The Agora Almanac

Section 05 / Timeline / Month

October 2017

Members of The Philosophy Forum wrote 9,976 posts in October 2017: 138 opening posts and 9,838 comments, running to about 924,000 words. 145 members posted, 39 of them for the first time.

By number of posts it ranks 26th of the archive's 125 months. 138 threads were opened, and 197 threads received at least one comment.

The most active thread was The Shoutbox, with 2,011 comments in the month.

9,976
Posts
26th of 125 months
145
Members posting
39 for the first time
138
Threads opened
197 threads active
924,000
Words written
93 per post
673
Posts on the busiest day
26 October 2017

Fig. 1

Posts per day in October 2017

Days are UTC. The busiest was 26 October 2017, with 673 posts, 454 of them in The Shoutbox.

0 400 800 1 8 15 22 29

Fig. 2

Most active threads

Comments posted during October 2017, whenever the thread was opened.

  1. 1The Shoutbox2,011
  2. 2Is 'information' physical?610
  3. 3Philosophy Joke of the Day383
  4. 4The American Gun Control Debate314
  5. 5Moderation Standards Poll277
  6. 6Emergence is incoherent from physical to mental events221
  7. 7Reconciliation and Forgiveness215
  8. 8Theory of Relativity and The Law of Noncontradiction206
  9. 9#MeToo178
  10. 10Hope is the opiate of the masses!168
  11. 11Problem of Evil (Theodicy)144
  12. 12On the transition from non-life to life141
  13. 13Evidence of Consciousness Surviving the Body114
  14. 14The Last Word113
  15. 15How to determine if a property is objective or subjective?110

Fig. 3

Most active members

Posts written during October 2017.

  1. 1Agustino689
  2. 2Baden605
  3. 3Wosret524
  4. 4T_Clark454
  5. 5S396
  6. 6Michael359
  7. 7Wayfarer318
  8. 8Noble Dust303
  9. 9TimeLine301
  10. 10Hachem264
  11. 11apokrisis259
  12. 12t0m240
  13. 13Thorongil232
  14. 14MikeL220
  15. 15Sir2u214

Fig. 4

The words of October 2017

Tracked words used unusually often this month compared with the archive as a whole: used by at least five members in the month, with no one member supplying more than 35% of the uses. Larger means more distinctive; the small figure is the number of uses.

Fig. 5

138 threads opened in October 2017

138 listed

Every thread started this month, with the comments it went on to draw by the end of the archive.

