The Agora Almanac

Section 06 / Network / Cluster 1 of 6

Cosmos and consciousness

Members who mostly answer one another about physics, cosmology and the place of mind in nature. 101 members of the 400 most prolific fall into this cluster; between them they wrote 153,439 posts, 15% of the archive.

Of the replies its members sent to others on the map, 39% went to fellow members of the cluster.

Its most prolific members are 180 Proof, TheMadFool, Agent Smith. Membership describes who a member answered most, not what they believe.

101
Members
of 400 on the map
153,439
Posts by its members
15% of the archive
39%
Replies kept inside
share sent to fellow members

Fig. 1

Words that mark the cluster

Words its members use unusually often compared with the forum as a whole, with each member's contribution capped so that no one voice defines the group.

Fig. 2

Strongest ties inside the cluster

Pairs of members in the cluster, by replies exchanged in both directions.

  1. 1180 Proof and Agent Smith1,857
  2. 2180 Proof and TheMadFool1,417
  3. 3universeness and Vera Mont1,139
  4. 4180 Proof and Jack Cummins1,134
  5. 5universeness and Hillary1,064
  6. 6Athena and Vera Mont831
  7. 7180 Proof and Gnomon825
  8. 8universeness and EugeneW745
  9. 9Athena and universeness735
  10. 10180 Proof and universeness717
  11. 11Agent Smith and universeness637
  12. 12TheMadFool and Jack Cummins604
  13. 13PoeticUniverse and Gnomon572
  14. 14Alkis Piskas and universeness537
  15. 15Gnomon and Agent Smith529

Fig. 3

Threads where its members gathered

Comments by members of the cluster, summed over each member's twelve most-visited threads.

  1. 1The Shoutbox2,312
  2. 2Culture is critical1,173
  3. 3Emergence936
  4. 4The Invalidity of Atheism908
  5. 5Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)750
  6. 6Antinatalism Arguments742
  7. 7Israel killing civilians in Gaza and the West Bank572
  8. 8A new argument for antinatalism551
  9. 9Currently Reading549
  10. 10The Subjectivity of Moral Values517
  11. 11What are your positions on the arguments for God?484
  12. 12What is Information?446

Fig. 4

The 101 members

Click a heading to sort.

180 Proof 16,469 17,492 14,752 2015 2021
TheMadFool 13,954 15,957 15,517 2016 2021
Agent Smith 9,469 7,670 7,210 2021 2022
universeness 6,312 9,862 7,528 2022 2022
Bartricks 5,999 8,715 8,011 2019 2021
Jack Cummins 5,753 5,305 6,156 2020 2021
god must be atheist 5,130 4,487 4,169 2019 2019
Gnomon 5,022 6,677 6,541 2019 2020
Gregory 4,968 3,213 4,293 2019 2021
Vera Mont 4,827 7,379 5,852 2022 2023
Athena 3,858 4,168 4,627 2018 2021
Pantagruel 3,570 2,811 3,277 2019 2023
3017amen 3,143 3,723 3,031 2019 2020
Ciceronianus 3,125 2,761 3,528 2015 2021
Possibility 2,942 4,420 4,588 2019 2020
Benj96 2,379 2,380 3,380 2020 2022
bert1 2,234 1,897 2,102 2015 2023
Alkis Piskas 2,147 3,762 2,418 2021 2022
L'elephant 1,934 2,222 1,773 2021 2022
Hillary 1,922 1,996 1,691 2022 2022
Jackson 1,766 1,647 1,549 2022 2022
PoeticUniverse 1,755 1,565 1,401 2019 2019
EugeneW 1,713 1,534 1,334 2022 2022
Valentinus 1,666 1,565 1,318 2018 2021
Pop 1,523 1,965 1,841 2020 2021
ToothyMaw 1,461 2,023 1,599 2020 2021
Tobias 1,177 1,677 1,783 2018 2022
Nickolasgaspar 1,140 1,955 1,509 2021 2022
Cheshire 1,090 1,282 1,107 2018 2021
Cuthbert 1,074 699 902 2017 2022
Darkneos 1,044 1,310 1,537 2020 2023
Prishon 984 766 670 2021 2021
Gus Lamarch 937 1,157 982 2019 2020
dimosthenis9 846 1,206 987 2021 2021
Enrique 845 789 1,073 2019 2021
TiredThinker 842 413 1,391 2020 2022
Raymond 816 756 653 2021 2022
punos 809 1,225 994 2021 2025
Haglund 802 802 684 2022 2022
Mark Nyquist 797 680 752 2021 2021
EricH 796 1,101 980 2019 2020
Existential Hope 789 812 941 2022 2022
EnPassant 734 722 734 2018 2020
Eugen 705 941 800 2017 2020
john27 695 724 530 2021 2021
Yohan 679 579 797 2019 2022
ovdtogt 671 676 528 2019 2019
magritte 639 664 583 2020 2020
Daemon 633 563 742 2020 2021
Zelebg 626 568 681 2019 2020
A Seagull 619 570 522 2017 2020
invicta 595 365 604 2023 2023
Leghorn 584 343 677 2020 2021
Down The Rabbit Hole 568 1,084 738 2020 2021
Michael McMahon 546 61 111 2019 2021
skyblack 544 410 331 2021 2021
SpaceDweller 523 689 619 2021 2022
prothero 516 374 482 2017 2020
Ennui Elucidator 511 552 628 2021 2021
Heracloitus 505 382 447 2018 2021
Amalac 489 1,030 689 2021 2021
TheHedoMinimalist 473 792 812 2018 2021
Average 470 399 392 2020 2022
Daniel 462 549 577 2018 2020
kudos 423 338 530 2018 2023
Michael Zwingli 416 508 431 2021 2021
lll 391 440 278 2022 2022
boagie 385 227 295 2021 2021
Angelo Cannata 383 288 536 2022 2022
charles ferraro 370 306 472 2018 2021
Mapping the Medium 366 271 312 2019 2020
uncanni 359 345 335 2019 2019
Chany 352 300 338 2017 2017
introbert 333 190 312 2022 2022
jas0n 328 406 333 2022 2022
Varde 327 108 221 2021 2022
PhilosophyRunner 322 314 367 2022 2023
Deus 320 188 350 2021 2022
chiknsld 314 443 320 2022 2022
GraveItty 311 310 268 2021 2021
Sir Philo Sophia 303 404 269 2020 2020
Seppo 276 329 318 2021 2022
spirit-salamander 268 432 444 2021 2021
Dharmi 264 269 271 2021 2021
Bret Bernhoft 260 173 373 2021 2022
theRiddler 260 28 122 2021 2022
neonspectraltoast 259 44 186 2020 2020
Shwah 259 239 261 2022 2022
Moses 250 385 321 2022 2022
Cartuna 246 226 238 2021 2021
Cornwell1 241 234 242 2022 2022
MAYAEL 239 117 175 2020 2021
SolarWind 237 197 279 2021 2021
Congau 228 291 375 2019 2020
Josh Alfred 227 79 165 2019 2019
Cartesian trigger-puppets 222 498 411 2021 2021
TheMadMan 221 277 281 2019 2023
stoicHoneyBadger 219 242 354 2021 2022
hope 216 209 188 2021 2021
Fine Doubter 214 145 156 2019 2021
Seeker 214 129 105 2022 2022

About these figures. Clusters are computed from reply counts alone; the name is editorial shorthand. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.