The Agora Almanac

Section 05 / Timeline / Month

April 2023

Members of The Philosophy Forum wrote 9,550 posts in April 2023: 98 opening posts and 9,452 comments, running to about 1.0 million words. 148 members posted, 8 of them for the first time.

By number of posts it ranks 33rd of the archive's 125 months. 98 threads were opened, and 169 threads received at least one comment.

The most active thread was The Shoutbox, with 1,571 comments in the month.

9,550
Posts
33rd of 125 months
148
Members posting
8 for the first time
98
Threads opened
169 threads active
1.0 million
Words written
106 per post
475
Posts on the busiest day
4 April 2023

Fig. 1

Posts per day in April 2023

Days are UTC. The busiest was 4 April 2023, with 475 posts, 179 of them in Neuroscience is of no relevance to the problem of consciousness.

0 250 500 1 8 15 22 29

Fig. 2

Most active threads

Comments posted during April 2023, whenever the thread was opened.

  1. 1The Shoutbox1,571
  2. 2Is indirect realism self undermining?849
  3. 3Neuroscience is of no relevance to the problem of consciousness692
  4. 4[Ontology] Donald Hoffman's denial of materialism291
  5. 5Definitions have no place in philosophy269
  6. 6Is communism realistic/feasible?242
  7. 7Ukraine Crisis239
  8. 8Exploring the artificially intelligent mind of GPT4228
  9. 9On Chomsky's annoying mysterianism.193
  10. 10Problems studying the Subjective178
  11. 11Consciousness - Fundamental or Emergent Model178
  12. 12Aesthetic reasons to believe170
  13. 13Zizek's view on consciousness - serious or bananas?167
  14. 14Ontological arguments for idealism159
  15. 15Martin Heidegger154

Fig. 3

Most active members

Posts written during April 2023.

  1. 1plaque flag1,140
  2. 2Jamal618
  3. 3Michael354
  4. 4T_Clark300
  5. 5Banno288
  6. 6180 Proof286
  7. 7javi2541997273
  8. 8Wayfarer262
  9. 9Tom Storm257
  10. 10frank251
  11. 11Hanover240
  12. 12Fooloso4240
  13. 13invicta230
  14. 14Isaac214
  15. 15Janus203

Fig. 4

The words of April 2023

Tracked words used unusually often this month compared with the archive as a whole: used by at least five members in the month, with no one member supplying more than 35% of the uses. Larger means more distinctive; the small figure is the number of uses.

Fig. 5

98 threads opened in April 2023

98 listed

Every thread started this month, with the comments it went on to draw by the end of the archive.

