The Agora Almanac

Section 05 / Timeline / Month

September 2019

Members of The Philosophy Forum wrote 12,966 posts in September 2019: 177 opening posts and 12,789 comments, running to about 1.1 million words. 219 members posted, 73 of them for the first time.

By number of posts it ranks 9th of the archive's 125 months. 178 threads were opened, and 280 threads received at least one comment.

The most active thread was The Subjectivity of Moral Values, with 1,131 comments in the month.

12,966
Posts
9th of 125 months
219
Members posting
73 for the first time
178
Threads opened
280 threads active
1.1 million
Words written
87 per post
663
Posts on the busiest day
25 September 2019

Fig. 1

Posts per day in September 2019

Days are UTC. The busiest was 25 September 2019, with 663 posts, 141 of them in Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here).

0 400 800 1 8 15 22 29

Fig. 2

Most active threads

Comments posted during September 2019, whenever the thread was opened.

  1. 1The Subjectivity of Moral Values1,131
  2. 2On Antinatalism714
  3. 3Should hate speech be allowed ?689
  4. 4Donald Trump (All General Trump Conversations Here)682
  5. 5Brexit492
  6. 6Are our minds souls?275
  7. 7The behavior of anti-religious posters251
  8. 8Metaphysics - what is it?237
  9. 9The Shoutbox232
  10. 10Realism, Nominalism, Conceptualism and Possible Worlds229
  11. 11If Not Identity Politics, Then What?201
  12. 12Why the Euthyphro fails180
  13. 13What is the difference between actual infinity and potential infinity?174
  14. 14Is introspection a valid type of knowledge173
  15. 15A description of God?150

Fig. 3

Most active members

Posts written during September 2019.

  1. 1Bartricks980
  2. 2S845
  3. 3Terrapin Station831
  4. 4NOS4A2493
  5. 5TheMadFool450
  6. 6Janus385
  7. 7Shamshir319
  8. 8T_Clark301
  9. 93017amen300
  10. 10Wayfarer293
  11. 11PoeticUniverse261
  12. 12alcontali254
  13. 13frank238
  14. 14Echarmion234
  15. 15god must be atheist227

Fig. 4

The words of September 2019

Tracked words used unusually often this month compared with the archive as a whole: used by at least five members in the month, with no one member supplying more than 35% of the uses. Larger means more distinctive; the small figure is the number of uses.

Fig. 5

178 threads opened in September 2019

178 listed

Every thread started this month, with the comments it went on to draw by the end of the archive.

