Thread / opened 17 April 2022
Can basic desert and retributivism be justified under Compatibilism?
Opened on 17 April 2022 by Captain Homicide, this thread drew 13 comments from 6 members over 4 days; the last was posted on 21 April 2022.
By number of comments it ranks 8,775th of the 13,923 threads in the archive. Together its posts run to 2,128 words, quotations excluded.
Most distinctive words: free will, dennett, determined, chance, pure.
People
Who took part
6 members commented. The five most active wrote 92% of the comments. The opener added 1 comment of their own.
Subject
What it was about
Tracked words used unusually often in this thread compared with the forum as a whole; larger means more distinctive, and the small figure is the number of uses.
- free will24
- dennett13
- determined16
- chance14
- pure13
- punished5
- determinism9
- punishment7
- responsibility9
- influences4
- wider4
- necessity7
- moral16
- result9
Subject mix, per 10,000 words
Thinkers named
See also
Threads on similar ground
Threads that share the most distinctive vocabulary with this one.
- Galen Strawson's Basic Argument54 comments, 2022
- Arguments for free will?173 comments, 2022
- Do we really have free will?43 comments, 2025
- How to live with hard determinism69 comments, 2020
- Are we doomed to discuss "free will" and "determinism" forever?91 comments, 2018
- If there is no free will, does it make sense to hold people accountable for their actions?122 comments, 2021
See also
More threads opened by Captain Homicide
Captain Homicide opened 15 threads in all; these drew the most comments.
- How would you respond to the trolley problem?433 comments, 2024
- Are there things that aren't immoral but you shouldn't want to be the kind of person that does them?133 comments, 2024
- Does no free will necessarily mean fatalism or nihilism?69 comments, 2024
- What are the best refutations of the idea that moral facts can't exist because it's immeasurable?56 comments, 2023
- How wealthy would the wealthiest person be in your ideal society?52 comments, 2023
- How far does the "My life or theirs" argument go?34 comments, 2024
Record
At a glance
- Opened
- 17 April 2022 (April 2022)
- Opened by
- Captain Homicide
- First reply
- 32 hours after the opening post
- Last comment
- 21 April 2022
- Comments
- 13
- Members commenting
- 6
- Words written
- 2,128 (410 in the opening post)
- Rank by comments
- 8,775th of 13,923
- Original thread
- Read it in the forum archive
About these figures. Thread titles are quoted from the archive. Everything on this page is computed from the public archive of The Philosophy Forum; quoted passages are removed before anyone's words are counted, and no post text is reproduced. See the methodology for definitions and caveats.