The Agora Almanac

Section 05 / Timeline / Month

July 2019

Members of The Philosophy Forum wrote 9,107 posts in July 2019: 162 opening posts and 8,945 comments, running to about 890,000 words. 205 members posted, 66 of them for the first time.

By number of posts it ranks 47th of the archive's 125 months. 166 threads were opened, and 243 threads received at least one comment.

The most active thread was On Antinatalism, with 625 comments in the month.

9,107
Posts
47th of 125 months
205
Members posting
66 for the first time
166
Threads opened
243 threads active
890,000
Words written
98 per post
480
Posts on the busiest day
24 July 2019

Fig. 1

Posts per day in July 2019

Days are UTC. The busiest was 24 July 2019, with 480 posts, 217 of them in What is Mind? What is Matter? Is idealism vs. materialism a confusion?.

0 250 500 1 8 15 22 29

Fig. 2

Most active threads

Comments posted during July 2019, whenever the thread was opened.

  1. 1On Antinatalism625
  2. 2Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)383
  3. 3Are science and religion compatible?305
  4. 4A Proof for the Existence of God248
  5. 5Reading Group, Preface to Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit, trans. Walter Kaufman.247
  6. 6Language is not moving information from one head to another.239
  7. 7Do we need objective truth?229
  8. 8What is Mind? What is Matter? Is idealism vs. materialism a confusion?220
  9. 9Let's Talk About Meaning213
  10. 10The HARDER Problem of Consciousness201
  11. 11Are philosophical problems language on holiday?197
  12. 12Seeing things as they are188
  13. 13The Universe Cannot Have Existed 'Forever'187
  14. 14Claim: There is valid information supplied by the images in the cave wall in the Republic163
  15. 15Musings On Infinity149

Fig. 3

Most active members

Posts written during July 2019.

  1. 1Terrapin Station817
  2. 2regularguy425
  3. 3god must be atheist378
  4. 4Shawn297
  5. 5Marchesk261
  6. 6Fooloso4259
  7. 7Janus247
  8. 8creativesoul233
  9. 9S224
  10. 10T_Clark211
  11. 11khaled206
  12. 12Amity203
  13. 13Wayfarer199
  14. 14BC190
  15. 15Devans99178

Fig. 4

The words of July 2019

Tracked words used unusually often this month compared with the archive as a whole: used by at least five members in the month, with no one member supplying more than 35% of the uses. Larger means more distinctive; the small figure is the number of uses.

Fig. 5

166 threads opened in July 2019

166 listed

Every thread started this month, with the comments it went on to draw by the end of the archive.