Disambiguating the concept of gender Pfhorrest 30 Sep 2019 1,292 53
The Subjectivity of Moral Values Bartricks 16 Sep 2019 1,221 31
Are our minds souls? Bartricks 2 Sep 2019 275 17
The behavior of anti-religious posters T_Clark 15 Sep 2019 251 29
Realism, Nominalism, Conceptualism and Possible Worlds AJJ 7 Sep 2019 229 7
What triggers Hate? Do you embrace it? Gnostic Christian Bishop 18 Sep 2019 227 21
Study: Nearly four-fifths of 'gender minority' students have mental health issues alcontali 18 Sep 2019 221 21
The tragedy of the commons Banno 27 Sep 2019 211 34
Using logic-not emotion-Trump should be impeached 3017amen 27 Sep 2019 210 26
If Not Identity Politics, Then What? Streetlight 7 Sep 2019 201 19
Godel's Incompleteness Theorems vs Justified True Belief TheMadFool 22 Sep 2019 182 25
Why the Euthyphro fails Bartricks 23 Sep 2019 180 16
Is introspection a valid type of knowledge T_Clark 9 Sep 2019 173 20
Why is so much rambling theological verbiage given space on 'The Philosophy Forum' ? fresco 10 Sep 2019 156 28
A description of God? Pattern-chaser 4 Sep 2019 150 34
Lies, liars, trolls: what to do about them. a deleted account 3 Sep 2019 144 17
The Weird Metaphysics of Censorship NOS4A2 20 Sep 2019 136 9
The Kantian case against procreation Bartricks 11 Sep 2019 135 17
Darwinian Morality JosephS 18 Sep 2019 122 16
Feminism is Not Intersectional Bridget Eagles 24 Sep 2019 111 17
Obfuscatory Discourse removedmembershiprc 5 Sep 2019 104 23
Is Change Possible? elucid 9 Sep 2019 102 18
What advance in epistemological or metaphysical knowledge did David Hume bring us? Ron Cram 19 Sep 2019 100 10
The meaning of life and how to attain it PhilCF 19 Sep 2019 100 14
Krishnamurti Thread Shawn 30 Sep 2019 97 20
What An Odd Claim creativesoul 21 Sep 2019 92 15
Rant on "Belief" A Gnostic Agnostic 8 Sep 2019 90 13
Whats the standard for Mind/Body MiloL 28 Sep 2019 90 16
Miracles as evidence for the divine/God TheMadFool 6 Sep 2019 89 14
Can an omnipotent being do anything? Bartricks 5 Sep 2019 87 25
Mortimer Adler, How to Read a Book. a deleted account 23 Sep 2019 84 10
What do you think of the mainstream religions that are homophobic and misogynous? Gnostic Christian Bishop 8 Sep 2019 82 16
Is there a logic that undermines "belief" in a god? A Gnostic Agnostic 9 Sep 2019 80 16
On the Value of Wikipedia Streetlight 16 Sep 2019 80 17
Political Lesbianism as a Viable Option for Feminism Bridget Eagles 24 Sep 2019 78 18
Pseudo-Intellectual collection of things that all fit together hopefully a deleted account 1 Sep 2019 77 14
How can you prove Newton's laws? Fernando Rios 13 Sep 2019 77 18
Two Objects Occupying the Same Space elucid 14 Sep 2019 76 17
Is democracy a tool or a goal unto itself? frank 15 Sep 2019 71 14
What's so ethically special about sexual relations? Bartricks 11 Sep 2019 67 14
Did god really condemn mankind? Is god a just god? Gnostic Christian Bishop 14 Sep 2019 65 15
Does neurophilosophy signal the end of 'philosophy' as we know it ? fresco 20 Sep 2019 64 16
Why I gave up on Stoicism. Shawn 30 Sep 2019 64 18
A simple argument against freewill. Miracle? TheMadFool 10 Sep 2019 63 13
The Problem of Evil & Freewill TheMadFool 20 Sep 2019 62 20
Does Jesus qualify as an idol? Gnostic Christian Bishop 9 Sep 2019 61 15
Irrational beliefs Rufoid 26 Sep 2019 61 14
Christianity: immortal soul Daniel C 3 Sep 2019 58 14
Spinoza's metaphysical nihilism bobobor 22 Sep 2019 57 13
A paradox about borders. Paralogism 5 Sep 2019 55 10
Let's rename the forum T_Clark 1 Sep 2019 54 15
A Genderless God Bridget Eagles 24 Sep 2019 54 22
The French Age of Consent Laws thewonder 27 Sep 2019 54 14
Neoliberalism, anyone? unenlightened 11 Sep 2019 53 13
Aquinas, Hume, and the Cosmological Argument ModernPAS 23 Sep 2019 53 7
What Happens When Space Bends? elucid 15 Sep 2019 52 13
Where is the Intelligence in the Design Jacob-B 4 Sep 2019 51 13
Man created "God" in the beginning Daniel C 27 Sep 2019 51 20
Philosophy and Climate Change Malcolm Parry 16 Sep 2019 50 16
