The Agora Almanac

Section 01 / Members / Rankings

Member league tables

Eight ways of ranking the 4,083 members of The Philosophy Forum: by output, by length, by threads opened and by how often they answered and were answered. Each table lists the first twenty-five.

Rankings measure volume, not quality. A member who wrote little may have written well, and nothing here says otherwise.

Table 1

Most posts

Opening posts and comments together, over the whole archive.

  1. 1Banno31,280
  2. 2Wayfarer26,147
  3. 3Janus19,552
  4. 4frank19,072
  5. 5180 Proof16,469
  6. 6T_Clark16,153
  7. 7Michael15,989
  8. 8Metaphysician Undercover14,863
  9. 9BC14,464
  10. 10Hanover14,434
  11. 11Terrapin Station14,146
  12. 12Baden14,011
  13. 13TheMadFool13,954
  14. 14Shawn13,496
  15. 15creativesoul12,475
  16. 16S11,567
  17. 17Agustino11,251
  18. 18schopenhauer111,060
  19. 19Tom Storm10,917
  20. 20Isaac10,707
  21. 21NOS4A210,404
  22. 22unenlightened10,025
  23. 23Jamal10,010
  24. 24ssu9,854
  25. 25Agent Smith9,469

Table 2

Most words written

Words of their own, with quoted passages, links and markup removed.

  1. 1Metaphysician Undercover3,220,104
  2. 2Wayfarer2,838,526
  3. 3BC2,052,242
  4. 4Janus1,728,446
  5. 5apokrisis1,628,637
  6. 6Banno1,526,481
  7. 7ssu1,459,795
  8. 8schopenhauer11,412,994
  9. 9Isaac1,411,359
  10. 10Count Timothy von Icarus1,395,014
  11. 11Gnomon1,392,817
  12. 12TheMadFool1,264,327
  13. 13Hanover1,143,263
  14. 14Joshs1,096,522
  15. 15Agustino1,076,248
  16. 16boethius1,039,175
  17. 17Pierre-Normand1,022,046
  18. 18T_Clark949,692
  19. 19Michael924,052
  20. 20Philosophim913,169
  21. 21fdrake883,342
  22. 22creativesoul878,822
  23. 23Moliere868,002
  24. 24Streetlight824,206
  25. 25Mww798,429

Table 3

Most threads opened

Number of threads started.

  1. 1Shawn680
  2. 2TheMadFool451
  3. 3Benj96252
  4. 4schopenhauer1216
  5. 5TiredThinker214
  6. 6_db185
  7. 7frank158
  8. 8Wheatley149
  9. 9Jack Cummins147
  10. 10Banno133
  11. 11Agent Smith132
  12. 12Gregory132
  13. 13Wayfarer104
  14. 14Andrew4Handel99
  15. 15Art4896
  16. 16BC95
  17. 17Baden95
  18. 18Mikie95
  19. 19Streetlight92
  20. 20Pfhorrest83
  21. 21jorndoe83
  22. 22Enrique77
  23. 23thewonder75
  24. 24I like sushi73
  25. 25Caldwell72

Table 4

Longest typical post

Median words per post, among members with at least 200 posts.

  1. 1Cabbage Farmer374 posts307
  2. 2Chet Hawkins290 posts288
  3. 3Dawnstorm390 posts281
  4. 4boethius2,665 posts265
  5. 5Count Timothy von Icarus4,231 posts248
  6. 6Gnomon5,022 posts245
  7. 7dclements504 posts240
  8. 8Cartesian trigger-puppets222 posts226
  9. 9Dan235 posts221
  10. 10Congau228 posts214
  11. 11TheHedoMinimalist473 posts209
  12. 12boundless772 posts206
  13. 13noAxioms1,754 posts201
  14. 14leo895 posts201
  15. 15Astrophel665 posts190
  16. 16Antony Nickles1,444 posts184
  17. 17PossibleAaran244 posts180
  18. 18Christoffer2,495 posts176
  19. 19Anthony211 posts172
  20. 20Ludwig V2,495 posts168
  21. 21Constance1,406 posts167
  22. 22Gary M Washburn249 posts161
  23. 23Possibility2,942 posts158
  24. 24Judaka1,702 posts158
  25. 25simeonz317 posts156

Table 5

Most replied to

Times a member was quoted or replied to by someone else.

