Tracked word / rank 1,333 of 4,705
The word incoherent
Members of The Philosophy Forum used the word "incoherent" 5,540 times in their own writing: 390 members, in 1,756 threads. Over the whole archive that comes to 0.534 uses per 10,000 words, which ranks it 1,333rd of the 4,705 tracked words.
Among full calendar years its use was highest in 2016 (0.897 per 10,000 words) and lowest in 2020 (0.360). Its rate was broadly steady across the decade (0.591 per 10,000 words in 2016-19, 0.565 in 2022-25).
Most concentrated in the thread Is self creation possible?, where it appears 53 times.
Trend
Uses per 10,000 words, by quarter
How often "incoherent" was used relative to everything written that quarter, so busy and quiet periods compare fairly. The peak was Q3 2016. The last quarter ends on 25 February 2026.
People
Who used it most
Members ranked by how many times they used "incoherent" in their own words.
- 1Metaphysician Undercover572
- 2Janus377
- 3Terrapin Station288
- 4180 Proof233
- 5Bob Ross202
- 6TheWillowOfDarkness157
- 7Bartricks156
- 8AmadeusD137
- 9Joshs134
- 10Banno107
- 11Count Timothy von Icarus102
- 12Harry Hindu99
People
For whom it is most characteristic
Members who use it unusually often given how much they wrote. The bar shows how distinctive the word is of the member; the figure is their number of uses.
- 1Terrapin Station288
- 2180 Proof233
- 3Janus377
- 4Metaphysician Undercover572
- 5TheWillowOfDarkness157
- 6Bob Ross202
- 7AmadeusD137
- 8Bartricks156
- 9Harry Hindu99
- 10EricH26
Threads
Threads where it is most concentrated
Threads in which "incoherent" is used unusually often for their size. The bar shows how distinctive the word is of the thread; the figure is the number of uses in it.
- 1Is self creation possible?53
- 2If I say "I understand X" can I at the same time say "X is incoherent"?20
- 3Idealism vs. Materialism54
- 4Some remarks on Wittgenstein's private language argument (PLA)57
- 5Jesus Christ's Resurrection History or Fiction?19
- 6Coherentism21
- 7Discussion on interpreting Aquinas' Third Way15
- 8There is no difference between P-zombies and non P-zombies.22
- 910k Philosophy challenge52
- 10A Measurable Morality39
- 11Does God have free will?21
- 12Realism, Nominalism, Conceptualism and Possible Worlds14
Vocabulary
Words that keep it company
Tracked words that are distinctive of the same threads. The figure is the number of threads in which both stand out.
About these figures. Counts cover members' own words only: quoted passages, links, markup and @mentions are removed first, and a possessive "'s" is folded into the base word. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.