The Agora Almanac

Section 05 / Timeline / Month

December 2018

Members of The Philosophy Forum wrote 9,440 posts in December 2018: 167 opening posts and 9,273 comments, running to about 938,000 words. 205 members posted, 61 of them for the first time.

By number of posts it ranks 36th of the archive's 125 months. 171 threads were opened, and 244 threads received at least one comment.

The most active thread was Naming and Necessity, reading group?, with 1,204 comments in the month.

9,440
Posts
36th of 125 months
205
Members posting
61 for the first time
171
Threads opened
244 threads active
938,000
Words written
99 per post
518
Posts on the busiest day
11 December 2018

Fig. 1

Posts per day in December 2018

Days are UTC. The busiest was 11 December 2018, with 518 posts, 211 of them in Idealism vs. Materialism.

0 300 600 1 8 15 22 29

Fig. 2

Most active threads

Comments posted during December 2018, whenever the thread was opened.

  1. 1Naming and Necessity, reading group?1,204
  2. 2Idealism vs. Materialism992
  3. 3Philosophical Investigations, reading it together.432
  4. 4Brexit402
  5. 5Is our dominion over animals unethical?331
  6. 6Science is inherently atheistic268
  7. 7Are there any good modern refutations to Global Antinatalism?233
  8. 8Arguments for discrete time196
  9. 9Fallacies of Strawson's Argument vs. Free Will174
  10. 10The Prime Mover 2.0169
  11. 11Is it immoral to do illegal drugs?164
  12. 12So much for free speech and the sexual revolution, Tumblr and Facebook...139
  13. 13Intentional vs. Material Reality and the Hard Problem137
  14. 14The Shoutbox128
  15. 15Is the trinity logically incoherent?127

Fig. 3

Most active members

Posts written during December 2018.

  1. 1Terrapin Station874
  2. 2Shawn625
  3. 3Banno433
  4. 4Janus282
  5. 5regularguy270
  6. 6S249
  7. 7Jamesk249
  8. 8creativesoul248
  9. 9sign245
  10. 10Metaphysician Undercover233
  11. 11Jake217
  12. 12Harry Hindu216
  13. 13frank190
  14. 14Devans99177
  15. 15BC168

Fig. 4

The words of December 2018

Tracked words used unusually often this month compared with the archive as a whole: used by at least five members in the month, with no one member supplying more than 35% of the uses. Larger means more distinctive; the small figure is the number of uses.

Fig. 5

171 threads opened in December 2018

171 listed

Every thread started this month, with the comments it went on to draw by the end of the archive.