On Antinatalism Shawn 11 Jul 2019 1,850 55
Reflections on Realism Dfpolis 31 Jul 2019 418 18
Reading Group, Preface to Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit, trans. Walter Kaufman. a deleted account 9 Jul 2019 385 16
Are science and religion compatible? Matias 28 Jul 2019 356 27
The basics of free will Possibility 20 Jul 2019 332 25
Let's Talk About Meaning creativesoul 21 Jul 2019 290 26
A Proof for the Existence of God Dfpolis 4 Jul 2019 248 25
What is Mind? What is Matter? Is idealism vs. materialism a confusion? regularguy 24 Jul 2019 222 14
Anarchy, State, and Market Failure Virgo Avalytikh 29 Jul 2019 209 15
The HARDER Problem of Consciousness Marchesk 5 Jul 2019 201 17
Are philosophical problems language on holiday? Marchesk 10 Jul 2019 197 15
Seeing things as they are leo 9 Jul 2019 188 16
The Universe Cannot Have Existed 'Forever' Devans99 10 Jul 2019 187 14
I Simply Can't Function Without My Blanket! Streetlight 14 Jul 2019 143 18
What's it all made of? Razorback kitten 20 Jul 2019 135 20
Why doesn't the "mosaic" God lead by example? BrianW 15 Jul 2019 132 18
Boris Johnson (All General Boris Conversations Here) a deleted account 23 Jul 2019 128 26
Platonic Realism and Its Relation to Physical Objects Wayfarer 5 Jul 2019 125 14
Almost 80 Percent of Philosophy Majors Favor Socialism Shawn 17 Jul 2019 112 20
Betsy Ross: Racist swine BC 3 Jul 2019 105 14
The Foundations of Mathematics Dfpolis 20 Jul 2019 105 11
Epistemic standard for spiritual knowledge? regularguy 31 Jul 2019 104 10
Philosophers are humourless gits Amity 5 Jul 2019 100 15
Concerning the fallacy of scientism alcontali 29 Jul 2019 100 15
Does consciousness = Awareness/Attention? Basko 19 Jul 2019 96 17
Important Unknowns Andrew4Handel 20 Jul 2019 95 12
Neurophenomenology and the Real Problem of Consciousness Marchesk 13 Jul 2019 94 19
I am horsed Marchesk 20 Jul 2019 92 10
The emotional meaning of ritual and icon unenlightened 3 Jul 2019 90 14
Free Will or an illusion and how this makes us feel. AwazawA 7 Jul 2019 83 9
Is it prudent to go to college? TheHedoMinimalist 6 Jul 2019 74 12
An epistemological proof of the external world. Shawn 7 Jul 2019 73 9
The most wonderful life. unenlightened 21 Jul 2019 70 11
Understanding suicide. Shawn 3 Jul 2019 69 24
A Query about Noam Chomsky's Political Philosophy Virgo Avalytikh 26 Jul 2019 65 12
Is Revenge Hopeless? Etzsche 6 Jul 2019 63 7
Zeno and Immortality TheMadFool 13 Jul 2019 63 20
There is no Real You. Filipe 17 Jul 2019 63 14
Sorites paradox and an aspect of objectivity TheMadFool 6 Jul 2019 54 8
Answering the cosmic riddle of existence Razorback kitten 26 Jul 2019 54 14
Atheism versus Agnostism christian2017 2 Jul 2019 53 11
When do we begin to have personhood? a deleted account 27 Jul 2019 51 8
What is the difference between God and the Theory of Everything? TheMadFool 4 Jul 2019 49 14
Work should be based on quantity of boredom involved schopenhauer1 6 Jul 2019 49 9
Are you a genius? Try solving this difficult Logic / Critical Reasoning problem Alexis Schaffer 17 Jul 2019 49 21
Awareness and intent: Discrimination a deleted account 3 Jul 2019 48 7
''Not giving a fuck'' as an alternative to morality as we know it Three-Buddy Problem 15 Jul 2019 48 7
Italy's immigration-security decree and its consequences Patulia 12 Jul 2019 46 10
The common man has always been there and endured it all. Brett 3 Jul 2019 45 6
The Principle Of Sufficient Reason Devans99 14 Jul 2019 45 8
The Identity and Morality of a soldier SethRy 21 Jul 2019 45 13
What is a scientific attitude? Jorge 14 Jul 2019 43 11
Is it moral for our governments to impose poverty on us? Gnostic Christian Bishop 18 Jul 2019 43 7
Why there must be free will Pantagruel 20 Jul 2019 42 7
