Astrophel665 posts0.37
- Joshs6,788 posts0.36
- Constance1,406 posts0.35
Conversation
Replied to most
J quoted or replied to other members 3,915 times, reaching 136 different members.
- 1Banno482
- 2Count Timothy von Icarus421
- 3Wayfarer352
- 4Janus173
- 5Leontiskos169
- 6Srap Tasmaner154
- 7Ludwig V148
- 8Patterner117
- 9Joshs112
- 10frank107
Conversation
Most replies from
J was quoted or replied to 4,066 times, by 127 different members.
- 1Leontiskos551
- 2Banno491
- 3Wayfarer265
- 4Count Timothy von Icarus246
- 5Ludwig V187
- 6Janus170
- 7Joshs154
- 8Patterner145
- 9frank121
- 10Srap Tasmaner112
Record
At a glance
- First post
- 26 September 2023 (September 2023)
- Last post
- 20 February 2026 (February 2026)
- Span
- 2 years and 5 months
- Cohort
- First posted in 2023, with 114 others
- Rank by posts
- 107th of 4,083
- Busiest year
- 2025 (1,639 posts)
- Longest post
- 1,900 words
- Days with a post
- 545
- Network cluster
- Language and logic
About these figures. Member names are the public handles shown in the archive. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.