Brexit Changeling 11 Dec 2018 3,102 78
Is it immoral to do illegal drugs? Drek 25 Dec 2018 1,075 54
Anyone care to read Kant's "Critique of Pure Reason"? Shawn 8 Dec 2018 626 24
Science is inherently atheistic VoidDetector 7 Dec 2018 457 34
Arguments for discrete time Devans99 18 Dec 2018 282 22
Intentional vs. Material Reality and the Hard Problem Dfpolis 18 Dec 2018 236 22
God and time Walter Pound 15 Dec 2018 185 40
The Prime Mover 2.0 Devans99 20 Dec 2018 169 14
Is the trinity logically incoherent? Walter Pound 24 Dec 2018 155 32
Spring Semester Seminar Style Reading Group John Doe 4 Dec 2018 146 12
So much for free speech and the sexual revolution, Tumblr and Facebook... BC 11 Dec 2018 143 17
Calling a machine "intelligent" is pure anthropomorphism. Why was this term chosen? Anthony 13 Dec 2018 117 29
The poor and Capitalism? Drek 29 Dec 2018 116 25
Best arguments against suicide? Shawn 3 Dec 2018 112 30
The subject in 'It is raining.' Shawn 5 Dec 2018 108 21
The War on Terror Shawn 17 Dec 2018 105 22
Quantum Indeterminacy and Libertarian free will Relativist 6 Dec 2018 100 10
Giving someone a burden they didn't need to experience is wrong schopenhauer1 25 Dec 2018 98 11
Could We Ever Reach Enlightenment? gnat 5 Dec 2018 95 18
'I love you more than words can say.' Shawn 7 Dec 2018 95 11
Nature versus Nurture Andrew4Handel 16 Dec 2018 87 12
Trauma, Defense a deleted account 8 Dec 2018 76 9
Sceptical Theism Rank Amateur 28 Dec 2018 76 10
Is Determinism self-refuting? Walter Pound 17 Dec 2018 70 15
Gov't or impeach a deleted account 26 Dec 2018 69 14
Willpower - is it an energy thing? Amity 29 Dec 2018 65 12
Plato's Republic, reading discussion Dagny 6 Dec 2018 61 15
General Mattis For President? Jake 21 Dec 2018 60 15
Causation: Is it real? Jamesk 8 Dec 2018 54 8
'The real is rational, and the rational is real' (philosophy as idealism/humanism) sign 16 Dec 2018 54 10
Some Questions I Would like to Discuss About Western Civilization/Culture johnGould 15 Dec 2018 52 18
Undirected Intentionality Shawn 21 Dec 2018 52 6
Too much religion? Jamal 8 Dec 2018 51 18
Discussing Derrida sign 4 Dec 2018 49 5
On what the existence of the unconscious entails for metaphysics philosophy 4 Dec 2018 46 5
On learned helplessness? Shawn 8 Dec 2018 46 6
Mutual relationship between Idealism and Materialism. Shawn 29 Dec 2018 46 7
Memory and reference? Shawn 10 Dec 2018 45 9
Lucid Dreaming Shawn 23 Dec 2018 44 19
Has Politcal Correctness Turned into Prejudice? ernestm 24 Dec 2018 43 13
How Relevant is Philosophy Today? BrianW 15 Dec 2018 39 14
Thought experiments and empiricism ADG 22 Dec 2018 39 9
Existential Quantification and Counterfactuals Shawn 14 Dec 2018 38 4
Why do we hate our ancestors? TogetherTurtle 15 Dec 2018 38 8
Euclidea Banno 1 Dec 2018 37 6
The new post-truth reality and the death of democracy a deleted account 3 Dec 2018 35 14
Is it morally wrong to not use a gift? Fuzzball Baggins 4 Dec 2018 35 14
CO2 science quiz frank 23 Dec 2018 35 7
The measure problem Fuzzball Baggins 3 Dec 2018 34 9
"Your honor, I had no free will." Shawn 20 Dec 2018 34 12
Is God a Subject? Shawn 30 Dec 2018 34 10
The capacity for freewill Jamesk 12 Dec 2018 33 9
Conscience without taboo? Billy 30 Dec 2018 33 7
Reconstructing Democracy - A New Form of Government? BrianW 9 Dec 2018 32 4
Are Numbers Necessary? Abecedarian 6 Dec 2018 31 14
How should Christians Treat animals? princessofdarkness 8 Dec 2018 30 16
The morality of using the Death Note TheHedoMinimalist 9 Dec 2018 30 10
The word ????? in John 1:1 Tzeentch 28 Dec 2018 30 15
Wittgenstein (Language in relative to philosophy) yonlee 8 Dec 2018 29 9
