Thread / opened 29 December 2021
If there is no free will, does it make sense to hold people accountable for their actions?
Opened on 29 December 2021 by T_Clark, this thread drew 122 comments from 30 members over 9 days; the last was posted on 6 January 2022.
By number of comments it ranks 1,674th of the 13,923 threads in the archive. Together its posts run to about 15,000 words, quotations excluded.
Most distinctive words: free will, determined, actions, determinism, criminal.
People
Who took part
30 members commented. The five most active wrote 54% of the comments. The 15 most active are listed. The opener added 31 comments of their own.
- 1T_Clarkopened the thread31
- 2javra12
- 3unenlightened8
- 4Raymond8
- 5BC7
- 6Janus5
- 7Tobias5
- 8Manuel5
- 9pfirefry5
- 10Reformed Nihilist4
- 11SophistiCat3
- 12Cheshire3
- 13Mww3
- 14jgill3
- 15Agent Smith3
Subject
What it was about
Tracked words used unusually often in this thread compared with the forum as a whole; larger means more distinctive, and the small figure is the number of uses.
- free will164
- determined44
- actions55
- determinism31
- criminal20
- choice41
- punishment20
- hold36
- ontic12
- freedom30
- deterministic15
- outcomes15
- tea10
- holding15
Subject mix, per 10,000 words
Thinkers named
See also
Threads on similar ground
Threads that share the most distinctive vocabulary with this one.
- Do I really have free will?96 comments, 2024
- Are we doomed to discuss "free will" and "determinism" forever?91 comments, 2018
- How to live with hard determinism69 comments, 2020
- How Do You Do Science Without Free Will?210 comments, 2019
- The Problem of 'Free Will' and the Brain: Can We Change Our Own Thoughts and Behaviour?152 comments, 2024
- Argument for deterministic free will60 comments, 2023
See also
More threads opened by T_Clark
T_Clark opened 52 threads in all; these drew the most comments.
- My favorite verses in the Tao Te Ching930 comments, 2021
- What does "real" mean?505 comments, 2022
- Beautiful Things439 comments, 2018
- What is metaphysics? Yet again.417 comments, 2021
- Philosophy Joke of the Day393 comments, 2017
- You don't need to read philosophy to be a philosopher331 comments, 2021
Record
At a glance
- Opened
- 29 December 2021 (December 2021)
- Opened by
- T_Clark
- First reply
- 20 minutes after the opening post
- Last comment
- 6 January 2022
- Comments
- 122
- Members commenting
- 30
- Words written
- 14,692 (324 in the opening post)
- Rank by comments
- 1,674th of 13,923
- Original thread
- Read it in the forum archive
About these figures. Thread titles are quoted from the archive. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.