The American Gun Control Debate Brian 9 Oct 2017 2,120 105
Is 'information' physical? Wayfarer 9 Oct 2017 1,576 77
Philosophy Joke of the Day T_Clark 5 Oct 2017 393 32
Moderation Standards Poll Baden 14 Oct 2017 286 28
Theory of Relativity and The Law of Noncontradiction TheMadFool 25 Oct 2017 243 22
Where Does Morality Come From? Matthew Gould 14 Oct 2017 232 24
Emergence is incoherent from physical to mental events schopenhauer1 8 Oct 2017 221 14
Reconciliation and Forgiveness TimeLine 8 Oct 2017 215 12
Problem of Evil (Theodicy) MysticMonist 6 Oct 2017 206 28
Neural Networks, Perception & Direct Realism Marchesk 30 Oct 2017 192 10
#MeToo ArguingWAristotleTiff 17 Oct 2017 181 14
Hope is the opiate of the masses! schopenhauer1 19 Oct 2017 179 18
Expressing masculinity Shawn 2 Oct 2017 117 18
Philosophical alienation Shawn 24 Oct 2017 116 17
Time, Determinism and Choice MikeL 4 Oct 2017 106 10
The tragedy of the downfall of the USA Banno 14 Oct 2017 106 23
The only moral dilemma Wosret 2 Oct 2017 103 16
Does Morality presuppose there being a human nature? bloodninja 14 Oct 2017 103 22
What makes a science a science? rickyk95 7 Oct 2017 94 11
The Moral Argument for the Existence of God cincPhil 30 Oct 2017 92 27
Godel's incompleteness theorems and implications guptanishank 30 Oct 2017 84 11
How Existential Questions are Discounted- WARNING: Adult Material schopenhauer1 4 Oct 2017 79 15
Inquisiting Agustino's Aristotelian Moral Framework VagabondSpectre 13 Oct 2017 79 14
Femtography Hachem 2 Oct 2017 77 4
Proof that a men's rights movement is needed WISDOMfromPO-MO 4 Oct 2017 77 20
What's the point of this conversation? Cabbage Farmer 18 Oct 2017 76 14
The priest and the physicist Meta 28 Oct 2017 76 14
Semiotics Killed the Cat MikeL 4 Oct 2017 75 11
Networks, Evolution, and the Question of Life Streetlight 18 Oct 2017 75 11
What is death in Heidegger's Being and Time? bloodninja 20 Oct 2017 72 8
Does Art Reflect Reality? - The Real as Surreal in "Twin Peaks: The Return" Noble Dust 15 Oct 2017 71 11
Ethics of care Shawn 16 Oct 2017 67 13
Argument against hell MysticMonist 26 Oct 2017 64 11
What does it mean to exist? MysticMonist 1 Oct 2017 62 14
Schopenhauer's Dynamite Agustino 22 Oct 2017 62 7
Presentism and ethics _db 7 Oct 2017 60 14
How does Eternalism account for our experience of time? Alec 17 Oct 2017 58 9
On Melancholy Shawn 20 Oct 2017 55 15
Deja vu Another 28 Oct 2017 54 6
A Question about Light Hachem 25 Oct 2017 53 10
The Double Slit Experiment Hachem 1 Oct 2017 52 9
Any Platonists? MysticMonist 1 Oct 2017 51 10
My OP on the Universe as a Petrol Can MikeL 12 Oct 2017 50 10
Commonplace Virtue? MysticMonist 21 Oct 2017 50 7
Does suicide and homicide have moral value? XanderTheGrey 30 Oct 2017 50 10
The morality of fantasy T_Clark 13 Oct 2017 49 13
Has 'the market' corrupted education? Shawn 28 Oct 2017 49 11
What happened to the Philosophy of Science forum? SophistiCat 14 Oct 2017 47 11
The Universe as a Gas Can - Part I: Entropy MikeL 13 Oct 2017 46 4
Is life a contradiction? TheMadFool 13 Oct 2017 44 11
New God's Existence Proof: The Paradox of Thought ThroughAGlassDarkly 16 Oct 2017 43 6
Views on the transgender movement _db 11 Oct 2017 40 17
Milgram Experiment vs Rhythm 0 TheMadFool 13 Oct 2017 40 8
Does infinity mean that all possibilities are bound to happen? Alec 13 Oct 2017 39 12
Does Man Have an Essence? anonymous66 10 Oct 2017 38 21
Defining Mysticism MysticMonist 31 Oct 2017 37 9
Blame kepler 10 Oct 2017 35 11
The value of truth TheMadFool 2 Oct 2017 34 10
Late night thoughts, well, in my timezone Cynical Eye 25 Oct 2017 34 10
Repentance? MysticMonist 4 Oct 2017 33 8
Growth Scalpounet 21 Oct 2017 33 9
Kant and lying to the murderer problem TheMadFool 5 Oct 2017 32 8
Quantum Idealism? jorndoe 10 Oct 2017 30 10
My own personal religion depression has enlightened me to TranscendedRealms 27 Oct 2017 30 6
Will there be any Fromage for Catalonia? BC 1 Oct 2017 29 9
Camera Obscura Hachem 11 Oct 2017 29 3
The morality of rationality TheMadFool 13 Oct 2017 29 9
The ontological auction Srap Tasmaner 15 Oct 2017 29 9
Setting up the perfect country... on mars? AlexiMicrowave 5 Oct 2017 28 5
Objective evidence for a non - material element to human consciousness? Robert Lockhart 12 Oct 2017 26 10
Invisible Light and Unhearable Sound? Hachem 8 Oct 2017 25 7
The Definition of the Devil TheMadFool 29 Oct 2017 25 7
The Republic Strikes Back: A Platonic Sequel MysticMonist 15 Oct 2017 23 6
Psychedelics, Hypnosis, NDE and the really real MysticMonist 26 Oct 2017 23 9
