The Agora Almanac

Section 05 / Timeline / Month

November 2018

Members of The Philosophy Forum wrote 8,642 posts in November 2018: 179 opening posts and 8,463 comments, running to about 865,000 words. 211 members posted, 73 of them for the first time.

By number of posts it ranks 59th of the archive's 125 months. 184 threads were opened, and 260 threads received at least one comment.

The most active thread was The Material and the Medial, with 320 comments in the month.

8,642
Posts
59th of 125 months
211
Members posting
73 for the first time
184
Threads opened
260 threads active
865,000
Words written
100 per post
558
Posts on the busiest day
16 November 2018

Fig. 1

Posts per day in November 2018

Days are UTC. The busiest was 16 November 2018, with 558 posts, 101 of them in Empty names.

0 300 600 1 8 15 22 29

Fig. 2

Most active threads

Comments posted during November 2018, whenever the thread was opened.

  1. 1The Material and the Medial320
  2. 2Wants and needs.314
  3. 3Is Idealism Irrefutable?285
  4. 4Empty names236
  5. 5Heidegger's vision of philosophy in 1919234
  6. 6Philosophical Investigations, reading it together.211
  7. 7Defining Good And Evil165
  8. 8Philosophical Investigations, reading group?154
  9. 9Fallacies of Strawson's Argument vs. Free Will154
  10. 10Truth is a pathless land.153
  11. 11Life is immoral?151
  12. 12Naming and Necessity, reading group?143
  13. 13Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)137
  14. 14Elon Musk on the Simulation Hypothesis137
  15. 15Are there any good modern refutations to Global Antinatalism?136

Fig. 3

Most active members

Posts written during November 2018.

  1. 1Terrapin Station1,089
  2. 2Shawn676
  3. 3macrosoft651
  4. 4Devans99225
  5. 5eodnhoj7208
  6. 6Jake204
  7. 7Metaphysician Undercover172
  8. 8hks172
  9. 9BrianW168
  10. 10BC160
  11. 11regularguy141
  12. 12Wayfarer121
  13. 13frank115
  14. 14ssu114
  15. 15Marchesk113

Fig. 4

The words of November 2018

Tracked words used unusually often this month compared with the archive as a whole: used by at least five members in the month, with no one member supplying more than 35% of the uses. Larger means more distinctive; the small figure is the number of uses.

Fig. 5

184 threads opened in November 2018

184 listed

Every thread started this month, with the comments it went on to draw by the end of the archive.