Neuroscience is of no relevance to the problem of consciousness bert1 3 Apr 2023 766 43
Why Monism? Art48 23 Apr 2023 300 26
Definitions have no place in philosophy Jamal 10 Apr 2023 269 29
Is communism realistic/feasible? jorndoe 18 Apr 2023 244 21
A potential solution to the hard problem Luke 30 Apr 2023 239 36
Analyticity and Chomskyan Linguistics Banno 25 Apr 2023 238 16
Will Science Eventually Replace Religion? Art48 29 Apr 2023 231 26
On Chomsky's annoying mysterianism. Eugen 7 Apr 2023 193 16
Problems studying the Subjective Andrew4Handel 5 Apr 2023 178 18
Consciousness - Fundamental or Emergent Model Eugen 26 Apr 2023 178 16
Aesthetic reasons to believe Tom Storm 11 Apr 2023 170 16
Zizek's view on consciousness - serious or bananas? Eugen 15 Apr 2023 167 13
Where Philosophy Went Wrong Fooloso4 16 Apr 2023 152 23
Real numbers and the Stern-Brocot tree keystone 25 Apr 2023 128 5
How the Myth of the Self Endures frank 15 Apr 2023 124 17
Politics fuels hatred. We can do better. AntonioP 6 Apr 2023 118 17
Pop Philosophy and Its Usefulness Mikie 4 Apr 2023 114 16
Is truth always context independent ? invicta 19 Apr 2023 113 16
Is The US A One-Party State? BC 23 Apr 2023 110 24
What is Conservatism? Vera Mont 7 Apr 2023 97 17
Reasons to call Jesus God Art48 4 Apr 2023 95 12
Replacing matter as fundamental: does it change anything? Eugen 29 Apr 2023 89 19
Modified Version of Anselm's Ontological Argument Epicero 19 Apr 2023 88 18
The hard problem of matter. TheMadMan 2 Apr 2023 84 17
Bunge's Ten Criticisms of Philosophy Art48 1 Apr 2023 81 17
Nothing is hidden plaque flag 21 Apr 2023 77 11
What is neoliberalism? Jamal 28 Apr 2023 66 10
Why the Hard Problem is so Relevant to Axiology and Ethics schopenhauer1 14 Apr 2023 65 5
Guest Speaker: Noam Chomsky Mikie 19 Apr 2023 64 41
The nature of man...inherently good or bad? invicta 30 Apr 2023 64 15
Inmost Core and Ultimate Ground Art48 14 Apr 2023 60 12
The Hard problem and E=mc2 Benj96 4 Apr 2023 53 9
In the brain Andrew4Handel 18 Apr 2023 53 16
Right-sized Government Vera Mont 23 Apr 2023 51 18
Does vocabulary have negative connotations? javi2541997 16 Apr 2023 48 6
Are sensations mind dependent? lorenzo sleakes 10 Apr 2023 47 14
What is a good definition of libertarian free will? Cidat 12 Apr 2023 43 13
Hegel and the Understanding of Divine/Supernatural Experiences ClayG 15 Apr 2023 42 7
Dilemma Paul 8 Apr 2023 41 21
Tristan Harris and Aza Raskin, warn about AI universeness 11 Apr 2023 40 12
When Adorno was cancelled Jamal 30 Apr 2023 36 9
Are you receiving email notifications for private messages? Jamal 12 Apr 2023 34 10
Chomsky on ChatGPT Mikie 20 Apr 2023 34 14
Why INPUT driven AI will never be intelligent invicta 23 Apr 2023 31 9
If there was a God what characteristics would they have? TiredThinker 3 Apr 2023 23 9
The meaning or purpose of life Average 19 Apr 2023 23 8
Uploading images Mark Nyquist 25 Apr 2023 23 8
Temporality in Infinite Time invicta 28 Apr 2023 23 9
Philosophical implications of contacting higher intelligences through AI-powered communication tools Bret Bernhoft 15 Apr 2023 22 8
What were your undergraduate textbooks? Largo 18 Apr 2023 22 9
Unjustified Skepticism Andrew4Handel 22 Apr 2023 22 9
A life without wants schopenhauer1 14 Apr 2023 21 13
Knocking back The Simulation Theory invicta 17 Apr 2023 20 8
The Importance of Divine Hiddenness for Human Free Will and Moral Growth gevgala 15 Apr 2023 19 13
The Central Tenets of Justice invicta 19 Apr 2023 19 8
On order, logic, the mind and reality. Benj96 30 Apr 2023 19 5
Why Would God Actually be against Homosexuality Katiee 14 Apr 2023 18 8
Micromanaging god versus initial conditions? TiredThinker 28 Apr 2023 18 9
Why is the philosophy forum Green now? Benj96 5 Apr 2023 17 9
Naturalism problem of evil Ishika 16 Apr 2023 17 7
English Words mixing Contexts Judaka 7 Apr 2023 15 7
Environmentalism and the cost of doing nothing invicta 16 Apr 2023 15 6
Grammatical analysis help boethius 25 Apr 2023 15 3
Plato's allegory of the cave an-salad 8 Apr 2023 14 9
Karma. Anyone understand it? TiredThinker 16 Apr 2023 13 9
A Normative Crowbar plaque flag 14 Apr 2023 12 3
Christians Should Question their Beliefs Katiee 14 Apr 2023 11 10
Life is more than who we are? TiredThinker 19 Apr 2023 11 6
The necessary good and evil invicta 1 Apr 2023 10 4
What is a good life? invicta 2 Apr 2023 10 5
An Argument Against Culturists Epicero 18 Apr 2023 10 6
The Fall and Rise of Philosophy Art48 18 Apr 2023 10 9
An Evidentialists Perspective on Faith Epicero 19 Apr 2023 10 5
The Wave Art48 22 Apr 2023 10 8
You can go to jail for using ChatGpt? RogueAI 11 Apr 2023 8 5
Response to Common Objection of Pascal's Wager Katiee 14 Apr 2023 8 7
God and Incremental Morality RogueAI 23 Apr 2023 8 6
One Is One Around Here plaque flag 5 Apr 2023 7 3
Philosophy of Law; Legislation, Access to Just Remedy, Application of Rights, Legal deliberation. Alexander Hine 19 Apr 2023 7 3
Stories/fictions and music as covert devices for speaking of actualities/truths Benj96 29 Apr 2023 7 5
Collective intelligence and collective moral Benj96 3 Apr 2023 6 5
Ethics of Fox Hunting invicta 4 Apr 2023 6 4
Morals made simple jorndoe 14 Apr 2023 6 5
We Should Not Speculate About Heaven ClayG 15 Apr 2023 6 6
Causal chains and culpability. Benj96 5 Apr 2023 4 3
Component Entities, Acts, Ultimate Ground of Existence, and God Art48 8 Apr 2023 4 3
When is tax avoidance acceptable invicta 13 Apr 2023 4 4
Elsewhere, elsewhen Ishika 15 Apr 2023 4 4
If Kant is Right, Then We Should Stop Doing Rational Theology ClayG 15 Apr 2023 4 4
Is silence golden? Bret Bernhoft 16 Apr 2023 4 4
Twins are weird Benj96 1 Apr 2023 3 3
Looking for philosophy that fits this theory combination. Caerulea-Lawrence 8 Apr 2023 3 3
Artificial intelligence, autonomy and economy Benj96 3 Apr 2023 2 1
Simplicity of naturalist vs. theist hypothesis claims Ishika 16 Apr 2023 1 1
Can you give me more info on Nietzsche's - Tree on a Hill? empleat 2 Apr 2023 0 0
Ethic of AI -> The prevailing issues in data capture and capitalism Mojo 14 Apr 2023 0 0
Moral bindingness and ultimate goals are subjective, moral 'means' are objective Mark S 26 Apr 2023 0 0
May 3 Wittgenstein forum: Paper on imagination by Hanoch Ben-Yami Antony Nickles 27 Apr 2023 0 0

About these figures. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.