Mutually exclusive ethical ideals? jancanc 26 Oct 2017 21 3
Boris Groys on Kojeve t0m 6 Oct 2017 20 5
What happened to my thread "Is all math a lie?" Jeremiah 11 Oct 2017 20 8
Moderation Poll Standard S 15 Oct 2017 20 10
If two different truths exist that call for opposite actions, can both still be true? Mark Marsellli 2 Oct 2017 19 15
Simultaneity, Sameness, and Symmetry- or a complete lack thereof MikeL 8 Oct 2017 19 5
Open and Free discussion? Hachem 5 Oct 2017 18 6
Does the late Hugh Hefner (Playboy) deserve the excoriating editorials in the NYT? BC 2 Oct 2017 17 10
Can we be wise without a supernatural God? a deleted account 26 Oct 2017 17 7
Does Roundup (glyphosate) harm the human body? Metaphysician Undercover 14 Oct 2017 16 7
Hypothetical Hurt, Real Hurt Streetlight 10 Oct 2017 15 7
Recommend me some books please? Jamie 15 Oct 2017 15 10
Is there such a thing as a selfless act? The duke 5 Oct 2017 14 7
The Logic of the Product BC 5 Oct 2017 14 5
Semiotics Proved the Cat MikeL 7 Oct 2017 14 4
Colors for the Apollonian and Dionysian Fernando Perla 7 Oct 2017 14 7
Consumption and Capitalism: Maybe an analogy would help WISDOMfromPO-MO 12 Oct 2017 13 4
Doing the least evil Frank Barroso 6 Oct 2017 12 6
Ontological dependence and two-aspect theories of reality jancanc 18 Oct 2017 11 3
Quantitative Skepticism and Mixtures fdrake 1 Oct 2017 10 3
If science is "the asymptote of truth", what would philosophy be to truth ? Nuncaltussum 5 Oct 2017 10 9
Homework help: falsificationism and existential statements Varun Soontornniyomkij 23 Oct 2017 10 7
Paradox of fiction TheMadFool 25 Oct 2017 10 4
On Convincing Convention That It's Wrong creativesoul 10 Oct 2017 9 7
Panspermia - Life from Space Wayfarer 16 Oct 2017 9 5
An interesting account of compassion? jancanc 17 Oct 2017 9 5
What happened to Korybski's General Semantics? Shawn 20 Oct 2017 8 4
At what point is it unethical to have children? learner111 22 Oct 2017 8 8
What do we want? Robert Lockhart 2 Oct 2017 7 3
The Nobel Prize of Physics 2017 Hachem 3 Oct 2017 7 5
Which philosophical direction may be useful for explaining 'Accelerationism'? Fuji 3 Oct 2017 7 4
Could anyone help me with this exercise about arguments and explanations? Dasein 16 Oct 2017 7 4
An attempt to a physical Theory of the human Mind kayzumfelde 4 Oct 2017 6 2
Why am I interested in designing games that unify sex and psychedelia? oranssi 4 Oct 2017 6 4
Hello World MountainDwarf 5 Oct 2017 6 3
On why the safest form of AI is a simulation of the brain Shawn 8 Oct 2017 6 5
In defense of winter WISDOMfromPO-MO 10 Oct 2017 6 6
Plato's Republic Book 1 Alaina Eimas 27 Oct 2017 6 3
Daniel Dennett - From Bacteria to Bach and Back: The Evolution of Minds The Empiricist 31 Oct 2017 6 6
What is Kant's "pure practical reason" jancanc 6 Oct 2017 5 2
How did languages develop gendered words? schopenhauer1 8 Oct 2017 5 4
Light Polarization Hachem 10 Oct 2017 5 2
Should moderators enforce rules of relevance? alan1000 17 Oct 2017 5 5
For Kant, does the thing-in-itself represent the limit or the boundary of human knowledge? jancanc 20 Oct 2017 5 5
The possibility of knowledge of absolute reality Tehilla 4 Oct 2017 4 4
Kant's Subsistence and Inherence Nino Millesi 22 Oct 2017 4 2
A positive mindset/attitude is not enough TranscendedRealms 25 Oct 2017 4 4
The First Few Cognitive Steps Required to Believe in Primordial Soup Theory MikeL 4 Oct 2017 3 2
Nothing new under the Sun Robert Lockhart 9 Oct 2017 3 3
What rights do we have? Another 14 Oct 2017 3 2
What's wrong with the Steady State Theory of the Universe? BC 17 Oct 2017 3 2
Is the world around me really public? antinatalautist 20 Oct 2017 3 3
A defense and extension of W. D. Ross' ethics of prima facie duties (excerpt from my book) _db 22 Oct 2017 3 2
A Question Regarding Oxygen TheMadFool 30 Oct 2017 3 3
Help me understand Kant Mojtaba 9 Oct 2017 2 2
Learning experiences a deleted account 9 Oct 2017 2 2
Russian Philosophy - How Would You Respond? Agustino 11 Oct 2017 2 1
Are Black and White Colors? Hachem 13 Oct 2017 2 1
Good is an actual quality like water that we need to "drink" TranscendedRealms 28 Oct 2017 2 2
Gratings and Theory of Light Hachem 12 Oct 2017 1 1
The reductional Principle of natural Sciences applied to Psychology kayzumfelde 9 Oct 2017 0 0
The Soul and Plato's Eye MysticMonist 12 Oct 2017 0 0
Quarterly Fundraiser 3 Baden 14 Oct 2017 0 0
Communication - Humankind beginning Scalpounet 21 Oct 2017 0 0

About these figures. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.