Naming and Necessity, reading group? Shawn 21 Nov 2018 1,817 23
Philosophical Investigations, reading it together. Valentinus 18 Nov 2018 1,796 37
Idealism vs. Materialism Jamesk 28 Nov 2018 1,006 24
Is our dominion over animals unethical? chatterbears 30 Nov 2018 547 25
Are there any good modern refutations to Global Antinatalism? khaled 24 Nov 2018 417 19
Fallacies of Strawson's Argument vs. Free Will Dfpolis 21 Nov 2018 328 19
The Material and the Medial Streetlight 4 Nov 2018 320 12
Wants and needs. Shawn 5 Nov 2018 314 11
Is Idealism Irrefutable? philosophy 8 Nov 2018 285 26
Heidegger's vision of philosophy in 1919 macrosoft 19 Nov 2018 244 18
Empty names Shawn 15 Nov 2018 236 16
Philosophical Investigations, reading group? Shawn 14 Nov 2018 154 11
Truth is a pathless land. Shawn 20 Nov 2018 153 20
Life is immoral? Andrew4Handel 24 Nov 2018 151 13
Elon Musk on the Simulation Hypothesis Shawn 15 Nov 2018 137 26
An End To The God Debate BrianW 3 Nov 2018 133 14
On depression, again. Shawn 13 Nov 2018 130 17
Vatican Republic, Catholic Political Party... nonsense or something that should exist? CarlosDiaz 3 Nov 2018 128 7
The Ontological Argument Fallacy TheMadFool 12 Nov 2018 126 9
The Objective Nature of Language Sam26 3 Nov 2018 109 14
My Animalistic Philosophy of Truth- Please give me reflections and debate! Jonah Tobias 12 Nov 2018 94 7
Re Psychological Hedonism: Do you have any criticisms? diesynyang 16 Nov 2018 88 4
Morality Versus Action Andrew4Handel 9 Nov 2018 86 9
Dennett on Colors Marchesk 21 Nov 2018 86 14
We Don't Create, We Synthesize BrianW 24 Nov 2018 86 12
Is there a subconscious? Ranger 2 Nov 2018 81 13
Two types of Intelligence Devans99 13 Nov 2018 79 11
Moral accountability under Compatibilism Relativist 29 Nov 2018 78 8
To be or not to be Rhasta1 8 Nov 2018 77 15
You cannot have an electoral democracy without an effective 'None of the Above' (NOTA) option. romanv 16 Nov 2018 69 13
Have you voted, why or why not? Shawn 6 Nov 2018 68 14
Skepticism...any way around it?! Kranky 24 Nov 2018 62 7
David Hume: "The Rules Of Morality Are Not The Conclusions Of Our Reason" F.C.F.V. 26 Nov 2018 62 9
Why should anyone be surprised at GOP voter suppression? LD Saunders 5 Nov 2018 61 13
Renewal and Remembrance. unenlightened 7 Nov 2018 60 9
Should the Possibility that Morality Stems from Evolution Even Be Considered? Play-doh 1 Nov 2018 59 29
Addressing the Physicalist Delirium SteveKlinko 17 Nov 2018 59 9
Lying to murderer at the door Happiness 14 Nov 2018 58 12
What can we be certain of? Not even our thoughts? Causing me anxiety. Kranky 22 Nov 2018 55 21
Who knows these things? Shawn 4 Nov 2018 53 6
Is climate change going to start killing many people soon? Lif3r 18 Nov 2018 53 17
Why Humans Will Never Understand 4D Space SteveKlinko 22 Nov 2018 53 12
At what age should a person be legally able to make their own decisions? MonfortS26 30 Nov 2018 52 14
GCB Existed Before Time adhomienem 1 Nov 2018 51 13
What are your views on death? outlier 9 Nov 2018 50 19
Education, Democracy and Liberty Athena 20 Nov 2018 50 9
The matter of philosophy Belter 15 Nov 2018 48 11
Direct Realism as both True and False Marchesk 21 Nov 2018 48 11
Anxiety is Fear regularguy 25 Nov 2018 47 4
Emotional Reasoning Shawn 22 Nov 2018 46 11
My argument (which I no longer believe) against free will regularguy 21 Nov 2018 45 13
On Suicidal Thoughts a deleted account 28 Nov 2018 44 20
Is it moral to lie to a murderer? Happiness 14 Nov 2018 42 11
Calculus Devans99 27 Nov 2018 42 9
Determinism and mathematical truth. EnPassant 8 Nov 2018 40 12
Is nihilism supportable or is it an excuse for a lack of talent? Artie 9 Nov 2018 40 11
A little from the Gospel Artie 15 Nov 2018 40 12
Francis Fukuyama's argument against Identity Politics ssu 11 Nov 2018 39 8
In pursuit of happiness. Shawn 4 Nov 2018 38 11
I wonder what the ratio male/female is in this forum DiegoT 12 Nov 2018 38 11