  1. 1Banno36,533
  2. 2Wayfarer34,448
  3. 3Metaphysician Undercover26,628
  4. 4Janus24,225
  5. 5Michael18,996
  6. 6frank17,564
  7. 7Isaac17,410
  8. 8Hanover17,116
  9. 9T_Clark16,140
  10. 10TheMadFool15,517
  11. 11BC14,899
  12. 12180 Proof14,752
  13. 13schopenhauer114,728
  14. 14Terrapin Station13,592
  15. 15Agustino13,105
  16. 16NOS4A213,097
  17. 17Tom Storm12,423
  18. 18Shawn12,256
  19. 19Baden12,073
  20. 20apokrisis11,977
  21. 21ssu11,848
  22. 22unenlightened11,153
  23. 23S10,977
  24. 24Jamal10,306
  25. 25creativesoul10,065

Table 6

Most replies given

Times a member quoted or replied to someone else.

  1. 1Banno33,763
  2. 2Metaphysician Undercover30,815
  3. 3Wayfarer29,719
  4. 4Janus24,432
  5. 5Isaac19,825
  6. 6T_Clark19,381
  7. 7frank19,012
  8. 8Agustino18,617
  9. 9180 Proof17,492
  10. 10Michael16,400
  11. 11TheMadFool15,957
  12. 12BC15,518
  13. 13schopenhauer115,249
  14. 14S15,122
  15. 15Terrapin Station14,498
  16. 16Tom Storm13,986
  17. 17ssu13,333
  18. 18Hanover12,773
  19. 19Joshs12,759
  20. 20Baden12,446
  21. 21apokrisis11,812
  22. 22Leontiskos11,113
  23. 23Shawn10,710
  24. 24Fooloso410,246
  25. 25khaled9,895

Table 7

Most days active

Separate days (UTC) on which the member posted at least once, out of 3,782 days in the archive.

  1. 1Metaphysician Undercover3,376
  2. 2BC3,109
  3. 3Janus2,968
  4. 4Wayfarer2,933
  5. 5Hanover2,902
  6. 6unenlightened2,762
  7. 7Banno2,667
  8. 8frank2,418
  9. 9ssu2,192
  10. 10180 Proof2,148
  11. 11Michael2,148
  12. 12Baden2,144
  13. 13schopenhauer12,025
  14. 14Gnomon2,011
  15. 15Benkei1,854
  16. 16T_Clark1,799
  17. 17jorndoe1,790
  18. 18Mww1,774
  19. 19NOS4A21,770
  20. 20praxis1,711
  21. 21Tom Storm1,647
  22. 22Jamal1,625
  23. 23Streetlight1,615
  24. 24Shawn1,574
  25. 25Joshs1,547

Table 8

Widest range of threads

Number of different threads the member commented in.

  1. 1BC3,029
  2. 2TheMadFool2,935
  3. 3Wayfarer2,920
  4. 4180 Proof2,659
  5. 5unenlightened2,267
  6. 6Banno2,036
  7. 7T_Clark1,959
  8. 8Tom Storm1,892
  9. 9Janus1,776
  10. 10Hanover1,631
  11. 11Terrapin Station1,461
  12. 12Metaphysician Undercover1,404
  13. 13Shawn1,377
  14. 14Agent Smith1,315
  15. 15frank1,242
  16. 16I like sushi1,216
  17. 17Baden1,207
  18. 18jgill1,196
  19. 19Outlander1,119
  20. 20ssu1,106
  21. 21Joshs1,064
  22. 22god must be atheist1,013
  23. 23Streetlight1,009
  24. 24Michael1,007
  25. 25javi25419971,001

About these figures. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.