Yes, you'd go to heaven, but likely an infinitely worse heaven VoidDetector 8 Dec 2018 29 16
Dimensionality Shawn 15 Dec 2018 29 8
Why Nothing Can Bring Certainty a deleted account 17 Dec 2018 28 11
The De Re/De Dicto Distinction Shawn 18 Dec 2018 28 3
The misery of the world. Shawn 23 Dec 2018 28 9
New Year's Resolutions Hanover 24 Dec 2018 28 9
Knowing humans too well. Self-delusion or unavoidable fact? FranckFriends 30 Dec 2018 28 10
Consequentialism / Utilitarianism. Jamesk 8 Dec 2018 27 5
Why is our upbringing so diametrically different than adulthood? Shawn 9 Dec 2018 27 6
Metaphysics Lambda (Book 12) Mattt 10 Dec 2018 26 5
Can you class a group of people with social statistics in this way? Drek 31 Dec 2018 26 12
Awareness and the Idea a deleted account 7 Dec 2018 25 9
How do you explain this process? Shawn 13 Dec 2018 24 7
Profound Alienation Shawn 24 Dec 2018 23 5
What does impairment of ToM suggest about the personal subpersonal divide? rei 1 Dec 2018 22 10
Science is inherently atheistic VoidDetector 7 Dec 2018 22 13
Is it more important to avoid being immoral or being legal? Drek 26 Dec 2018 22 12
A flaw in the doomsday hypothesis Fuzzball Baggins 3 Dec 2018 21 6
Why are we here? Pattern-chaser 5 Dec 2018 21 9
Divine Simplicity and human free will Walter Pound 19 Dec 2018 21 7
The voice in your head Shawn 28 Dec 2018 21 9
Scientific/objective purpose of human species, may be to replicate universes VoidDetector 6 Dec 2018 20 6
Ethical Work Andrew4Handel 28 Dec 2018 19 9
Burned out by logic Intro book krishnamurti 25 Dec 2018 18 12
Pearlists shouldn't call themselves atheists Tomseltje 18 Dec 2018 17 5
Music as a Form of Communication? Shawn 29 Dec 2018 17 8
Reality, Perceived or Conceived? BrianW 21 Dec 2018 16 4
Only dead fish go with the flow regularguy 6 Dec 2018 15 7
When is coping justified? Shawn 9 Dec 2018 15 4
Argument from first motion Devans99 11 Dec 2018 15 3
The Kingdom of Heaven regularguy 25 Dec 2018 15 8
How to overcome Death Anxiety Penav25 1 Dec 2018 14 11
Who should I read? a deleted account 5 Dec 2018 14 11
Are tough guys latent homo/bisexuals? regularguy 11 Dec 2018 14 3
Are We Spoiled Yuppy Brats? Jake 20 Dec 2018 14 5
Is it possible to argue against this? Blubarb 24 Dec 2018 14 7
Argument for an Eternal First Cause Devans99 28 Dec 2018 14 7
How to go beyond an agonal vision of Reality? DiegoT 12 Dec 2018 13 6
Retro-time travelling Happenstance 14 Dec 2018 13 7
The Chinese Social Credit System? Shawn 28 Dec 2018 12 7
Question About Forum Data Jake 13 Dec 2018 11 3
Accessibility Relations Across Possible Worlds Shawn 15 Dec 2018 11 2
Barcan Formula Shawn 18 Dec 2018 11 3
Separation of Church and State? Drek 25 Dec 2018 11 6
Misremembering Sim 4 Dec 2018 10 5
The Argument from the Scientific Test of Reality vulcanlogician 7 Dec 2018 10 8
Thank you. Shawn 8 Dec 2018 10 5
The Man in the High Castle. Shawn 11 Dec 2018 10 5
Happy videos Shawn 19 Dec 2018 10 3
How does Berkeley's immaterial world actually work? Jamesk 31 Dec 2018 10 6
Argument of theological fatalism Yajur 8 Dec 2018 9 5
Civility Medicp251 10 Dec 2018 9 7
Why are Public Intellectuals (Often Scientists) So Embarrassing in their Political Commentary? MindForged 20 Dec 2018 9 8
Is belief in LFW and lack of empathy correlated? regularguy 12 Dec 2018 8 6
What you want? What you need? What you should? a deleted account 24 Dec 2018 8 3
The Content Cynic Shawn 26 Dec 2018 8 3
On Education Shawn 30 Dec 2018 8 4
Pew Survey: How do European countries differ in religious commitment? SophistiCat 24 Dec 2018 7 7
Back to basics, back to the ground. a deleted account 24 Dec 2018 7 3
Question About Consciousness Datalchemist 31 Dec 2018 7 6