Is Economics a Science? LD Saunders 2 Nov 2018 37 14
The community where everyone is wrong frank 4 Nov 2018 34 8
The Republic of Plato John64 9 Nov 2018 31 11
Do we have the right to choose? Artie 11 Nov 2018 31 11
Defending The Enemy? Jake 5 Nov 2018 30 13
Is The Mind Infinite? Tzeentch 9 Nov 2018 30 8
Journey as journey a deleted account 25 Nov 2018 29 3
Discovering Mathematics Dan84 30 Nov 2018 29 6
Do I need to be saved? Shawn 1 Nov 2018 28 14
Is it always better to be clear? Wheatley 17 Nov 2018 26 16
Confused. "I think or I think that I think". Kranky 19 Nov 2018 26 11
The problem with Psychiatry leo 28 Nov 2018 26 14
why does socrates reject property dualist concept of mind joe b 18 Nov 2018 25 5
Four alternative calendar proposals Michael Ossipoff 20 Nov 2018 25 9
How do we know the world wasn't created yesterday ExistenceIspain 8 Nov 2018 24 9
What are 'cognitive distortions'? Shawn 17 Nov 2018 24 5
Time to reconsider the internet? Brian Jones 20 Nov 2018 24 13
Are you conscious when you're asleep and dreaming? BrianW 28 Nov 2018 24 10
On Kant, Hegel, and Noumena philosophy 6 Nov 2018 23 11
"And the light shineth in darkness..." Tzeentch 19 Nov 2018 23 13
Consciousness as primary substance regularguy 19 Nov 2018 23 9
Soundness Moliere 27 Nov 2018 23 8
Living forever. Shawn 9 Nov 2018 22 6
No need to be upset. Shawn 9 Nov 2018 22 6
Moving to Mars, wait? Shawn 4 Nov 2018 21 7
Being interested in words vs things Welkin Rogue 5 Nov 2018 21 6
Whether Revenge is Just Artie 8 Nov 2018 21 11
The last great ones? Brian Jones 19 Nov 2018 21 8
Senses Susu 26 Nov 2018 21 6
Is the following definition appropriate to rationality? benedict 6 Nov 2018 20 4
Is Anarchic Society Even Possible? Does it work? Lif3r 10 Nov 2018 20 6
Human dignity musicpianoaccordion 13 Nov 2018 20 6
The Lame Stoic Shawn 27 Nov 2018 20 6
On Sincerity. Shawn 1 Nov 2018 19 5
The Courtroom Thread. Shawn 1 Nov 2018 19 4
Hume's "Abject Failure" Walter Pound 23 Nov 2018 19 9
Chemistry: Elements and Substances blokeybloke 24 Nov 2018 19 10
Rethink the world leo 5 Nov 2018 18 9
Logical Behaviourism Shawn 17 Nov 2018 18 5
What do you view as symbols for eternity and stability? UngeGosh 28 Nov 2018 18 9
Thoughts, feelings, actions = who you are? LSDC 5 Nov 2018 17 8
Nobody knows why they're doing what they're doing bizso09 5 Nov 2018 17 7
Why do we like beautiful things? Wheatley 21 Nov 2018 17 11
Blasphemy law by the backdoor jorndoe 3 Nov 2018 16 9
Suffering caused by people leo 9 Nov 2018 16 5
How can I enjoy things if I cannot be certain they are happening? Kranky 20 Nov 2018 16 7
Philosophy in Games - The Talos Principle Tzeentch 21 Nov 2018 16 10
God and Eternalism and the Prime Mover Devans99 23 Nov 2018 16 5
Union of abstract metaphysical and personal anthropomorphic God concepts Elrondo 24 Nov 2018 16 11
Missing From The Immigation Debate Jake 8 Nov 2018 14 10
All Fallacies are Fallacious and Exist as Laws of Logic. eodnhoj7 13 Nov 2018 14 5
Is it possible to prove inference rules? Nicholas Ferreira 18 Nov 2018 14 6
Some counterarguments against pessimism's view on moral testimony flight747 2 Nov 2018 13 3
The Soul-Making Theodicy Iwanttostopphilosophizingbutikant 1 Nov 2018 11 8
Thoughts on play musicpianoaccordion 13 Nov 2018 11 8
The morality of killing gorilla Harambe and communitarianism Happiness 17 Nov 2018 11 7
What does 'scientifically impossible' mean? Wheatley 25 Nov 2018 11 10
How can you justify your rights? Should we need to? rayofsunshine 29 Nov 2018 11 7
What exactly is good and bad? (In terms of living creatures). outlier 7 Nov 2018 10 9
On solipsism and knowledge regularguy 21 Nov 2018 10 4
Can we be held responsible for what we believe? Francesco di Piertro 21 Nov 2018 10 10
Moral Value of Private Censorship LD Saunders 9 Nov 2018 9 4
Why aren't we satisfied? Shawn 16 Nov 2018 9 5
Disappearing beneficiaries argument Luke1i1 23 Nov 2018 9 4
The problem of Negation Jerin Jaison 27 Nov 2018 9 4