All we need to know are Axioms TheMadFool 18 Sep 2019 49 10
Survival of the fittest and the life of the unfit Wheatley 28 Sep 2019 45 20
Sin and emotion. A Gnostic Agnostic 9 Sep 2019 42 13
Stoicism is alright... but it ain't that great PhilCF 19 Sep 2019 42 15
Natural vs Unnatural TheMadFool 1 Sep 2019 40 12
Life and Existence: Logical or Illogical (or both) or something else? 3017amen 4 Sep 2019 40 5
At the End of the Book, Darwin wrote... TheMadFool 6 Sep 2019 39 11
Threads deleted. A Gnostic Agnostic 19 Sep 2019 39 13
'Miracle Cures' Jacob-B 13 Sep 2019 37 9
Why neurosis is hard to treat schopenhauer1 16 Sep 2019 36 4
What is scale outside of human perception? schopenhauer1 19 Sep 2019 36 8
A 'commonsense' argument for Cartesian skepticism. Paralogism 3 Sep 2019 35 6
Monty Hall Problem - random variation Wheatley 12 Sep 2019 35 8
Turning of entire reality into science is a path to self-destruction lepricok 26 Sep 2019 35 8
How to cope with only being me? raindrop 27 Sep 2019 34 17
Euthanasia or Murder? NOS4A2 16 Sep 2019 31 9
Beware of Accusations of Dog-Whistling NOS4A2 18 Sep 2019 31 12
This has nothing to do with Philosophy sorry, but how old are you guys? Jimmy 13 Sep 2019 30 15
Adventures in Modern Russia Jamal 30 Sep 2019 29 9
Existential Depression and Compassion. Shawn 22 Sep 2019 28 9
relationship to the universe Gregory 2 Sep 2019 27 8
Omega Point Cosmology, God TheMadFool 4 Sep 2019 27 10
Nature's Laws, Human Flaws Paradox TheMadFool 19 Sep 2019 27 12
The dis-united states Banno 6 Sep 2019 26 9
God. The Paradox of Excess TheMadFool 29 Sep 2019 26 14
Humans are devolving? Lucielle Randall 4 Sep 2019 25 13
The birth of tragedy. New2K2 6 Sep 2019 25 12
Loaning Money to older brother Stanley 29 Sep 2019 25 14
Homo suicidus TheMadFool 7 Sep 2019 24 12
Why? Why? Morality TheMadFool 12 Sep 2019 24 8
A way to prove philosophically that we are smart enough to understand a vision of any complexity? IuriiVovchenko 22 Sep 2019 24 12
What happens when you're tired of (your own) negativity? Shawn 28 Sep 2019 24 6
Bird Songs, Human Tongues TheMadFool 29 Sep 2019 24 9
Reasoning badly about free will and moral responsibility Bartricks 2 Sep 2019 23 7
Known Valid Argument Forms - Is the system complete. TheMadFool 15 Sep 2019 23 8
Death anxiety Shawn 3 Sep 2019 22 13
Life and Meaning Daniel C 3 Sep 2019 22 12
Purdue Pharma, thoughts on justice ZhouBoTong 18 Sep 2019 22 4
The Virtue of Selfishness: The Desire for the Unearned a deleted account 28 Sep 2019 22 10
Fractals and Panpsychism TheMadFool 2 Sep 2019 21 10
India, China, Zero and the Negative Numbers TheMadFool 21 Sep 2019 21 8
It's not ideological. It's personal. regularguy 3 Sep 2019 19 6
CCTV cameras - The Ethical Revolution TheMadFool 11 Sep 2019 19 9
Sherlock Holmes, Science and Understanding TheMadFool 11 Sep 2019 19 5
No room for freewill? Sheik Yerbouti 14 Sep 2019 19 8
God and The Three Universe problem Anonymys 11 Sep 2019 18 7
Being in two Different Places Simultaneously elucid 17 Sep 2019 18 10
A 5 sided square Ariel D'Leon 17 Sep 2019 18 8
On The Format of Logical Arguments MichaelJYoo 3 Sep 2019 16 8
The only constant is change! TheMadFool 6 Sep 2019 16 9
My hero is trying to kill us all TheMadFool 7 Sep 2019 16 7
What happened to my ignore-list? Pattern-chaser 19 Sep 2019 16 8
Would there be a God-like "sensation" in the absence of God or religion? How is this to be explained Maureen 20 Sep 2019 16 13
About the difficulty of staying present Ariel D'Leon 20 Sep 2019 16 9
Delete Profile removedmembershiprc 10 Sep 2019 15 7
A rationale to decline some Revelations. Zuhair 7 Sep 2019 14 5
Mikhail Bakhtin's Dialogic Imagination uncanni 22 Sep 2019 14 5
Almost Famous Things T_Clark 3 Sep 2019 13 4
Have you guys ever regretted falling down the rabbit hole seeing how deep it can get? Jimmy 13 Sep 2019 13 8
Paley, Hume, and the teleological argument ModernPAS 23 Sep 2019 13 8
Why general purposelessness equates to suffering through imposed output expectations schopenhauer1 6 Sep 2019 12 8