I can't know that I know about many things regularguy 25 Jul 2019 42 8
Identity Politics or The Politics of Difference regularguy 27 Jul 2019 42 10
Equanimity, as true happiness. Shawn 23 Jul 2019 41 9
In what capacity did God exist before religion came about, if at all? How do we know this? Maureen 1 Jul 2019 36 13
The Problem Of Consent Andrew4Handel 10 Jul 2019 36 8
What are the philosophical equivalents of the laws of nature? Denovo Meme 31 Jul 2019 35 11
Dream Characters with Minds of their Own Shawn 14 Jul 2019 34 8
Hume on why we use induction Wheatley 24 Jul 2019 32 11
We Don't Matter SimonSays 13 Jul 2019 31 21
What do we really know? Pantagruel 31 Jul 2019 31 9
Wittgenstein's solipsist from Tractatus. Shawn 8 Jul 2019 30 5
The concept of independent thing leo 1 Jul 2019 28 13
Proof of god is a moral question. Do you see the morals shown for god as good or evil? Gnostic Christian Bishop 9 Jul 2019 28 8
If Post Modernism was correct christian2017 2 Jul 2019 27 6
Does the bible promote Veganism? chatterbears 16 Jul 2019 26 7
Where on the evolutionary scale does individuality begin? Jacob-B 28 Jul 2019 26 7
Is it an unwritten community laws/custom, to demand factual proof when making a reasoned opinion? god must be atheist 22 Jul 2019 25 9
Can you lie but at the same time tell the truth? Patulia 11 Jul 2019 24 17
What is laziness? Wheatley 15 Jul 2019 24 14
On perfection Patulia 26 Jul 2019 24 10
My psychological torture and constant harassment regularguy 3 Jul 2019 23 5
Is thinking logic? Brett 9 Jul 2019 23 8
Why should an individual matter? DanielPhil 28 Jul 2019 23 11
Mathematics is the part of physics where experiments are cheap Mephist 7 Jul 2019 22 8
Pig Brains in a Vat? Marchesk 16 Jul 2019 22 7
Law vs Rules vs Codes BrianW 29 Jul 2019 22 6
Language is all about [avoiding] confusion - The Perfect Language TheMadFool 1 Jul 2019 21 7
Ship reaches destination without compass paradox TheMadFool 1 Jul 2019 21 5
I'm Not Happy and I'm Not Sad. Shawn 27 Jul 2019 21 6
Hotelling's Law in US Politics Shawn 19 Jul 2019 20 9
What's your personality like? Wheatley 26 Jul 2019 20 12
The Analogy of Necessity Dfpolis 1 Jul 2019 19 6
Marijuana Use and Tertiary Concerns Jude Joanis 11 Jul 2019 19 10
Models of Governance JosephS 26 Jul 2019 19 4
What is progress? Pantagruel 29 Jul 2019 19 12
Determinism vs 'Intelligent Design' Jacob-B 4 Jul 2019 18 6
Why do human beings ignore that the world is like a hell which is full of suffering? empathy 7 Jul 2019 18 8
Link Between Feminism And Obesity Ilya B Shambat 14 Jul 2019 18 8
What is Philosophy for you? Pantagruel 23 Jul 2019 18 10
Do logic and reason say that God is our servant? Gnostic Christian Bishop 30 Jul 2019 18 4
Predestination and Forgiveness christian2017 2 Jul 2019 17 6
If pornography creates these kinds of changes in the brain, then what is this telling you? Maureen 3 Jul 2019 17 13
Elon Musk's "Neuralink" TogetherTurtle 19 Jul 2019 17 4
The world may be a place for non-substantial things that appear substantial nevertheless god must be atheist 24 Jul 2019 17 4
Haddocks' Eyes Streetlight 10 Jul 2019 16 7
Useful hints and tips Amity 28 Jul 2019 16 10
What Russia Has To Offer America Ilya B Shambat 8 Jul 2019 15 4
A different private language argument, is it any good? SomeName 4 Jul 2019 14 7
Is self-confidence, as an accepted value, an element for egoistic behaviors ? David Jones 15 Jul 2019 14 5
Let's talk about morphic resonance Glenn Turner 19 Jul 2019 14 9
Predictive modelling is not science alcontali 20 Jul 2019 14 8
Egalitarianism and Slavery in the US. Shawn 10 Jul 2019 13 7
What does psychosis tell us about the nature of reality? Wheatley 19 Jul 2019 13 11
Handedness and evil TheMadFool 3 Jul 2019 12 3