IELTS reading test logical inaccuracies poedgar 2 Nov 2018 8 7
The CBT Thread Shawn 22 Nov 2018 8 3
A fellow philosopher called me a Romantic hks 22 Nov 2018 8 3
From Kant's Groundwork - short question a deleted account 2 Nov 2018 7 4
Did Augustine draw a distinction between Community and Society John Strong 11 Nov 2018 7 3
On solipsism. Shawn 14 Nov 2018 7 3
Simplicity musicpianoaccordion 16 Nov 2018 7 4
Does capitalism encourage psychopathic behaviour? pbxman 20 Nov 2018 7 6
Does every thing have value? Zhou Du 7 Nov 2018 6 5
On emotions. Shawn 11 Nov 2018 6 3
Abstract Aspects of Society I like sushi 16 Nov 2018 6 3
Is Philosophy Bullsh*t? regularguy 30 Nov 2018 6 3
The Trolley Problem and the Moral Machine SophistiCat 3 Nov 2018 5 4
Concepts and Apparatus Streetlight 8 Nov 2018 5 5
Empirical vs Theoretical BrianW 14 Nov 2018 5 5
Manipulative and fake news: how to spot it and why it's important frank 17 Nov 2018 5 4
Is philosophy no better than politics? regularguy 26 Nov 2018 5 2
Divine Command Theory and the Incarnation FordFestivaPhilosophy 1 Nov 2018 4 4
Various philosophy essays. Critique me up Marc fromPHIL527 1 Nov 2018 4 4
Possible but not actual? Really? And other thoughts... petrichor 6 Nov 2018 4 4
Greetings jaofao 15 Nov 2018 4 3
Two-Dimensional Semantics Shawn 3 Nov 2018 3 2
What is truth? Connection to the post-truth world? Kushal 16 Nov 2018 3 3
Happy Thanksgiving (in the USA) hks 22 Nov 2018 3 2
Future events in human history. Shawn 23 Nov 2018 3 2
We are Human thus Imperfect therefore our opinions are imperfect Bill Bisco 25 Nov 2018 3 3
A vote for empiricism a deleted account 26 Nov 2018 3 1
The "Elsewhere, Elsewhen" Objection Play-doh 30 Nov 2018 3 3
On the Harm of Pascal's Wager FordFestivaPhilosophy 1 Nov 2018 2 2
Alvin Plantinga's modal argument for maximal greatness and maximal excellence Iwanttostopphilosophizingbutikant 1 Nov 2018 2 2
What would immanuel kant do? ( Hypothetical) Cailane 3 Nov 2018 2 2
Are rankings fact or opinion statements? wichura 4 Nov 2018 2 2
What next beyond the basics? a deleted account 19 Nov 2018 2 2
Can Frege overcome Russell's criticism in "On denoting"? EmaFort 20 Nov 2018 2 2
Counterpoint study: Fux's Gradus ad Passus ('Steps to Parnassus') Brian Jones 20 Nov 2018 2 2
Peter Woit on the state of scientific cosmology Wayfarer 21 Nov 2018 2 2
(Dis)-identification with thought? Shawn 23 Nov 2018 2 2
Soul Mates? a deleted account 25 Nov 2018 2 1
Declawed Miracles Empedocles 28 Nov 2018 2 2
Identifying and discussing the beginning of Knowledge as presented in the Critique of Pure Reason Ikolos 28 Nov 2018 2 2
Immanuel kant: Moral action Cailane 3 Nov 2018 1 1
IAAF regulations for testosterone levels in female athletes tmb 4 Nov 2018 1 1
Deleted post leo 7 Nov 2018 1 1
Type-Token Distinction. Shawn 16 Nov 2018 1 1
Evolution and Creation: My Take sydney 24 Nov 2018 1 1
Need Urgent help in mathematical logic problem zoro 24 Nov 2018 1 1
Possible argument refuting idealism? philosophy 25 Nov 2018 1 1
Are our thoughts certain? Kranky 25 Nov 2018 1 1
Religious Liberty eli rotello 27 Nov 2018 1 1
Identifying, discussing the beginning of knowledge in Kant's Critique of Pure Reason Ikolos 27 Nov 2018 1 1
Counterfactuals of Creaturely Freedom and the Potential for "Impossible" Worlds Play-doh 30 Nov 2018 1 1
I'd love your input on a new Philosophy channel on Youtube! EcceHomo 2 Nov 2018 0 0
Proof that nobody exits besides me and I am the world bizso09 6 Nov 2018 0 0
The importance of the spiral in nature zee 12 Nov 2018 0 0
Are You a Spongebob or Squidward? And which do you respect more diesynyang 13 Nov 2018 0 0
Is Psychology a real scientific discipline? DiegoT 20 Nov 2018 0 0
Plato on a Circular Universe Devans99 23 Nov 2018 0 0
Recommendations for books on Non-standard analysis? Shawn 27 Nov 2018 0 0
My musical tunes and their unrealized greatness TranscendedRealms 28 Nov 2018 0 0

About these figures. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.