Another view of Consciousness waechter418 23 Sep 2019 12 4
The trend I'm seeing schopenhauer1 28 Sep 2019 12 6
Monotheism versus dichotomous optimistic realism. Zuhair 28 Sep 2019 12 6
Kantianism vs Deontology Zachary Beddingfield 12 Sep 2019 11 8
True Lies, Realism in cinema TheMadFool 19 Sep 2019 11 6
IQ and education Christopher 6 Sep 2019 10 6
Ontic versus ontological Daniel C 2 Sep 2019 9 7
Playfulness as more of a possibility in approaching life. Perdidi Corpus 1 Sep 2019 8 4
Freedom from Menticide Christopher 6 Sep 2019 8 4
Most Important Works in Philosophy MichaelJYoo 8 Sep 2019 8 7
Which is more difficult to learn: classical Greek or German? philosophy 13 Sep 2019 8 6
Do coriander leaves taste like soap? Wheatley 17 Sep 2019 8 4
Is this conceivable to happen, and if yes, what and how will it develop? god must be atheist 22 Sep 2019 8 6
Anthropomorphization of Reality into God, Why? BrianW 5 Sep 2019 7 6
On Virtue Ethics MrPhilosopher 8 Sep 2019 7 4
Socrates Vs Aristotle... Who Was The Better Man? PhilCF 19 Sep 2019 7 3
Nominalism thewonder 27 Sep 2019 7 5
Why Living Now Isn't Surprising: Prime Principle of Confirmation PhilosophyAttempter 30 Sep 2019 7 5
The possible deeper consequences of freedom of speech. Roel 2 Sep 2019 6 5
What distinguishes 'philosophy of religion' from 'theology' ? fresco 10 Sep 2019 6 6
Everything Exists, Even if it Doesn't Bay3z 26 Sep 2019 6 6
Why set theory is the foundation of mathematics, why not simulating real life? Zuhair 28 Sep 2019 6 2
Framing the 'Free Will' question Robert Lockhart 26 Sep 2019 5 5
Love is a transient feeling TranscendedRealms 30 Sep 2019 5 5
Indian moon shot fails Wayfarer 8 Sep 2019 4 4
Big or Small Government? An old debate between left and right KevinMcCabe 10 Sep 2019 4 4
Help with Logical Notation James Bejon 19 Sep 2019 4 2
A stupid argument for mind-body dualism TheMadFool 4 Sep 2019 3 3
Which are the sources of information that excerpt more influence over your actions and thoughts? Ariel D'Leon 7 Sep 2019 3 3
Antonio Brown, Spectacle, School Shooters a deleted account 8 Sep 2019 3 3
Are there any questions merely verbal? (Especially metaphysical questions) Eiwar 8 Sep 2019 3 3
Unoriginal Reflections Robert Lockhart 23 Sep 2019 3 3
Mind the Mind waechter418 26 Sep 2019 3 3
Why was I banned steveklinko2 1 Sep 2019 2 2
implications of free will removedmembershiprc 9 Sep 2019 2 2
Does anyone have a Degree in All or None? Yes/No? TheMadFool 11 Sep 2019 2 2
The necessity of psychopathy New2K2 16 Sep 2019 2 2
Two possibilities of human origins and its effects upon any philosophical outlook? ed lonegan 30 Sep 2019 2 2
Is it ethical to have children? Matias 1 Sep 2019 1 1
An artistic solution to the problem of evil with a little bit of free will TheMadFool 1 Sep 2019 1 1
Are we entitled to have children? petrichor 3 Sep 2019 1 1
Is Having Kids bad? elucid 10 Sep 2019 1 1
"The Ethics of Eating Meat" -- why is that a question of ethics? It's a question of kindness. god must be atheist 15 Sep 2019 1 1
The face of determinism Shamshir 18 Sep 2019 1 1
Knowledge and creativity ?? Wittgenstein 21 Sep 2019 1 1
Quotable Philosophical Quotes Daniel C 21 Sep 2019 1 1
The split between Continental and Analytic philosophy. Shawn 21 Sep 2019 1 1
Too bad "Ignore list browser extension" was closed; I was just about ready to ask why it don't work god must be atheist 24 Sep 2019 1 1
Cya! thewonder 27 Sep 2019 1 1
Causality in compatabilism Gregory 30 Sep 2019 1 1
Jordan Peterson jokes Fine Doubter 2 Sep 2019 0 0
Hegel's method Gregory 6 Sep 2019 0 0
A rationale to refuse Revelation! Zuhair 6 Sep 2019 0 0
The Infinite! In Search of The Ultimate Truth. TazAnastazio 19 Sep 2019 0 0
In The Nature of Things Robert Lockhart 21 Sep 2019 0 0
Contextualizing "belief" in/of the Edenic framework. A Gnostic Agnostic 22 Sep 2019 0 0
Wittgenstein and Education. Shawn 27 Sep 2019 0 0
Is Religious Evil a Problem for Theism? CS Stewart 29 Sep 2019 0 0

About these figures. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.