Happiness as the ultimate purpose of human life Patulia 17 Jul 2019 12 8
This is surrealism frank 22 Jul 2019 11 5
Words restrict Reality? Robee321 29 Jul 2019 11 7
Burnout god must be atheist 31 Jul 2019 11 4
Pain and Pleasure, the only real things? Mehdim 1 Jul 2019 10 8
Are there any thoughts on occultism and intuitionalism Corra 4 Jul 2019 10 5
Are there any new age philosophers on the forum Corra 8 Jul 2019 10 5
The eternity Problem Filipe 10 Jul 2019 10 8
What is the epistemology of epistemology? alcontali 13 Jul 2019 10 4
On self control khaled 17 Jul 2019 10 4
Mind development regel 24 Jul 2019 10 9
Free will, an empirical claim? TheMadFool 3 Jul 2019 9 6
How to define the notion of Goodness? nguyen dung 11 Jul 2019 9 4
Nihilism necessarily characterising a logical reality. Robert Lockhart 30 Jul 2019 9 6
Context principle (Frege) and Language game (Wittgenstein) TheMadFool 13 Jul 2019 8 4
Philosophy of Action, Ethics, Law and Categorization/Visualization JosephS 15 Jul 2019 8 3
Atheist Take on Reincarnation and Karma Nicholasm5581 23 Jul 2019 8 8
How Would You Behave If You Were Oppressed? jorgealarcon 4 Jul 2019 7 7
Chinese Room Language Games Marchesk 13 Jul 2019 7 4
What have you learned from philosophy? Shawn 5 Jul 2019 6 4
Does Homosexuality point to a non mechanistic world? Cris 6 Jul 2019 6 4
Nested Ethical Reversals JosephS 18 Jul 2019 6 2
Philosophy (of) and Mental and Developmental Disorders (ie.autism) Grre 28 Jul 2019 6 5
Are There Non-Religious Biographies About Jesus Christ? philsterr 2 Jul 2019 5 4
Shattered Mirror Jacob-B 14 Jul 2019 5 4
Paradox? Robert Lockhart 22 Jul 2019 5 5
Help ambiguity problem Robint 23 Jul 2019 5 4
Emotions are necessary to give us a positive or negative perspective TranscendedRealms 24 Jul 2019 5 3
Misery is a waste of time Corra 1 Jul 2019 4 2
How could an AI discover its true nature if it exists inside a virtual reality? Cris 1 Jul 2019 4 4
How a simple but persuasive moral argument goes wrong Marchesk 13 Jul 2019 4 2
The Art of Everything & Nothing RoboIntegrity 14 Jul 2019 4 3
Cogito ergo sum? Is there an absolute level of existence? think 15 Jul 2019 4 3
Three Questions about Jung (Dynamics of Personality) McMootch 27 Jul 2019 4 2
Verbal acuity in men vs. women regularguy 28 Jul 2019 4 3
Freeing your heart Corra 1 Jul 2019 3 2
Magic of Thinking jorgealarcon 2 Jul 2019 3 3
Wrong Helping Approaches Ilya B Shambat 11 Jul 2019 3 3
Ethics, public safety and safety in the world of aviation. FreeEmotion 12 Jul 2019 3 2
Alt-Right: WASPs and Jews Ilya B Shambat 15 Jul 2019 3 3
My idea on dreams in one's sleep -- why we do it, what its function is, what its mechanism is god must be atheist 16 Jul 2019 3 3
Existence theory treeko301 21 Jul 2019 3 2
Experience and Existence Kelly Miles 29 Jul 2019 3 3
The Work-Life Balance in Ancient Egyptian Ethics WerMaat 30 Jul 2019 3 3
Hello! andreiachim 4 Jul 2019 2 2
Epistemology a deleted account 9 Jul 2019 2 2
You Are What You Love Reflection gottesser 14 Jul 2019 2 1
The effect of paranormal and "ghost" tv shows Teller 19 Jul 2019 2 2
What is an "evidential import"? clemens 24 Jul 2019 2 2
Does consciousness derive from fear? roberthp 27 Jul 2019 2 2
Motivations for Post Modernism christian2017 2 Jul 2019 1 1
Consciousness, Social Norms And Reality Ilya B Shambat 10 Jul 2019 1 1
Why do not exist the Supreme Form of Bad? nguyen dung 11 Jul 2019 1 1
What are the cultural benefits, if any, with Brexit? halo 14 Jul 2019 1 1
"Self-Esteem" And "Law Of Attraction" Ilya B Shambat 1 Jul 2019 0 0
Reflection on You Are What You Love gottesser 12 Jul 2019 0 0
Timelike Structure JosephS 17 Jul 2019 0 0
What is the philosophy of Haibane Renmei? underground-man 21 Jul 2019 0 0

About these figures. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.