Dancing musicpianoaccordion 2 Dec 2018 6 5
Would it be ethical to clone people like Einstein? Shawn 4 Dec 2018 6 5
Petitionary Prayer FordFestivaPhilosophy 7 Dec 2018 6 6
Why can't religious texts be used to construct computers/forums etc? VoidDetector 7 Dec 2018 5 4
Can we stop talking about Jesus please lupac 8 Dec 2018 5 5
Revisionary Pronouns Iwanttostopphilosophizingbutikant 8 Dec 2018 5 5
I can't post a reply Hrvoje 15 Dec 2018 5 3
Can hypotheticals prove true in ALL situations and change our pragmatic behaviors? NakedNdAfraid 19 Dec 2018 5 3
Misheard Songs... a deleted account 19 Dec 2018 5 5
'50% of my decisions are wrong' says... alfredokles 26 Dec 2018 5 3
Newbie Classicist Not 29 Dec 2018 5 4
What's interesting about the personal vs subpersonal distinction? rei 4 Dec 2018 4 3
Rejection of the incompatibilist argument Iwanttostopphilosophizingbutikant 8 Dec 2018 4 2
Argument on miracles Yajur 8 Dec 2018 4 3
Are all definitions stipulative definitions? Shawn 17 Dec 2018 4 2
Do we have a moral duty to use genetic engineering for species conservation? Hans 23 Dec 2018 4 4
Syntax-Semantics Computers Humans TheMadFool 29 Dec 2018 4 3
Starting out on the road JoeTheBassPlayer 10 Dec 2018 3 3
I can't remember what this book is? Nmann 11 Dec 2018 3 3
All topics converge to philosophy? Shawn 16 Dec 2018 3 2
Have you encountered this? regularguy 18 Dec 2018 3 2
Has Anyone Spoken About Personal Identity in This Way? Datalchemist 19 Dec 2018 3 3
A new study proves parachutes are useless jorndoe 21 Dec 2018 3 3
Disturbing Dreams... Tzeentch 22 Dec 2018 3 3
Hoilday Greetings Dfpolis 24 Dec 2018 3 3
Man and a Box ben 5 Dec 2018 2 2
Scope and Limits of the Invalidation Effects of a Defective Cognitive Nature on the Cogito Sum charles ferraro 6 Dec 2018 2 2
Christian Exclusivist Universalism Francesco di Piertro 8 Dec 2018 2 2
A world without the romantic ideal: how would it be different? frank 14 Dec 2018 2 2
Deleted post Pussycat 14 Dec 2018 2 2
Death Existence Consciousness Andrew4Handel 19 Dec 2018 2 2
quantum consciousness, the observer effect, and Westworld ernestm 22 Dec 2018 2 2
Holiday Blues Thread. Shawn 24 Dec 2018 2 2
Improving the lives of others but resulting in more people being unhappy in the future Luke1i1 26 Dec 2018 2 2
Can I ask a really hard question? about logic What is the difference between these two sentences? 1. albert 6 Dec 2018 1 1
Works are not Necessary for Salvation adhomienem 6 Dec 2018 1 1
An Argument Against Exclusivity When Referencing God Francesco di Piertro 7 Dec 2018 1 1
Is it possible? TheMadFool 7 Dec 2018 1 1
Is Enacting Harm on West World Conscious Machine-like Beings Wrong in the eyes of God? princessofdarkness 7 Dec 2018 1 1
Google Waymo One self-driving taxi service launched in Phoenix 2 days ago VoidDetector 8 Dec 2018 1 1
The Joy of Doing Philosophy Shawn 26 Dec 2018 1 1
A Defense of Moral Relativism rickyk95 1 Dec 2018 0 0
ddddd VoidDetector 7 Dec 2018 0 0
Folk religion musicpianoaccordion 7 Dec 2018 0 0
Our human nature and the catholic catechism musicpianoaccordion 7 Dec 2018 0 0
Circles and Thoughts loosefanbeltdan 8 Dec 2018 0 0
Google Waymo launched Ai self driving car service 2 days ago. VoidDetector 8 Dec 2018 0 0
Cosmological argument Iwanttostopphilosophizingbutikant 8 Dec 2018 0 0
We are mental artists by nature TranscendedRealms 15 Dec 2018 0 0
Fundamentalism in mainstream metaphysics Patrick Aoun 22 Dec 2018 0 0
Socrates Dream in Phaedo rahman 23 Dec 2018 0 0
What are ethics, is it a human construction or part of ourselves and ethic in our society Dimitrios Pap 29 Dec 2018 0 0

About these figures. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.